2 ms·
but no, not really? you could duplicate media since the days of the compact cassette, but we had several decades where people weren't losing their minds and cre
by gruez 5y ago
but no, not really? you could duplicate media since the days of the compact cassette, but we had several decades where people weren't losing their minds and creating music NFTs. The craze over scarcity for digital media was entirely a phenomena that appeared in the past few years.
- mcintyre1994 5y agoHow does DRM fit into this? Isn't that kind of an attempt to make digital media scarce? It's just that NFTs are using technology that wasn't available when Sony had to install rootkits to try to achieve something like the same thing.
- jtbayly 5y agoNo. DRM is literally the attempt to block right-clicking. NFTs don't try to block it.
- gruez 5y ago>How does DRM fit into this? Isn't that kind of an attempt to make digital media scarce? Not really? There's a song on itunes for $0.99. No matter how many copies you buy, there's still going to be the song available. They're definitely restricting access, but it's an entirely different dynamic from limited edition trading cards, or signed vinyl records. That's why an vintage record can fetch hundreds of dollars on the secondary market, but good luck selling that mp3 you got from itunes in the early 2000s.
- bhaak 5y agoCompact cassettes were not a lossless medium. The DAT cassette was fought against with tooth and nail. The CD was okay as a read only medium. Look how long it took for the music industry to accept DRM free audio formats. Without Apple's dominance we probably wouldn't still have them now. The web had from the beginning the problem of monetizing digital content that you just could right-click and download.
- gruez 5y ago> Compact cassettes were not a lossless medium. The DAT cassette was fought against with tooth and nail. The CD was okay as a read only medium. even if we accept that, that still means we had more than 3 decades of limitless duplication, yet people aren't "lose their minds and bend their whole will toward reintroducing scarcity by any means possible". >Look how long it took for the music industry to accept DRM free audio formats. Without Apple's dominance we probably wouldn't still have them now. 1. DRM realistically wasn't an issue due to pirates (remember naptster?) 2. games have DRM that are sometimes unbroken for years. Yet nothing noticeable changes when the DRM is finally broken. there's also DRM-free games, that people aren't clamoring for scarcity over. therefore I doubt something being DRM protected or not has any effect on its scarcity value.
- bhaak 5y agoWe didn't have 30 years of limitless duplication. You're overestimating how many people were online in the 90s. Look at the graphs from this article: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/visualizing-40-years-of-music-industry-sales/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/visualizing-40-years-... I'm actually surprised that the music industry revenue went down that fast in the 2000s. I would have guessed it took a little bit longer. So going by those figures, we had 20 years of limitless duplication and it utterly destroyed the revenue of the music industry. Exactly what they feared would happen if there was ever a digital writable medium to play music from. NFTs are not DRM. They produce scarcity in a different way than DRM does. They don't encrypt digital content, they sign it. Without additional support from websites or physical venues this doesn't do anything. This could e.g. be something like a Twitter checkmark for a NFT profile or being allowed to a special club only if you own a certain kind of NFT.
- gruez 5y ago>So going by those figures, we had 20 years of limitless duplication and it utterly destroyed the revenue of the music industry. Exactly what they feared would happen if there was ever a digital writable medium to play music from. right, but that's more of a economics issue (ie. how content creation would be funded) than GP's claim of "people who are forced to reckon with the concept of infinite abundance lose their minds and bend their whole will toward reintroducing scarcity by any means possible.". >NFTs are not DRM. They produce scarcity in a different way than DRM does. the NFT equivalent in ye olden days would be signed records/cds/posters. they have similar characteristics to NFTs (scarcity, bragging rights, etc.), but people aren't "losing their minds" over them. I haven't heard owners of signed records making fun of napster/itunes users for "right-clicker mentality" or whatever.