6 ms·
Tim Cook: Users Who Want to Sideload Apps Can Use Android
- p49k 5y agoThey would have a stronger argument if their products were actually secure, yet we see regularly how nonresponsive and even combative Apple is with security researchers and how journalists and activists are constantly hacked due to zero-days. They have $200B in the bank, they could throw a few at building a respected security org that could eclipse efforts like Project Zero.
- havkd 5y agoI’m happy with AltStore, thank you.
- meibo 5y agoI'm not. The 7 day timeout is very annoying and the windows server is spotty, due to the need to have iCloud + iTunes installed. And to periodically reinstall them when it decides that it's time to break.
- HenryKissinger 5y agoAnd so Apple's anti-consumer, anti-freedom products continue.
- bzzzt 5y agoYou can't have everything. Giving you, but also other companies the freedom to do as they want with your phone and data could also be considered anti-consumer.
- theonemind 5y agoSideloading seems like an exotic and vaguely illicit sounding way of saying "installing applications not from Apple's app store". This is kind of the mirror image of phrasing it like "install apps without paying Apple 30%" Annoyingly, entrenched powers have the podium and often claim the prerogative of coining the terminology for the debate. Not that they don't have a somewhat defensible position in terms of security. But an effective Apple and Android smartphone duopoly hardly makes the decisions of one player some neutral "let the free market sort it out" kind of proposition.
- kazinator 5y agoTrue, but it is also a word used in the Android ecosystem which refers more or less to installing applications not from the Google Play store. I couldn't have Japanese TV service on my livingroom screen, without loading an .apk file directly from the provider onto the Android box. Tim Cook's analogies with cars, air bags and seatbelts are what is disingenuous, not so much the sideloading word, which is a foregone given. A better analogy is that the Apple car is one that refuses to take certain exits off the freeway, or shortcuts that are not charted in the guidance system.
- jnaina 5y agoIt's about choice. I'm a tech head and can easily root phones if I need to. But increasingly, the mobile phone is a key life tool and I'd rather that it works like a fully managed appliance. I'm willing to pay the Apple tax to blissfully live safely in their walled garden. Absolutely no need to wail and rant about Apple and their App Store practices constantly. Just use Android.
- lucasyvas 5y agoDo you work for Apple? "Blissfully live safely in their walled garden" I'm sorry to call you out, but this sounds ridiculous. It has nothing to do with safety. If you care about safety, you shouldn't be satisfied with a curated experience. You should demand it from the OS capabilities regardless of where the app comes from.
- asalardu2311 5y ago“ You should demand it from the OS capabilities regardless of where the app comes from.” That sounds like a quote from Tim Cook. Seriously though, if the commenter is happy with Apple and how it fits their work patterns then why do you need to call them out? I’m consistently confused about the mental horsepower spent on this debate when the solution is really simple: if you don’t like a product, don’t buy it. I think Tesla’s look lame, so I don’t own one. I don’t like Twinkies, so I don’t buy them. I guess my point is - wuu saa
- 1cvmask 5y agoI don't see any legislative resolve to this freedom to download your app anywhere but from the EU and China. Just like we have unlocked phones today as an option, we might have to travel to Europe or China in the future to get iOS devices without app locks on it.
- zibzab 5y agoI am _absolutely_ fine with apple not allowing sideloading. Call it control, or security or whatever, I am fine with it. What I _dont_ accept is a single company automatically getting 30% from every other business in the world. And I belive this is really what Tim is trying to defend, he is just using sideloading and security arguments to muddy the waters.
- perfopt 5y agoPreventing side loading allows a single company to get 30% of sales. If side loading were allowed users could purchase apps from any source they trust and make a conscious choice to install purchased apps.
- 8jef 5y agoThe security argument Apple has been spinning for so many years is a fallacy of the worst kind. Like pedling life in prison, with Uncle Tim as warden, as opposed to the so much dangerous and risky life out there, in the wild, where you can do whatever you want. Like owning a Pinephone.
- quitit 5y agoAeroplanes have still crashed since the introduction of passenger screening security measures. So since planes can still crash, we shouldn’t have airport security.
- catach 5y agoFatal car crashes happen, so seat belts and airbags are not about safety, but about control.
- 8jef 5y agoLike Apple is not the only mean for computing, aeroplanes do face competition: you can walk, drive, cycle, etc. You can also own your aeroplane if other people scare you. But the way I see it, Apple is more like one particular air company which operates aircraft without seats or windows, where customers are blindfolded, then strapped very tight on top of one another. That can be very safe travelling, and quite unpleasant at the same time.
