8 ms·
I remember when this news first came out, and I heard a lot of folks scoff "Ha, see, I knew organic was always a scam", but I think that position misunderstands
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I remember when this news first came out, and I heard a lot of folks scoff "Ha, see, I knew organic was always a scam", but I think that position misunderstands some very important details about this story.
Randy Constant wasn't selling organic produce, or really much of anything that you think of buying "organic" at the grocery store. Because, for the most part, there tend to be a lot of visual differences between organic and conventional: conventional apples, for example, tend to be huge and spotless, while organic are almost always smaller and less "pristine". Similarly, stuff like organic, grass-fed milk tastes much different than conventional milk.
I've always been of the opinion that, as a consumer choice, organic makes sense for certain types of products where you eat the skin and all, e.g. apples, vegetables, etc.
In this case, though, Mr. Constant was selling "organic" grain primarily as livestock feed. The idea that you can really tell, or there is any difference at all, in the meat of livestock fed organic vs. conventional is extremely far fetched. Sure, there way be some tiny difference, but it's not like conventional methods include spraying with heavy metals. Most of the pesticides, etc. sprayed on conventional crops certainly don't show up in the meat of animals that eat these crops.
So this whole episode did expose the scam of organic livestock feed, but I don't think it's fair to stretch that to organic products generally.
- colechristensen 5y agoOrganic does not taste or look different. If the produce looks shabbier it’s because they were less selective about throwing pieces into lower grades or it has been on the shelf longer. If milk tastes different its the “grass fed” part not the organic part. People have magical thoughts about what organic does. Roundup and synthetic fertilizer do not affect flavor.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Roundup and synthetic fertilizer do not affect flavor I'm not arguing they do. But I've seen conventionally grown apples that were nearly the size of my head, and I've never seen organic produce that comes anywhere close. Granted, that just means it would be difficult to pass off organic as conventional, while the reverse you could just pick conventional earlier, but I think arguing "organic does not look different" is asking me to disbelieve my eyes every time I go to the grocery store.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt's not about picking earlier, an apple is either ripe or not. Some producers get rid of much of the fruit early in the season which results in fewer, larger apples. Organic producers could do this just as well, but generally don't.
- gadders 5y agoIf you compare two apples of the same type, I completely agree. I think a lot of times with "organic" produce, the taste improvements come from something else - typically using different, heritage varieties that were bred for flavour, rather than looking good on the shelf.
- thriftwy 5y agoThis is like with handicraft vs. mass produced items. It's trivial to make worse handicraft than mass produce, but handicraft makers realize that if they charge N times more they've got to add at least some value. They also focus in areas where it's possible to add value (no handicraft Android phones or Lego bricks). So when you actually buy some handicraft item/organic food, it is usually different/better quality, not because this is inherent property of the production process, but because the price has to be justified.
- colechristensen 5y agoYou’re assuming “organic” implies some sort of increased manual process, it decidedly does not.
- thriftwy 5y agoIf you're ready to pay more for an "organic" label on top of the same thing, I have a bridge to sell.
- obiwan14 5y ago> Organic does not taste or look different. You're missing the point of organic, especially produce, and especially those you have to eat the skin too. It's not the taste, but the pesticide residue on the skin. Those residues accumulate in your body. What's the long term effect? I'm sure you know what the answer to that is. By that measure alone, organic is healthier than non-organic.
- Khelavaster 5y agoSynthetic fertilizer absolutely affects flavor. Especially for root vegetable and aromatic plants which rely on healthy root microbiomes for nutrient absorption without synthetic fertilizer.
- kryogen1c 5y ago> Organic does not taste or look different. this is patently false. the easiest and most obvious case is eggs. try it yourself. buy a dozen of the cheapest factory farm eggs you can find and a dozen of organic cage-free eggs. crack them open and look. they barely look like the same thing. factory farm eggs look pale and sickly - organic looks rich and nutritious. of course, you could just search it: https://www.backyardchickens.com/hredirect2.php?c=4903441 https://www.backyardchickens.com/hredirect2.php?c=4903441
- colechristensen 5y agoThe color of the yolks depend on eating a small number of things. Essentially if chickens eat yellow or orange pigmented things, the yolks of their eggs are darker. "organic" has nothing to do with it, feed choice does, and things to supplement egg color are often fed to chickens to make their eggs have darker yolks to make people think exactly this. It is essentially marketing.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoIf you expect there to be no difference in the meat of livestock that has been fed organic, why would you expect any differences regarding human consumption?
- dagw 5y agoIt's reasonable to assume that much of the 'poison' ends up concentrated in organs that I'm not eating.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoI'm not an expert, but I know some poisons accumulate in the body fat. If you believe in the harmfulness of PUFAs, they too become part of the body and are similarly damaging.
- mywittyname 5y ago>"Ha, see, I knew organic was always a scam" I'm probably one of these people, so I feel the need proffer a defense. It isn't that I think organic produce is a scam. But from what I understand about the verification systems in place it is easy to get away with labeling non-organic products as organic. And since organic products sell at a price premium, everyone has a financial incentive to be in on it. Everyone just passes the buck upstream. I'm certainly not going to pay a price premium for something that isn't easy to validate. Now, if the organic green peppers look better than the non-organic ones, I might buy them instead, but in this instance, I'm paying for tangibly better produce, not a fancy sticker. It doesn't help that I grew up in soy bean country right around the time when everyone was going organic, so I've seen first-hand the disdain that land owners had for organic buyers. The article is really spot on in this respect.
- azinman2 5y agoCan you tell us more about this distain?
