4 ms·
> I have been saying this for quite some time: The future vision of an all-electric ground transportation system is between impossible and untenable without a m
by vkou 5y ago
> I have been saying this for quite some time: The future vision of an all-electric ground transportation system is between impossible and untenable without a massive scale-up in nuclear energy generation in places like the US.
Through the 20th century, the US doubled its electricity production ~every 20 years.
What makes you say doubling its electricity production is impossible over the next ~20?
- armada651 5y ago> Through the 20th century, the US doubled its electricity production ~every 20 years. The US has done that using fossil fuels though. > What makes you say doubling its electricity production is impossible over the next ~20? Whether the US can do the same thing with net zero emissions is the big question.
- vkou 5y ago> The US has done that using fossil fuels though. In that time period, non-hydro renewables were an order of magnitude more expensive than fossil fuels. They aren't anymore. > Whether the US can do the same thing with net zero emissions is the big question. Actually, even if it does so by building new coal plants, it would be done with net-negative emissions, because utility energy generation is more carbon-efficient than a tiny ICE burning gasoline (Which also requires a mountain of energy, and, uh, doing other ethically questionable things[0], to extract and refine.) The problem to solve is not that of energy generation. We know how to build power plants. We haven't built as many in recent years, because electricity demand has temporarily peaked. The problem to solve is figuring out the politics of getting electric vehicle infrastructure rolled out across the country[1]. Because it concerns land use, there's a lot of stakeholders that need to be on board for this. Fortunately, there are market pressures (people buying EVs, demand for charging infrastructure) that are pushing on this. [0] Prior to the fracking boom, your taxes paid for imperial adventures in the Middle East, the primary purpose of which was oil security. [1] Actually, I think the problem to solve is getting people out of cars and into scooters, mopeds, bicycles, buses, and trains, but that's neither here nor there.
- robomartin 5y ago> What makes you say doubling its electricity production is impossible over the next ~20? Easy: It takes us decades to build anything of any significance any more. A nuclear power plant could take 30 years, maybe 50 at this rate. We need over a thousand of them. In addition to this, the cost to build anything in the US is so high, I am not sure we have the financial means to build 1400 GW in energy generation capacity and the massive infrastructure upgrades this would require in order to be useful. The famed California High Speed train is the perfect (and saddest) example of just how incompetent we have become. It was promised at a price tag of about ten billion dollars. It was going to bring forth an era of amazing energy-efficient transportation up and down the State. We are at about a HUNDRED billion today. We have only built TEN miles. Which are NOT OPERATING. And, if we did have a running train on these ten miles, I believe the top speed would be limited to somewhere around 50 MILES PER HOUR. Yeah. No. I think a massive shift in leadership, national focus and philosophy has to occur before we can even dream of a future where our 300 million vehicles are electric. What's going to happen is that --and I hate to put it this way-- those in the upper-middle class and above might be able to migrate to electrics while everyone else is stuck with gasoline powered vehicles at $10 per gallon. In other words, the poor get shafted once again. Brilliant.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI only follow the California High Speed project from a distance and not in detail, but it was my understanding that the plan called for a route through a 2000 m (6000 ft) high mountain range. Most actual high speed lines in the world try to avoid such terrain as much as possible. The ones that actually need to cross comparable mountains (like the Alps) take decades to build (so called Basis Tunnels, in Switzerland and Austria) and the cost is staggering.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoWhere there is the will, there is a way!