4 ms·
What is a search engine? What is the scope of the data that you search? Who is the customer? Google has made these decisions. 1. The customer is the advertise
by dragontamer 5y ago
What is a search engine? What is the scope of the data that you search? Who is the customer?
Google has made these decisions.
1. The customer is the advertisement companies. This is where Google gets their money from, and therefore is the primary customer.
2. Advertisements, SEO, and information from across the "free web" is collated into one simple to use source (just a "textbox" and one button). The simplest interface you can possibly get.
----------
For a new search engine to outcompete Google, it must change either #1 or #2. Changing #2 seems difficult, but maybe its not so insurmountable? StackOverflow has shown how "tags" can be added to a search for example. I also am old enough to remember "web directories", which was more like a filesystem / phonebook representation of the internet.
But ultimately, the big benefit of search is determining the scope of #1: who is the customer, and how do you get money from them?
----------
People may say that "Search Engines" don't have room for innovation anymore, but frankly, I personally have seen the rise of Search Engines over the past 20 years.
* Wolfram Alpha -- An odd thing to call a "search engine", but it really is one. Searches upon mathematical encyclopedias, and a strong focus on mathematical formulas. I'd definitely call it successful in its corner of the internet.
* Tagging-engines -- The tagging system is moderated by humans. And then humans add/remove data to the tags. Moderators tightly control the tags to ensure that they remain useful (ex: If someone mis-tagged C++ on a Java question on StackOverflow, a human has to come by and fix it later).
But tagging systems are "easy" to moderate, and the job of the community is farmed out. You can imagine that a tagging engine is a community platform where the work is distributed among the whole community, and am moderation system exists to build up trust.
Ultimately: tagging-engines have a search-engine like interface, but the human-element to curate and organize the information is clearly a good model.
--------
I'd say tagging-engines have had the biggest rise in the past 10 years, not only StackOverflow, but many communities seem to be tagging their own data someway / somehow. The moderation team is the product really, even if the moderation team has been recruited from the community. "Crowd Sourcing" at its finest.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI think there's quite a lot of ways you can change both #1 and #2. #1: Search engines are cheap enough to operate that you can run them non-profit, for community benefit. The "customer" can be the public good. #2: Even sticking to the free web, depending on how you adjust the ranking algorithms can significantly impair the effectiveness of SEO.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]