- arghnoname 5y agoWhile I understand that organic farming with reasonable yields requires care and expertise, at face value this just looked like amateur hour to establishment farmers--at least initially. I'm not endorsing this view, but I grew up in farm country and heard it a lot. The thinking is something like what follows. Pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers massively increased yield, so eschewing these modern innovations due to some woo to get trash yields and inferior products (e.g., smaller, with more signs of insect predation) just seems like lunacy. Keep in mind, people who have made a living judiciously spraying their crops with these chemicals for many years aren't likely to think they've been poisoning themselves or the population for a lot of reasons, so they won't buy into the central premise of organic farming. So it's like insisting on doing all of your programming on a PD-11/20 just because it's pure. When customers start insisting on the right to buy inferior products at inflated prices, it's all the more batty.
- azinman2 5y ago
- knubie 5y agoI thought the whole point of organic was to reduce the environmental and health impacts of artificial pesticides and fertilizers (plus more humane conditions for livestock), not making food taste better.
- gruez 5y ago>reduce the environmental and health impacts of artificial pesticides and fertilizers that seems like using a blunt instrument to address two orthogonal issues, in a roundabout way. 1. if it's actually about the environmental/health impacts, why shouldn't artificial pesticides/fertilizers be allowed on a per-chemical basis if the evidence supports its safety? 2. is there any requirement that organic farming have less environmental impact on net compared to conventional farming? You might win in terms of run-off artificial pesticides and fertilizers, but then lose out overall because of lower yields. >(plus more humane conditions for livestock), is humane treatment part of organic certification?
- defaultname 5y ago"The idea that you can really tell, or there is any difference at all, in the meat of livestock fed organic vs. conventional is extremely far fetched." If they tested the feed of course they would know the difference because the non-organic feed would be contaminated with pesticides/herbicides. And organic livestock is fed organic feed because of course the contaminants are reflected in the meat. This is easily verified as basic fact, though actually testing the feed or the meat is an expensive process hence the whole honor system. This doesn't make organic a scam. Exactly the same reason you might not want an apple sprayed with a pesticide applies to eat a burger from a cow that was fed feed sprayed with the same. In many ways moreso given that these things are concentrated as you go up the food chain. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-40/chapter-I/subchapter-E/part-180/subpart-C/section-180.364 https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-40/chapter-I/subchapter-E... Conventional red meat can have 20X the amount of glyphosate than your apple can. This was a failure of the certification and monitoring system. Often by design. I don't buy organic. Too niche of a section and the risk profile seems low enough that it doesn't seem worth the attention to me. But I'm not threatened by it, as many seemingly are, and get why some people are focused on that. Years back I did subscribe to a CSA that followed organic principles not because of the organic element, but because their land use was sustainable and quite beautiful (most farms are dire factories, in essence, whereas this place was an eclectic wonderland).
- bloaf 5y ago> the non-organic feed would be contaminated with pesticides/herbicides. https://www.agdaily.com/technology/the-list-of-pesticides-approved-for-organic-production/ https://www.agdaily.com/technology/the-list-of-pesticides-ap... Organic farming uses herbicides and pesticides too.
- Madmallard 5y agoOrganic foods, especially ones that have a USDA stamp other rigorous approvals, are upheld to much higher sanitary, chemical-cleanliness, and soil-care standards than conventional crops. The thing about organic pesticides is a red herring. Fresh organic foods raised in good soil are unarguably way better for you than the alternative. There's not even a comparison.
- ashtonkem 5y agoYou can’t tell the difference between conventional and organic grain fed beef, but you can tell the difference between grass finished and grain finished beef. And there has been some fraud in this area too, usually in restaurant settings where the chef’s skill can make up the difference. Bel Campo Meats comes to mind, they were accused by former workers of lying about what meat went into their product; grass fed vs. grain fed.
- chasebank 5y agoAnecdote, but a friend of mine is an avocado farmer in Carpinteria, CA. Around 15 years ago he went through the process of converting his orchards to certified organic. He said it's 99% paperwork and nothing really changed on the farming side. Swap out one chemical for another that skirts the rules and technically organic. I don't know if this is how it is in the rest of the farming world, but wouldn't surprise me.
- BeetleB 5y ago> Similarly, stuff like organic, grass-fed milk tastes much different than conventional milk. Nope. Or rather, milk tastes different for plenty of reasons, and you can buy non-organic milk that tastes similar to organic. And I can absolutely guarantee that you can buy organic milk that tastes no different from the mass produced cheap non-organic milk. (I've spent a lot of time testing/tasting different milk products).
- schwartzworld 5y ago> Similarly, stuff like organic, grass-fed milk tastes much different than conventional milk. That's because the cow is eating grass, not because it's "organic" > organic makes sense for certain types of products where you eat the skin and all, e.g. apples, vegetables, etc. I feel like that would be true if there was any legal definition of organic that meant "pesticide-free", which there isn't. Organic farms use ancient pesticide technology, which isn't that good and requires MORE pesticides to be used.
- frazbin 5y agoNope that's wrong about the livestock feed. Beef bioaccumulates pesticides in fatty tissue just like anything else. You can't test every steak (yet), but that doesn't mean organic is a scam-- just means it's scammable. It'd all feel much different if we had more data to empower consumers. Imagine e.g. a meat thermometer that gave ppb/ppt of 100+ pesticide residues.. suddenly you find one kind/cut of meat has orders of magnitude more pesticide than another.. "oh weird I never felt good after eating that brand of meat, maybe I'll pay an extra $2 a pound next time".
- gruez 5y ago> Imagine e.g. a meat thermometer that gave ppb/ppt of 100+ pesticide residues You don't even need a consumer widget to do that. We have organic certification programs that conduct inspections/audits. Why can't we have a "low pesticide"/"pesticide free" program that does guarantees low pesticide residues?