3 ms·
Yeah, but I can’t sell you the PDF because I can’t prove that I’m selling only to you. That makes the PDF useless to sell on. An example of something is the fa
by renewiltord 5y ago
Yeah, but I can’t sell you the PDF because I can’t prove that I’m selling only to you. That makes the PDF useless to sell on.
An example of something is the fact that I am a vim donor and a neovim initial backer. I really like that I’m in backers.md. If they would have handed out NFTs for backing, I would have loved that too.
- captn3m0 5y agoThe artist could publish a git repo with all the signatures? We already solved this problem with Cert Transparency in PKI. None of this needs a energy-hungry blockchain.
- renewiltord 5y agoAh but I can’t transfer it without the artist having to be involved. And so, in practice, I can’t transfer it because that adds too much trouble for them.
- captn3m0 5y agoYou could sign it forward. Slightly harder to validate, but maybe if the original PDF included your key - that should maintain a clear chain of custody on the PDF itself.
- renewiltord 5y agoOh for sure. And the existence of the signed on copy with a timestamp can invalidate later signed copies, etc. This is just a mechanism that provides that in a general way. It’s sort of like, how, before Uber you could call up the few cabbies you had who you liked and get a ride but having Uber was a game changer anyway because the friction fell below some threshold.
- thephyber 5y agoNFTs aren't a novel solution to digital signatures. They do leave a public audit trail in the blockchain/ledger, so potential buyers can know how many authorized copies of the asset there are (at least on a given NFT platform). That is generally an improvement over baseball cards (which may not have accurate manufacturer-supplied print counts). Personally, the only value NFTs currently provide in addition to say PGP/GPG digital signatures are features similar to joining a country club. When you buy the right NFT, you can opt to schmooze with other owners of that class of asset (celebrities, sports stars, etc). I suspect governance or additional smart contract features will provide more benefits in the future, but they may also come with SEC/CFTC oversight so they may also come with more drawbacks.