4 ms·
"The République is universal and therefore spans the entire planet." That's a strange interpretation. Regarding elections the key is that the French Republic
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
"The République is universal and therefore spans the entire planet."
That's a strange interpretation.
Regarding elections the key is that the French Republic put a very strong emphasize on equality among citizens. So all citizens should be represented in Parliament and all citizens have the right to vote for the President.
- southerntofu 5y ago> the French Republic put a very strong emphasize on equality among citizens That's a strange interpretation. France is one of the countries with the highest levels of inequalities, and one of the most racist countries on earth where even little girls can't be allowed into school if they display signs of muslim worship (but a christian cross is fine). Also, many people who reside in France are denied citizenship. > So all citizens should be represented in Parliament The french electoral system was precisely designed to prevent actual representation of the people which was deemed too dangerous by the elites of the 18th century. The 5th republic famously does not have proportional elections, so you end up with a notable part of the population not being represented at all, which arguably favors the far-right in their political agenda of pretending they're being oppressed (despite them having cultural hegemony across the political landscape). > all citizens have the right to vote for the President Yet only few can run for president. And even if you vote, what's it gonna change? The president is not bound by law to any electoral promise, has immunity from all corruption investigation, and has absolute powers.
- Veen 5y ago> where even little girls can't be allowed into school if they display signs of muslim worship That's only racist if it discriminates against a particular group. It doesn't. Little girls can't wear crucifixes and little boys can't wear the kippah either. You seem to think that Muslims should be exempted, but why should they get special treatment? They're expected to adhere to France's secular approach to public institutions the same as everyone else.
- southerntofu 5y ago> That's only racist if it discriminates against a particular group. Agreed. > Little girls can't wear crucifixes and little boys can't wear the kippah either. From what i've witnessed when i was working in schools, and what i heard from various kids i "tutor", i can assure you that's not the case. Even teachers get away with wearing a christian cross because they are not the ones targeted with this law. > France's secular approach I'm ok with secularism. It means you can have any beliefs and the State should not oppress/discriminate you for what you believe or don't believe. The State is supposed to be neutral in such manners, as explained in the 1905 law. However, since the 80's the French state is clearly not neutral and is redefining "laïcité" as a tool of oppression against muslims which does not apply to other religions. I would recommend you read the 1905 law to understand how the meaning of the word has been deformed by a far-right agenda.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe state does not oppress muslims, please stop making these ridiculous claims in all your comments. The law as it stands is that no overly visible religious symbols can be worn in state schools and what has happened is that a minority of muslims have decided to challenge this by sending girls wearing hijabs to school. By law it is fine to wear a discrete cross, star of David, crescent, whatever as a necklace. There is nothing oppressive or far-right there. It's not the attitude of the French state that has changed but the attitude of a minority towards secular French society.
- southerntofu 5y ago> The state does not oppress muslims In France, yes of course. And it's not exactly a new thing. In several colonies, the "indigenous" used to have a special non-citizen status such as "Français Musulman d'Algérie". As part of the colonial enterprise, France ran "unveiling campaigns" for muslim women [0]. Lately, the laws against religious symbols claim all religions are treated equally, but: - they are advertised as a means to fight against islamic terrorism (apparently a piece of cloth is terrorist propaganda in some people's views), therefore explicitly targeting islam - as another commenter pointed out, wearing a christian cross around your neck would very rarely if ever get you into trouble; many people in France will defend the idea that it's not the same, because France supposedly has judeo-christian roots [1] Likewise, the laws against covering your face in public space voted under Sarkozy did not mention islam; however the entire campaign and debate around them was centered on veiled muslim women as islamist propagandist and potential terrorist. If you don't think that's a fair interpretation (???), the burkini case [2] is even more obvious and more widely documented in the english-speaking world. The ban of young muslim girls from schools started in the 80s with "far-left" (marxist-leninist) teachers whose anti-religious ideas led them to battle for young girls to be kicked out of school. The excellent documentary "Un racisme à peine voilé" [3] from 2004 explains the roots of this topic uniting some parts of the far left and most of the far right, and the logical fallacy behind their reasoning: - the teachers painted these young girls as victims of islamic indoctrination and male domination, so they need access to secular public education to become free individuals - because they're refusing to remove their clothing, we'll get kicked them out of school so they don't receive education and remain "victims" of islamic patriarchy [4] This also raises the question: who