6 ms·
> A few weeks ago there was a conversation [1] regarding the utility of signals like this, with a common opinion that they are useless. Unfortunately, typical
by wolverine876 5y ago
> A few weeks ago there was a conversation [1] regarding the utility of signals like this, with a common opinion that they are useless.
Unfortunately, typical for HN - a bit odd for a community built around innovative startups. Look at the top comment for almost every discussion, a smarter-than-thou takedown of whatever the OP says. I wish the mods would automatically move that comment to the bottom.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoIt's okay to be critical of proposed ideas. The problem with hand held signals such as this is that they're self-defeating. To be effective they must be widely understood and conspicuous. If they are well understood and conspicuous, then the attacker will punish the victim for attempting to make them. Attackers will surely see articles like this and will prevent victims from putting their hands anywhere near the glass in future.
- sam0x17 5y agoThat said, when it's generational you get interesting and good effects -- a hand signal the young people know might be enough to save a young person from an old person abducting them.
- dada78641 5y agoI don't think this signal becomes useless the moment an attacker knows about it. It's one thing to prevent your victim from speaking to anyone unattended, but it's hard to imagine there never being a moment for them to make a quick hand gesture to the outside world. At some point an attacker has to take their eyes off their victim even if for just a moment. It's true that attackers can take precautions against this, but that also makes their attack harder to carry out.
- NoahRoseWood 5y agoThe hand signal just needs to be silent, so it can be flashed secretly at strangers. In this case, it worked. The teenager was able to flash the signal at a driver without alerting her captor
- scoopertrooper 5y agoThat might work if the driver happens to be blind. But as I said, an attacker with knowledge of the use of hand signals to seek help would be alert to their passenger holding their hand up to window. So, they'd either restrain their passenger or threaten them to keep their hands away from the window. It worked this time because we're in a local optimum of sorts where enough community members understand the signals to help and enough attackers don't know about the signal to prevent it from being made. However, as community consciousness of these signals grows (through articles such as this) attackers will get wise to the practice. Hence, they're self-defeating.
- darkerside 5y agoIt seems like you're approaching this like a spherical cow, instead of a real world problem. It's easier to discreetly hand signal than to say something.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoThere is nothing wrong with simplifying a problem to get at its essence, but yes it is important to accept real-life is messy. I'm sure in a restricted set of circumstance this may help people (as it did in this story), but I sincerely doubt it'd lead to a material increase in kidnapped people being liberated. It'd certainly be less effective than other interventions such as cracking down on people trafficking networks or poverty reduction programmes. The expressiveness of hand gestures (in general) is quite limited and any gesture used for covert communication must make a tradeoff between conspicuousness to the public and conspicuousness to the attacker. This limitation restricts the situations in which they can be made and results in gestures that could be easily dismissed or otherwise misunderstood and thus limit their utility.
- pferde 5y agoI can't believe this needs to be pointed out, but it's not an either-or proposal. We can have signals such as this one, as well as efforts to curtail human trafficking.
- stolen_biscuit 5y agoCalling 911 by that logic is self defeating because it's easily recognizable and can easily be preventable, but it's not, because these things aren't about being fool-proof, but giving people a means to communicate if the opportunity arises to do so. A silent hand gesture is perfect, can be easily made when someone turns their back, or is distracted and if recognized, can potentially save your life. But yes, it depends on IF the opportunity arises to do so, even if the attacker knows the hand signal. And a silent hand signal is incredibly easy to pull off in a situation like what occurred to this poor girl.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoYes, the first thing a kidnapper will do is remove your phone from you because they're aware it can be used to call 911. So 911 is self-defeating in certain situations because attackers are aware of it and will target people in such a way as to avoid 911 being called. However, it still has utility because there are a range of situations where attackers take some time to subdue their victims (such as a home invasion) or in cases where there is a witness unseen by the attacker. These hand signals only make sense in cases where the attacker already has physical (though not mental) control over the victim and the crime is not immediately obvious to witnesses. I think this case would actually be one of the easiest for the attacker to prevent with prior knowledge of the hand signal. Most people hardly ever look at the occupants of passing cars and only subset of them would have the knowledge and presence of mind to interpret the signal and not dismiss it anyway. So, a victim would have to have their fist pressed up against the glass for an extended period of time. The attacker, sitting right next to the victim, would catch that in their peripheral vision pretty quickly.
