6 ms·
It seems that this is approximately how much they spend each year and have ~500 staff. I like Wikipedia but does it really take that many people and that much
by colechristensen 5y ago
It seems that this is approximately how much they spend each year and have ~500 staff.
I like Wikipedia but does it really take that many people and that much money to run it?
Having grown with startups from a very early stage to mid-stage, it seems pretty clear that 500 people never do 10x as much as 50 people, more like 2x if that.
That much spend seems unsustainable long term.
- ZetaZero 5y ago> I like Wikipedia but does it really take that many people and that much money to run it? It takes a lot of people and money to raise $150m/year ;->
- belval 5y agoAccording to their 2019/2020 statement they spend 5M$ in "donation processing" and an additional 5M$ in wages for the donation campaigns. 10M$ in expenses to get 120M$ really isn't so bad. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f7/Wikimedia_Foundation_FY2019-2020_Audit_Report.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f7/Wikim...
- bashmack 5y agoI wonder if that also includes all the work done simply to figure out the best way to solicit for donations?
- ZetaZero 5y agoThanks! I checked on Charity Nav https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/200049703 https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/200049703 It says they spend 9 cents to raise every dollar, almost exactly your numbers. Overall, they are rated superbly.
- squarefoot 5y ago> I like Wikipedia but does it really take that many people and that much money to run it? Just take a look at how fast people around the globe are editing it. https://wikistream.toolforge.org/ https://wikistream.toolforge.org/ Not that I like those tactics to beg for money but, yes, keeping it running while ensuring accuracy requires a lot of staff.
- bashmack 5y agoKeeping Wikipedia accurate is the volunteer's job. You can tell by how easy it is to find errors.
- charles_f 5y agoBetween content moderation, dev, security, infrastructure and such, then the support needed, I can easily see how Wikipedia can grow to 500 people. They're offering a stable product that has a presence in almost _every country in the world_, serving an insane volume of data. This is not a random startup, I'm actually amazed they pull it out with just 500 people
- tablespoon 5y ago> Between content moderation....I can easily see how Wikipedia can grow to 500 people. IIRC, nearly 100% of all content moderation is done by Wikipedia volunteer editors, so that's not actually an operational expense of theirs.
- Beldin 5y agoTrue, but I don't think you can keep the volunteers if you're in maintenance mode. The scale of volunteers needed requires some responsiveness, some support.
- tablespoon 5y ago> True, but I don't think you can keep the volunteers if you're in maintenance mode. The scale of volunteers needed requires some responsiveness, some support. Some, but not much I'd wager. My point is it's not like they have a big line item for paying full-time 100 moderators or something, so "moderation" doesn't belong with the other items on that list.
- bashmack 5y agoIt's the best kept secret of Wikipedia that the volunteers generally despise the Foundation, and their long history of being unresponsive to their concerns and slow to act on their priorities while forcing the volunteers to adapt to what the Foundation finds things to spend all this money on, is a big reason for it.
- bmhin 5y agoThere has been some concern about their inflating spending for a while. I'm honestly not well versed in if this is some potential disaster or problem like it can be made out to be, but it does seem like Wikimedia will generally find ways to spend money they get, whether it's a good use of the funds or not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_C...
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoIt's one of the most visited site on the planet, and people are constantly writting on it. It's on the same scale of facebook, youtube or twitter, activity wise. And I wager those sites have more than 500 people working on them, for a lot more money. And they are for profit!
- Thaxll 5y agoSame scale? We're talking about almost static pages, with some videos / audio. At heart wikipedia is very simple and did not changed much from 15 years ago.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoFor comparison, OpenStreetMap has roughly $800k in reserves and their expenses are a couple hundred thousands dollars per year. I agree there are probably more justifiable expenses at Wikimedia than that, but that there is a middle ground between the high water mark they're targeting and what other non-profits are operating with. The Internet Archive's annual budget is ~$10 million. EDIT: @dylan604 (replying here due to HN throttling): Section 230 shields Wikipedia from most liability/exposure: https://www.eff.org/issues/cda230/successes/wikipedia https://www.eff.org/issues/cda230/successes/wikipedia
- dylan604 5y agoWhat's the legal expenses associated with Wiki? I could see some people wanting to sue for information linked to/about them. OSM probably doesn't have that same type of exposure.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoAlexa rank for wikipedia is 13, OSM is 4550. It's not on the same planet. No, not on the same galaxy. Wikipedia is not only read and written by the entire planet of humans, including the smallest 3rd world countries, it's also a bot feast, and busy powering APIs all over the world. It got hundreds of links in some articles, which are automatically connected to all other articles in a gigantic graph of data. Oh, each article may also exist in a hundred languages, times each version, thanks to the history of all edits ever performed or suggested. It's not just links though, now articles have plenty of metadata that generate connections, tables, ranks, toc, indexes, hierarchies, and listings as well. All that is edited, rollbacked, debated, diffed and rendered almost on the fly for millions of articles, while respecting the permission system, and of course, the fun part, detecting the thousands of attempt at abuses by second. In the blink of an eye. Because wikipedia is _fast_. It's one of the fastest site around. Of course now it is also serving billions of images, sounds and videos. And the foundation is also maintaing: MediaWiki Meta-Wiki Wikibooks Wikidata Wikinews Wikiquote Wikisource Wikispecies Wikiversity Wikivoyage Wiktionary Not to mention animating workshops all around the globes, helping NGO to provide offline wikipedias for poor countries and providing and maintaining the wiki as FOSS.
- zitterbewegung 5y agoWith an Alexa rank of 13 and very real competitors that are large tech companies (every search engine now tries to answer your question instead of presenting Wikipedia anymore) seems to be quite appropriate to me.
- moralestapia 5y ago>I like Wikipedia but does it really take that many people and that much money to run it? Maybe we could ask Mozilla. /s At least Wikipedia is not actively working on sabotaging their flagship product.
- bashmack 5y agoI wouldn't be so sure. Many flagship software projects launched the Foundation have been greeted with outright hostility by the volunteer community, precisley because they don't seem to be of much use, and in some case often hamper, the basic task of writing and maintaining English Wikipedia.