4 ms·
I don't understand why people are focusing on nuclear now, and not 5 years ago or 10 years ago. What has changed? If I understand correctly, technology hasn't
by wolverine876 5y ago
I don't understand why people are focusing on nuclear now, and not 5 years ago or 10 years ago. What has changed?
If I understand correctly, technology hasn't changed. People want nuclear because either they don't think renewables can scale up quickly enough or because of the base load problem (renewables can't always provide energy on demand). Has any of that changed? Renewables generally are cheaper and have more scale now.
If we'd started 10 years ago, we might have some plants coming online soon.
- 99_00 5y ago>What has changed? Wind and solar were rolled out at state and national scale.
- LatteLazy 5y agoPeople forgot the last set of nuclear boondogels. Nothing sells a pyramid scheme like 10 years without one...
- cbsmith 5y agoI mean... the technology has changed, but it is hard to argue that it has changed in a way that makes the decision different.
- liuliu 5y agoBecause China encountered major setback on their nuclear ambitions due to the US ban (China was previous planning to use US technology for their nuclear plants). It took a few years (>5) for them to mature domestic technology and scale up nuclear plants.
- Gwypaas 5y agoIt is the last death throes of an industry coupled with some tech minded people thinking it's controversial and cool, even though the tech in reality is old and boring. The "silver bullet" to fix climate change, much like we saw with all manner of things last year with Covid. The one chance to revive nuclear power in the west through Virgil C. Summer, Vogtle, Hinkley Point C, Flammanville and Olkiluoto 3 failed miserably with several of the major players now bankrupt. China keeps dipping it's toes in nuclear to keep the option open but no real commitment, and this announcement of 150 reactors is no real change to the long term plans either. In 2019, China had a new target of 200 GWe of nuclear generating capacity by 2035, which is 7.7% out of predicted total electricity generating capacity of 2600 GWe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_China So with about 50 GWe from 50 reactors today adding another 150 gives you the same goal of about 200 GWe.
- samsolomon 5y agoFWIW, Vogtle 3 is on track to come online next year. https://www.power-eng.com/nuclear/overcoming-delays-hot-functional-testing-on-vogtle-nuclear-unit-3-progressing-successfully/ https://www.power-eng.com/nuclear/overcoming-delays-hot-func...
- FooBarWidget 5y agoIn case of China, after Fukushima they decided to suspend generation 2 reactors and only build generation 3 reactors. But that didn't go smoothly and there were lots of delays. By the time generation 3 was ready, the trade war hit and a bunch of Chinese nuclear companies got blacklisted by the US. So they had to ditch foreign IP (French designs) and create their own IP (Hualong One) which also took time. These 150 reactors we see today are the end of a long pipeline. David Fishman is an expert on this topic. Thread: https://twitter.com/pretentiouswhat/status/1293961095892279296 https://twitter.com/pretentiouswhat/status/12939610958922792...
- oceanplexian 5y agoPretty simple, we were in the middle of a nuclear renaissance (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_renaissance_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_renaissance_in_the_Uni...) in the US prior to Fukushima. Instead of informing the public of the facts (The plant was an antique, didn't meet safety standards, was built on a fault line), the media in the US used it as an opportunity for scare-mongering and politicized it.
- Schlaefer 5y ago> Instead of informing the public of the facts (The plant was an antique, didn't meet safety standards, was built on a fault line) Knowing these facts makes it even more scary. We can't move countries away from fault lines, so plants are going to be build in these places again. Everything new is going to be old eventually. There's no reason to expect meeting safety standards in the future if we can't do it right now.
- rmbyrro 5y agoI think I understand your point here, but it also seems to me this line of thinking also denies the laws of evolution...
- nitrogen 5y agoEveryone seems to forget that it took a freaking tsunami that displaced hundreds of thousands of people to take out a 60 year old reactor design. While coal is killing people every day.
- Schlaefer 5y agoOf course it should take a freak event to take out a nuclear power plant, it shouldn't happen every second Sunday. But I would also expect it to be an event that doesn't happen regularly every few hundred years [1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/21/world/asia/21stones.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/21/world/asia/21stones.html
- godelski 5y ago10 years ago was Fukushima. Which caused a reversal in nuclear production. The 10-30 years before that (1980-2000) most of the environmentalists were campaigning against nuclear. Especially in light of Chernobyl and three mile. The difference now is there's significant efforts into smrs (even if little think it's about thorium, it isn't), which means that nuclear could become scalable. If that happens, then it is a game changer because it's the only real downside of the technology.
- account4mypc 5y agoi think people are more desperate for change (and imo, rightly so)
- Zigurd 5y agoNuclear power has very long lead-times. If you want to convince the public to build uranium fission power plants, you have to do it now or the time in which they would be relevant to the climate crisis will pass. That assumes the public will want current-generation uranium fission plants, which they did not want in the past.