4 ms·
It says a lot about human society that as soon as we manage to abolish scarcity for a particular class of goods, people who are forced to reckon with the concep
by kibwen 5y ago
It says a lot about human society that as soon as we manage to abolish scarcity for a particular class of goods, people who are forced to reckon with the concept of infinite abundance lose their minds and bend their whole will toward reintroducing scarcity by any means possible.
- jareklupinski 5y agoFrom article: > In this term we have a microcosm of the entire philosophical debate surrounding NFTs we'll come up with any reason that lets us shoot the sht about it endlessly :)
- gruez 5y agobut no, not really? you could duplicate media since the days of the compact cassette, but we had several decades where people weren't losing their minds and creating music NFTs. The craze over scarcity for digital media was entirely a phenomena that appeared in the past few years.
- mcintyre1994 5y agoHow does DRM fit into this? Isn't that kind of an attempt to make digital media scarce? It's just that NFTs are using technology that wasn't available when Sony had to install rootkits to try to achieve something like the same thing.
- jtbayly 5y agoNo. DRM is literally the attempt to block right-clicking. NFTs don't try to block it.
- gruez 5y ago>How does DRM fit into this? Isn't that kind of an attempt to make digital media scarce? Not really? There's a song on itunes for $0.99. No matter how many copies you buy, there's still going to be the song available. They're definitely restricting access, but it's an entirely different dynamic from limited edition trading cards, or signed vinyl records. That's why an vintage record can fetch hundreds of dollars on the secondary market, but good luck selling that mp3 you got from itunes in the early 2000s.
- bhaak 5y agoCompact cassettes were not a lossless medium. The DAT cassette was fought against with tooth and nail. The CD was okay as a read only medium. Look how long it took for the music industry to accept DRM free audio formats. Without Apple's dominance we probably wouldn't still have them now. The web had from the beginning the problem of monetizing digital content that you just could right-click and download.
- gruez 5y ago> Compact cassettes were not a lossless medium. The DAT cassette was fought against with tooth and nail. The CD was okay as a read only medium. even if we accept that, that still means we had more than 3 decades of limitless duplication, yet people aren't "lose their minds and bend their whole will toward reintroducing scarcity by any means possible". >Look how long it took for the music industry to accept DRM free audio formats. Without Apple's dominance we probably wouldn't still have them now. 1. DRM realistically wasn't an issue due to pirates (remember naptster?) 2. games have DRM that are sometimes unbroken for years. Yet nothing noticeable changes when the DRM is finally broken. there's also DRM-free games, that people aren't clamoring for scarcity over. therefore I doubt something being DRM protected or not has any effect on its scarcity value.
- bhaak 5y agoWe didn't have 30 years of limitless duplication. You're overestimating how many people were online in the 90s. Look at the graphs from this article: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/visualizing-40-years-of-music-industry-sales/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/visualizing-40-years-... I'm actually surprised that the music industry revenue went down that fast in the 2000s. I would have guessed it took a little bit longer. So going by those figures, we had 20 years of limitless duplication and it utterly destroyed the revenue of the music industry. Exactly what they feared would happen if there was ever a digital writable medium to play music from. NFTs are not DRM. They produce scarcity in a different way than DRM does. They don't encrypt digital content, they sign it. Without additional support from websites or physical venues this doesn't do anything. This could e.g. be something like a Twitter checkmark for a NFT profile or being allowed to a special club only if you own a certain kind of NFT.
- jerf 5y agoI think that's the most interesting take on the whole NFT phenomenon I've seen. Is the whole thing a real-world manifestation of a large group of people's inability to subconsciously accept infinite abundance of digital goods? I don't know if that's true, but it's interesting.
- mananaysiempre 5y ago... There’s a thing called “conspicuous consumption”, and it’s apparently old as the hills (are there any pol sci people here who actually know this stuff and can tell me I got everything backwards?). That NFTs are indeed it is a good point and I appreciate the insight, but in view of the aforementioned hills the remaining commentary about modern first-world humans seems unfounded.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agohttps://standardebooks.org/ebooks/thorstein-veblen/the-theory-of-the-leisure-class https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/thorstein-veblen/the-theor... Book that introduced the phrase.
- killtimeatwork 5y agoI'm not sure it's conspicuous consumption. Cases of recent pure conspicuous consumption in the tech world, such as the "diamond app" (an iOS app that displays a diamond and costs couple thousand dollars) didn't really catch on that much. I think what's really driving NFTs is: 1. Speculation. People just see it as another asset class that can be blown up and sold to the greater fool. 2. Artists trying to monetize their digital work this way. Up until NFTs arrived, digital art had very little market value (due to ability to make indistinguishable copies of the original at zero cost). Some artists hope that the NFTs will be the vehicle which allows them to cash on their digital work. 3. Money laundering and similar usual suspects.
- jerf 5y agoI think you're right that that is a related concept, but I don't think it makes this uninteresting, I think it is perhaps exactly why it's interesting. It is precisely that it isn't "conspicuous consumption"... it's conspicuous, but it isn't consumption. The NFT "owners" are bothered because they've engaged in this conspicuous consumption, but then aren't reaping the benefits they expected because the thing wasn't consumed. They consumed the thing, but what's this, so are other people! That's not part of the deal! I think you've sharpened the interestingness, not removed it.
- acdha 5y agoI see it more as another instance of the rent-seeking instinct. There’s a ton of capital seeking reliable returns and most of the blockchain buzz has been based on the idea that people with lots of capital can buy in early so everyone else will be forced to pay them an ever-increasing premium just to be able to make transactions. NFTs are a way to generate the demand they’re counting on — scarcity is part of the sales pitch to keep buyers from asking whether they’re actually getting much for their money.
- gruez 5y ago>most of the blockchain buzz has been based on the idea that people with lots of capital can buy in early so everyone else will be forced to pay them an ever-increasing premium just to be able to make transactions So you think NFTs are a plot by people to drive up ETH gas fees?
- acdha 5y agoI think there are a ton of people who see a huge amount of money piled into cryptocurrencies which have not seen much adoption and are trying to come up with things which could give normal people a need to start using it. NFTs are just part of the larger frenzy trying to be the one who finds a winning combination. If you recall, that first big NFT sale was when a major Ethereum holder paid a lot of money for an NFT but not the rights to one of Beeple’s paintings. That lead to a ton of free advertising, and since this was all paper money based on a fraction of their total Ethereum holdings I’m sure they were expecting the cost to be outweighed by the increased demand for their remaining tokens.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIs there a readable summary of this NFT thing. I was only vaguely following it but assumed it was some way to support artists, kind of like rich people getting a hospital wing named after your family trust fund. Not great, as you don't want to rely on philanthropy of the super rich, but probably better than many of the alternatives. But is the idea to generate a secondary market for this stuff and sell it on at higher prices?
- zrobotics 5y agoThe second option, unfortunately. Most people on art communities are pissed off at the whole NFT thing, it really doesn't help artists much. First, anyone can generate a NFT, so there's no guarantee that the artist is even involved with the token. Second, creating a NFT costs ethereum, so it's totally possible to spend money creating one that turns out to be worthless. Third, most of the 'art' associated with the valuable NFTs is procedurally generated crap, so it's fairly obvious that the buyers are mostly interested in speculation.