3 ms·
>> 3. Proliferation risk? > None? It is France. They already have nuclear weapons. But while we're talking about it, Megatons to Megawatts[2] has been the best
by wolverine876 5y ago
>> 3. Proliferation risk?
> None? It is France. They already have nuclear weapons. But while we're talking about it, Megatons to Megawatts[2] has been the best deproliferation project in history, reducing the number of nuclear warheads by over 20,000.
More nuclear trained personnel, designs, materials, and plants mean more opportunities for someone to acquire technology or materials.
- godelski 5y agoBy who? Someone not... French? I think you misunderstand both how difficult that would be to pull off and how much enriched uranium you would need for a bomb. Bombs and reactors don't use the same materials. Bombs use a shit ton more enriched materials. If you look back at that M2M page you'll notice how much highly enriched material was turned into unenriched (500 tonns -> 15000 tons, in case you didn't click). That's a pretty big differential. I'm sorry, but you're just spreading FUD. There's a reason the Iran Deal is a fine deal. But I don't expect anyone to understand this without 1) reading the fucking thing and 2) actually understanding nuclear physics and reactor design (this should be rather unsurprising, but for some reason everyone thinks they are qualified on this matter). I suspect you don't meet either qualification, given your comment.
- wolverine876 5y agoYou might be surprised to know that other people have well-studied, informed opinions that don't match yours. Have a good day!
- godelski 5y agoOf course there are. But we have to pay attention to what the community is saying in general. Consensus. To be fair, this is often hard to decipher when you aren't in said community and we are talking about a rather complicated topic ("Here be Dragons"). I mean we have "climate experts" showing up on certain news channels claiming that the IPCC reports are hogwash but we have a huge consensus in the community in general. So with the Iran deal, what do we have? Well they would have needed around 3-6mo to enrich their stockpile for enough material for a single weapon. Something they haven't done before and do not have the technology to do. Also something they did not appear to be attempting to do. But I talked about consensus. I'd say Nature is a good source for that[0]. You'll note here that Nature is talking about getting enough enriched material in months but several other news sources I looked at used the phrase "build a weapon" instead. I'd call this fear mongering and misunderstanding the science. I'm not trying to tell you that you're dumb, but rather that this is a complicated matter and that amateur levels of understanding aren't quite enough to even get the basics. I have a degree in the field, have worked in the industry and in energy departments. My level of understanding is barely enough to get the basics. I'm calling you out because we're talking about something extremely complicated that people vastly overestimate their expertise to handle. Atomic physics is not a simple thing where you can get a basic understanding through even months of googling. [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00254-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00254-7
- dang 5y agoWould you please stop breaking the site guidelines? We penalize and eventually ban accounts that post like this. I don't want to penalize or ban you, so if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules, we'd be grateful.
- dang 5y agoPlease make your substantive points without swipes, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- godelski 5y agoSorry dang. I got too heated and let my emotions get the best of me. And sorry wolverine876
- effie 5y agoMore opportunities - yes, more risk - not necessarily. Interested people already know how to build a nuclear bomb, there is very little mystery there, not much need to steal designs. The greatest risk here is someone stealing enriched fuel, because getting it is the hard part of building the nuclear bomb. If a big country like France can handle guarding hundreds of small nuclear weapons, they can certainly handle guarding nuclear fuel in small number of additional NPPs. We are not talking about building NPPs in every small town guarded by incompetent local volunteers. Trained armed personnel and accountability of processes and personnel in few facilities can prevent this risk.