does our body belong to? By claiming to prevent muslim patriarchs from controlling women's bodies, we end up giving power to the police to control women's bodies. How is a morality police requiring you get more cloth (such as in Iran) any different from a morality police requiring you remove more cloth (like in France)? In both cases, the patriarchal establishment has empowered an armed force to dictate women's clothing. In 2005, after the police hunted down two innocent teenagers (Zyed & Bouna, who were coming back home from a football game during ramadan) until they died in an electric power station [5], there were huge riots across France to denounce police brutality and racism. The population was upset because not only did the police generate this situation, but when they saw the young people climb into the power station, instead of calling for electrical/medical help (there were safety procedures available to shut down the station), they called for police reinforcements and made jokes about them dying on the radio with their colleagues; the two youngsters died 10 minutes later. Three days later, just as the riots were cooling down, the police in Clichy-sous-Bois threw a teargas canister inside a local mosque [6], triggering a new wave of outrage and riots. We could take a long time to discuss the racist doctrines permeating french public life, the emergence of the "great replacement" [7] far-right narrative in public discourse and how it fueled terrorist actions across the globe [8], how public television gave tribune to Eric Zemmour for years to spill his racism over the air (until he defended the idea of deporting muslims from France [9]), how the attacks on Charlie Hebdo and Hyper Cacher fueled a new wave of islamophobic attacks and further entrenched the far-right ("riposte laïque") definition of secularism as absence of religion (not neutrality of State in matters of religion as was the original definition) in public State discourse and proposed laws, etc. But i'm no historian and i've given you enough to read so let's just take a minute to mention recent developments. The french government has banned (without a decision from a judge) a french human-rights non-profit providing legal council and information of anti-muslim discrimination and hate crimes (CCIF) [10]. The government also closed down (without a decision from a judge) dozens of mosques [11] across France. We've been here before in history. Please read about the 1930s in Europe and how Jews were treated, and take lessons from the past so we don't end up in a new genocide. In particular, you can see how left-wing anti-clericals were mostly insensitive to the oppression of Jews because it was about "religion not race". History repeats itself. The "Islamophobia in France" [12] page in Wikipedia is very incomplete. I hope we can find time to improve it. [0] https://fpif.org/deep-colonial-roots-frances-unveiling-muslim-women/ https://fpif.org/deep-colonial-roots-frances-unveiling-musli... [1] That's arguably true, if we put aside the fact that the catholic church systematically oppressed and eradicated all other cultures and religions for centuries (except for the jews, who apart from specific periods of extermination, were discriminated from most jobs but were not assimilated into christianity). [2] https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/can-europe-make-it/defending-indefensible-france-burkini-affair-and-further-mainstre/ https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/can-europe-make-it/defendin... [3] https://invidious.fdn.fr/watch?v=6lPxYYmio38 https://invidious.fdn.fr/watch?v=6lPxYYmio38 [4] I personally don't agree with this interpretation that all veiled women are victims of the patriarchy; it defies my experiences exchanging and engaging in political activities with veiled muslim women, many of whom identify with feminist politics [5] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2005/11/14/timeline-france-riots/ https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2005/11/14/timeline-france-ri... [6] https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/3507-the-colonial-gas-machine-teargas-grenades-secular-humanist-police-and-the-intoxication-of-racialized-lives https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/3507-the-colonial-gas-machi... [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Replacement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Replacement [8] https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/16/the-inspiration-for-terrorism-in-new-zealand-came-from-france-christchurch-brenton-tarrant-renaud-camus-jean-raspail-identitarians-white-nationalism/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/16/the-inspiration-for-ter... [9] https://www.rt.com/news/216703-television-muslims-deported-france/ https://www.rt.com/news/216703-television-muslims-deported-f... [10] https://blogs.cuit.columbia.edu/rightsviews/2021/05/14/macron-laicite-and-a-fight-for-the-rights-of-french-muslims/ https://blogs.cuit.columbia.edu/rightsviews/2021/05/14/macro... [11] https://www.rt.com/news/508562-france-76-mosques-closure-darmanin-extremism/ https://www.rt.com/news/508562-france-76-mosques-closure-dar... [12] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamophobia_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamophobia_in_France
- wyoh 5y ago> France is one of the countries with the highest levels of inequalities France has a Gini coefficient in line with other OECD countries. > one of the most racist countries on earth Citation needed. > even little girls can't be allowed into school if they display signs of muslim worship I don't see how that's racist. No religious symbol are allowed in school, even christian cross are banned. > many people who reside in France are denied citizenship Why would residing in a country grant you citizenship?
