3 ms·
> Nuclear fuel is refined to about ~20% fissile material. Nuclear weapons typically need over 80% or 90%. Countries would need to build their own enrichment fac
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Nuclear fuel is refined to about ~20% fissile material. Nuclear weapons typically need over 80% or 90%. Countries would need to build their own enrichment facilities to bring nuclear fuel to weapons grade uranium, and then further refine that to plutonium. If they had such facilities they'd be able to refine natural uranium to weapons grade anyway.
I've wondered about that. On one hand, the reasoning above makes sense. On the other, people who know far more than I do say there is proliferation risk. I suspect there is something I don't understand.
- Manuel_D 5y agoThe proliferation risk is that countries build enrichment facilities claiming it's for nuclear electricity production, but instead used for weapons production. This can be addressed by prohibiting the construction of enrichment facilities and having countries that already possess nuclear weapons enrich fuel for other countries pro-bono.
- godelski 5y agoI think it is also worth mentioning that enrichment plants don't scale linearly. So it starts to become fairly obvious when a country is producing more enriched material than what is necessary for their energy production.
- wolverine876 5y agoThat doesn't seem to have occurred to the nuclear nonproliferation community.
- godelski 5y agoI'm not sure who you're talking about. If we're talking about nuclear scientists who are pro nonproliferation, well they're the ones who invented it. If we're talking about green peace, well, they are neither green nor peaceful.
- wolverine876 5y agoI'm learned about it from random Internet commenters who make posts that know it all, dismiss everyone else, and support it by being aggressive and obnoxious.
- godelski 5y agoWe're on HN. There are people with expertise in the field. You can also vet everything I've stated. I've linked sources and pulled from my own experience. You would not be arguing with me if this was on database processing or something computer related. But we're talking a hot topic and one that is known to be extremely complicated. Sorry that you think my education and experience in the field is dismissive of the views of someone who claims to have neither.
- underwater 5y agoThat arrangement sounds great for the countries with enrichment facilities and a raw deal for everyone else. What country would want to have that dependancy for basic energy needs?
- wolverine876 5y agoThey get fuel processing without having to develop and deploy very expensive technology, and possibly get free processing. Also, they get less nuclear proliferation, which could be existential for humanity. I believe it is in the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty or was proposed as another agreement.
- godelski 5y ago> On the other, people who know far more than I do say there is proliferation risk. Who? I mean I hear people on the news state it, but never any concerns at a certain 3 letter agencies that is not the department of education. I haven't heard a serious nuclear physicist be concerned with the Iran Deal. And when Iran broke the deal (not long ago) those same people knew it was a bluff, because Iran didn't even have the ability to produce enough enriched material to create bombs. Even running their enrichment centers at full capacity. Which btw, these enrichment centers don't scale linearly, which is why it is easy to vet through satellite photography. Weapon enrichment centers are typically kinda obvious. This may be a key part in what you aren't understanding. I also linked in another comment the Megatons to Megawatts program. You'll notice there the conversion rate of weapons material to fuel was about 30x (remember, reversing that process is not linear).
- wolverine876 5y agoEdit: After reading your other comment to me, I can see this isn't proceeding in good faith. For other people reading: I'm very well read (for an amateur) about the Iran deal, and it appeared to be accepted by experts that they could enough produce weapons-grade materials for a nuclear bomb within around a year. I don't recall anyone questioning it. The goal of the deal was to push the timeline to multiple years (if Iran violated the deal).