- stolen_biscuit 5y agoYes, nobody is saying it's completely impervious to being prevented. It's a discrete way of alerting people to you being in danger, I don't know why you think it's a bad thing when it has literally been proven to be effective and potentially saved a young womans life. I do not understand the hostility to the idea.
- dkersten 5y agoThe video in the article has an example where it can be effective: as a silent non verbal signal. Sure, writing it may be more effective but if for some reason you can’t, then a signal may be helpful.
- kortex 5y agoThe symbol appears (to me) to be deliberately designed to be easy to disguise with a wave or other subtle hand gesture, particularly on some sort of video call. It's very obvious from the front, but not very obvious from other perspectives. It's this information differential that makes it effective. If you are at the point where you cannot even get your hands near where other people can see them, your signal bandwidth to the outside world is likely already severely curtailed. As in, you are probably locked in a basement. I don't think this is meant to address that severe of a human trafficking/abuse situation.
- Razengan 5y ago> typical for HN - a bit odd for a community built around innovative startups. Look at the top comment for almost every discussion, a smarter-than-thou takedown of whatever the OP says. Some people show their intelligence by looking for something to improve, others can only exhibit their intelligence by looking for something to disprove. And the longer you stay on HN you’ll see that it’s mostly populated by the latter.
- wolverine876 5y agoAnd it's not exhibiting intelligence, at least not to intelligent people. It's wasting our time.
- dang 5y ago"Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29165092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29165092 since it applies here too. Relatedly, would you please review the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) and stop breaking them? I'm unfortunately seeing a lot of that in your recent commenting history.
- dang 5y ago"Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html It's extremely easy to arrive at false generalizations by considering only the subset of the data that makes the strongest impression on you. On the internet, including HN, what makes the strongest impression are all the things that aggravate and activate and rub us the wrong way. The positive and innocuous portions of the data set, of which there are plenty, get left out of this generalization. You would arrive at opposite conclusions with different data points. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=%22false%20feelings%20of%20generality%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Supercilious putdowns of the rest of the community are notoriously even easier and more tempting than other forms of this cognitive bias, because they gratify other motivations too. They predictably lead to lame and tedious discussion, which is why we have that guideline. Here are some congruent things to do instead: (1) leave the community if you feel it's so bad; (2) post substantive contributions that make things less bad; (3) find how you yourself are doing the thing you complain about, and change that aspect. Would you please review the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) and stop breaking them? I'm unfortunately seeing a lot of that in your recent commenting history.
- OJFord 5y agoI don't! Why should the first response be uncritical praise? If it were to always be one or the other, I'm pretty sure I'd prefer critical. That'd better mirror real-world unmanaged debate/didagreement (if that's a goal) too.
- sjtindell 5y agoI definitely see what you're referring to happen a lot. Ironically, one thing I also enjoy about HN is reading a questionable article and seeing the top comment be a well thought out take down from someone who seems like a real expert. But it's true the top comment regularly seems to be a (sometimes egregiously wrong) takedown or downplaying.
- uoaei 5y agoI see the zealotry surrounding rationalism in this space but was always puzzled by it. Rationality is achieved when one merely makes rational arguments following some axiom or assumption. But it says nothing about the reasonableness of the axiom or assumption per se. It would seem that some folks employ faulty assumptions in supposedly rational discussions, assuming that they are winning the debate (whether it is a debate or not) without considering their blind spots.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoI don't think that's a fair criticism of deductive reasoning. A rational argument should absolutely try and drill down into assumptions. We might accept some assumptions for the sake of argument, but that doesn't take them off the table for unpicking once the main argument is made.
- prox 5y agoI noticed it depends a lot on the actual expertise of the commenter. Some are really high end, and comments follow to be interested. If it’s not, you see counterpoints arise fairly quickly.
