3 ms·
> The physical shelves in a library only serve a single, small geographic area, not the whole world What part of that sentence is not contradicted by inter-lib
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> The physical shelves in a library only serve a single, small geographic area, not the whole world
What part of that sentence is not contradicted by inter-library loans? The books come off the shelves, and must be found there. They serve a wide geographic area, sometimes even the whole world (my mother was a librarian at several very specialized libraries and they participated in both receiving and giving loans involving other libraries around the world. It is true that the physical shelves in a library in (say) Germany will not be organized using DDS, but it remains true that the physical shelves can serve a wide geographic area.
And this is not even to comment on those specialized libraries that people will travel from around the world to visit. Same physical shelves, world-wide service area. These can include libraries focused on individuals (famous historical figures, for example), or academic libraries with particularly rich holdings in certain areas, or libraries that just happen to have the only instance of a set of books/documents.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) is not a special-holdings cataloguing system. It is not even an academic holdings cataloguing system (in the US the Library of Congress Classification System, LCSS, is overwhelmingly used for this). DDC is used, in the majority of cases, for public libraries, serving local communities, in the US. The fact that DDC was developed at an academic library (Amherst College Library) doesn't refute this --- origin stories are not present-use stories, and Amherst have largely converted to the LCCS (see: https://www.amherst.edu/library/find/finditfrost/call-numbers https://www.amherst.edu/library/find/finditfrost/call-number... https://www.amherst.edu/library/find/finditfrost#tab-44437 https://www.amherst.edu/library/find/finditfrost#tab-44437). The LCCS, though influenced by DCC, is distinct. It still reflects a US-centrism, though with different emphasis. History of the Americas occupies two of the twenty alphabetic major classifications, and each of political science, law, education, agriculture, technology, military, and (separately) navel science, has its own major classification, reflecting the interests of a government ... and that government's library shelving concerns. Specialised libraries rarely use DCC in my experience. Medical libraries often use their own specific classification, and academic libraries in the US as noted above typically use LCCS, though some retain DCC or their own ideosyncratic classifications (both are generally being phased out for LCCS). For the University of California, an academic library with a strong inter-campus ILL programme, local circulaty exceeds ILL within the multicampus system by over an order of magnitude (1.6 million vs. 135k https://libraries.universityofcalifornia.edu/about/facts-and-figures https://libraries.universityofcalifornia.edu/about/facts-and...). For a local public library with few exceptional holdings, ILL circulation is likely a far smaller fraction of circulation. (Some have regional lending arrangements with peer libraries, independent of ILL. This still remains a small fraction of total circulation.) Much use of materials is within the library itself, captured only (if at all) in reshelving statistics, though those are hard to find. (I used the UC library system only because it's among the few that have available statistics.) The point remains that the principle focus of a cataloguing system is for local use and management of a bibliographic collection. ILL happens to be an incidental and compatible use. It is not of itself a major factor in classification system development. If you have any substantive argument to the contrary, I'd be happy to hear it. You've not yet made one.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThat's a lot of good information about library classification systems. But none of of it seems to impinge on this sentence: > The physical shelves in a library only serve a single, small geographic area, not the whole world which is the line I was responding too.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf 90%+ of your use case (for a major academic library) is local, and <10% is remote (though within the same general geographical region and topical interests), do you solve for the <10% solution or the >90% solution? If you're a regional nonspecialist nonacademic library where that split is far more likely 99%/1%, which do you solve for? I am telling you flatly that your assumption and premise is false. Libraries, in the overwhelming majority of institutions, serve local communities, in the overwhelming majority of transactions. I've provided data to back my argument. You ... continue to hand-wave.