- southerntofu 5y ago> France has a Gini coefficient in line with other OECD countries. We could debate whether Gini is a good measurement, but we'll probably agree that in any case it could be better? We have resources to house and feed all, yet people die from cold/heat on the streets or from lack of food, in france, in 2021. >> one of the most racist countries on earth > Citation needed. I don't have a scientific measurement of it. However, it's not exactly a secret France has a long history of colonization and racial hierarchies, and using "women's rights" as a decoy for oppressing foreign people. So not only it's racist, but it's not "just" lightweight xenophobia as you would find in many places. As for a direct quote saying France is the most racist country on Earth, i would refer to this short documentary about the struggles of undocumented people: https://youtube.com/watch?v=MMgxpU5Jyv4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=MMgxpU5Jyv4 (to watch with your favorite invidious instance) EDIT: There was also a nationwide debate about a decade ago about removing equality of races from the constitution, arguably because since races don't exist biologically they should not be mentioned. That should be a redflag. > I don't see how that's racist. No religious symbol are allowed in school, even christian cross are banned. Denying people their identity is racist. Or fascist, whichever you prefer. Also, on paper, no religious symbols are allowed, but in practice christian symbols are widely accepted and only muslim symbols cause "problems". That's what's especially racist about it. Laïcité (secularism) is the principle which states the State cannot mandate what you must or must not believe. Under pressure from the "far left" (teachers unions) and the far right ("ripost laïque", "génération identitaire"), the word has been redefined to mean that you cannot have displays of religion in public spaces (unless they're christian displays). That's the exact opposite of the content/spirit of the 1905 law of separation of Church and State which i strongly recommend you to read. The documentary "Un racisme à peine voilé" may also offer you some perspectives on this topic to see beyond the newspeak. > Why would residing in a country grant you citizenship? It's in the etymology: citizenship is derived from the "city" where you reside, unless you're a slave in which case you don't have such status. It's only natural that you enjoy political rights wherever you live your life, don't you think? Most countries have provisions for granting citizenship to foreigners. The french conditions are tough and require to know quite a lot about the (imperial, not popular) history of France and show allegiance to the authoritarian principles of the State typical of a far-right agenda. As a french person with anarchist politics, i could not pass the test (same goes with many other french people).
- ldng 5y ago>> the French Republic put a very strong emphasize on equality among citizens > That's a strange interpretation. France is one of the countries with the highest levels of inequalities, and one of the most racist countries on earth where even little girls can't be allowed into school if they display signs of muslim worship (but a christian cross is fine). Also, many people who reside in France are denied citizenship. It is not an interpretation, it is the law that you are either genuinely misunderstanding or knowingly misrepresenting. Most of the time, those misrepresenting it do have an agenda. The French Republic respect every religion and THUS disallow active proselytism within its institutions PRECISELY to enforce respect of EVERYONE'S freedom of religion choice. And, no a christian cross is not, by law, allowed either. Nor any ostentatious religious sign of any religion. Period. All that said, it is true that the law is not always correctly applied (or even understand for that matter). That does not make it lawful.
- southerntofu 5y ago> All that said, it is true that the law is not always correctly applied (or even understand for that matter). That does not make it lawful. Although i would argue controlling people's aesthetics is against freedom of conscience, i know we all have rights on paper. I'm more concerned with the actual situation day-to-day than what the law says. The french law also says you have the right to decent housing, but what's of interest to me is that there's hundreds of thousands of mishoused/homeless people when there's literally millions of empty apartments (source: INSEE) waiting for them.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoPretty sure it's a dig at the US where people in many of its overseas (basically only Hawaii) territories don't get to vote in the presidential election, while it sounds like there is universal suffrage in all of France's territory.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoYes, more than French territory in fact (that's what he was getting at but that's not really the meaning of 'universal'): Every French citizen in the world has the right to vote in Presidential elections and every French citizen in the world is part of a parliamentary constituency and can vote for a Representative/MP. Usually the polling station is the nearest Consulate or Embassy. For instance there is a French MP who is elected in North America to represent French citizens who live in the USA and Canada in the French Parliament [1]. Map of the constituencies [2] (The MP for the 11th constituency must max out on air miles). [1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premi%C3%A8re_circonscription_des_Fran%C3%A7ais_%C3%A9tablis_hors_de_France https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premi%C3%A8re_circonscription_... [2] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7ais_%C3%A9tablis_hors_de_France#/media/Fichier:2T_L%C3%A9gislatives_2017_fran%C3%A7ais_de_l'%C3%A9tranger.svg https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7ais_%C3%A9tablis_hor...