- wolverine876 5y ago> someone who seems like a real expert They almost never seem like it to me. A suggestion: Look for whether they provide evidence, not just claims that anyone can type.
- rjzzleep 5y agoMaybe if there were more of these in the outside world, tech scene or not, we'd have less Theranos kinds to deal with.
- robocat 5y agoYour top voted reply to the first comment shows the same same issue. It would be really great if HN provided multiple different moderation systems, so everyone could select a moderation algorithm that suited them better.
- teekert 5y agoPlease don't, these comments are most valuable. In fact when something is relevant for me I wait for some time and revisit the comments. The top comment is often indeed the opposite view, and as such, very valuable and it allows you to make up your own mind. The truth (or I should say "a considerate opinion") is often in the middle of OP and the top comment, I find.
- guerrilla 5y ago> The truth (or I should say "a considerate opinion") is often in the middle of OP and the top comment, I find. Careful with that. [1] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- teekert 5y agoYeah, that indeed, so... see how everything fits in your world-view and think about both stances and form an opinion keeping an open mind and acknowledge that you could still be wrong... Then, you could test that opinion by writing a respectful comment to the top comment. :)
- ChrisSD 5y agoThe fallacy is a favourite of the news media "In the studio today we have someone who has been studying this topic at a reputable institution for decades. And to argue a different side we have someone who only learned about this topic ten minutes ago but nonetheless can be relied upon to have strong contrary opinions, no matter the subject." Of course the reputable person could be wrong but listening to the guy spouting BS is not going to help discern the truth, which is almost certainly not anywhere in whatever "middle" was conjured up by the BS.
- guerrilla 5y agoYeah, well they have to fill their bothsidesism[1] quota somehow. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance
- iSnow 5y agoI even hesitated clicking on the comment section as it was totally clear this was going to be dominated by contrarian for contrarian's sake comments, Reddit style. It certainly helps for some deep technical articles, but when it comes to broader topics, HN has become grumpy and old.
- 1_player 5y agoAlways has been. And not only on HN, on the Internet everybody is a contrarian that knows better. It's cool to hate.
- iSnow 5y agoI used to be like that and find that re-conditioning myself is really hard. Agreeing to something while acknowledging its flaws seems so bland if you can write a scathing take-down instead...
- wolverine876 5y agoAs an alternative perspective: Writing a 'scathing take-down' is lazy BS; you don't have to know anything or even do anything. It adds nothing to the world. To write something constructive takes thought and creativity (as in, to 'create' something). ("Agreeing to something while acknowledging its flaws" isn't the alternative.)
- aaron695 5y ago> HN has become grumpy and old It's fun playing games with domestic violence. Secret symbols and code words. 20 years ago it was how to escape from a car trunk. Teach your kids! You'll save the day with your upvotes, like.. for real. That's what Reddit or TikTok or 4chan is for. It's fair that adults don't want these childish games everywhere.
- lowdose 5y agoBut it is also satisfying having read the article want to give your hot take on the matter and the top comment nails it already. Saved me at least a half hour.
- JustFinishedBSG 5y agoIf the solution proposed doesn't use Rust and cannot be sold as a SaaS is it even innovative ?
- kortex 5y agoIt's as predicatabde as cron. _thread on new technology_ -> some quip about how you can do it with X old tool. Orchestration? "Just use some bash/perl, no need for this k8s craziness" On a thread about Micro - a new cli text editor? "Just use vim." And of course, the OG: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224
- me_me_me 5y agoI actually enjoy them, as long as they are civil and technically correct. They are right to point out that the signal had nothing to do with the rescue, its a fair point. I treat those comments as reality check that lets me question my own stance and views. Afterall we all have different opinions, and mine might not be right.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoWe do whenever we see it. You can always let us know at hn@ycombinator.com if there's a particularly bad one. Unfortunately, this comment here, and the fact that it was pinned to the top of the subthread, is sort of a variant of the same thing. I'll mark it off topic now.