- dandotway 5y agoIf we had Surgeon General-style warnings found on cigarette boxes applied to Apple products what would the best labels be? WARNING: Apple levies 30% App Store tax on hundreds of millions of non-wealthy individuals in order to make an elite group of AAPL stock holding billionaires even richer. WARNING: This device has no user serviceable parts and will be without security updates and repair service within 5-7 years from date of purchase. Manufacturer does not allow installing 3rd party operating systems such as Linux to extend usable device life.
- jet_32951 5y agoAnd yes, they do. The filesystem of the original ipod convinced me that Apple didn't want to build computers that played music but instead wanted to mediate their influence. A site "anythingbutipod.com" convinced me to go forward with Cowon music players. And so it goes, if you want a real pocket computer that does what you wish, it isn't apple.
- danfang 5y agoFor many (including me), Apple products are real pocket computers that do everything we wish. Apple products are built with a set purpose in mind. I couldn't care less about side-loading or hacking random software onto these devices. You can't expect products built for the masses to be suitable for a minority use case.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoBut presumably "the masses" who use Android don't do a lot of sideloading either? I mean, I doubt they're getting adb and fastboot set up. Unless we just mean they're figuring out how to install F-droid or the Amazon App Store?
- rp1 5y agoWhat about something like Fortnite? You might not personally be interested in the game, but surely you can imagine that some people might want to play it, and you can probably also imagine Epic not wanting to give Apple a 30% cut. How do you reconcile those two things?
- asalardu2311 5y agoWhy does the commenter need to reconcile this? Their desire of using Apple doesn’t mean they need to all apps to run on it. Personally, I’m not a gamer and don’t care about Fortnite availability nor their cost of doing business on Apple. If Apple banned an app I cared enough to use, I’d probably vote with my dollars and change platforms.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago
- Zababa 5y agoThe quote: > I think that people have that choice today, Andrew, if you want to sideload, you can buy an Android phone. That choice exists when you go into the carrier shop. If that is important to you, then you should buy an Android phone. From our point of view, it would be like if I were an automobile manufacturer telling [a customer] not to put airbags and seat belts in the car. He would never think about doing this in today's time. It's just too risky to do that. And so it would not be an iPhone if it didn't maximize security and privacy.
- zibzab 5y agoMaybe a better car analogy is that Apple is like an automaker who decides where their customers are allowed to drive??
- blibble 5y agoand who's allowed to sit in the car with you
- thomascgalvin 5y agoApple decides which gasoline you're allowed to use, and charges a 30% tax on it.
- throwntoday 5y agoIn your analogy Apple would be charging the gas station owner 30% not the person pumping. Why should the end-user care about developers fees? Apple built the entire ecosystem and infrastructure, they should be allowed to charge whatever they like.
- bzzzt 5y agoAdding to that, they are a middle man preventing the gas station owner to collect my number plates, bank account details and purchase data and selling those to third parties. Cutting out the middle man just gives another corporation an advantage.
- inspector-g 5y agoIf he’s so fond of user choice and isn’t using the argument disingenuously, then keep sideloading off the table but give all devs/users the choice to use a payment system other than Apple IAP - that’s the real issue for most people. If all other rules stayed the same but IAP became optional all this regulatory/PR pressure would drop to near-zero.
- smackeyacky 5y agoThanks Tim, I already was. Keep on gatekeeping for my customers and I'll keep telling them why iphones and macs are cancer.
- throwntoday 5y agoAnd they will keep on buying Apple products.
- Yaa101 5y agoPeople keep smoking too...
- nickm12 5y agoAt the advent of the iPhone, I was 100% all-in on the Apple ecosystem. However, the lack of sideloading pushed me to Android and over time I've become more and more satisfied with that choice, even though I rarely sideload applications. I want my operating system vendor to protect me by building in strong, granular controls over my software and making it easy for me as a user to control my application software. Apple has done that with iOS (yay!) but those capabilities have little to do with the App Store review process, which is used to collect rent and block competitors to their services business model. Apple leadership continues to be disingenuous in conflating these two things.
- dann0 5y agoAgain with the automatic Apple hate! Incredible. No one is making you buy an Apple device. Cook just told you to not buy an Apple device if you don’t like the trade offs they make. But of course, your personal purchase decision is the only true and valid option for everyone in every situation. The people that are complaining the loudest are the people that don’t even use Apple devices.
- rasz 5y agoApple is porting Android to iPhones? Neat!
- ciwolsey 5y agoI have both options on Android. I can sideload or not sideload. On iOS I only have one choice..
- culopatin 5y agoIf Android could make a cross platform app to work like handoff and airdrop then I would go back.