Okay I think I understand now where you're coming from and it was answered somewhere else in this discussion: when we receive a weird requirement we can ask for

Okay I think I understand now where you're coming from and it was answered somewhere else in this discussion: when we receive a weird requirement we can ask for confirmation and clarifications and even express disagreement, but we will implement it after all that. Anything else would be at least disingenuous, if not worse.