4 ms·
FWIW we've also received the exact same email from the same named person with the same vague text of having "identified a vulnerability in your Web Application"
by mythz 5y ago
FWIW we've also received the exact same email from the same named person with the same vague text of having "identified a vulnerability in your Web Application", judging from Troy's twitter thread he seemed to have sent the same email to many others.
We're still waiting on a reply to asses whether there's any validity in his claim. I guess what I'm curious is how do people best handle this situation? Normally if it's any other pc security threat or legal liability claim cold emailing us we'd just report spam & ignore but with a software vulnerability we're at duty to investigate, which I expect would make his vulnerability claim so effective with engagement.
Given this happened shortly after we added a SECURITY.md to our project with the contact email used, it wouldn't surprise me if he is just email spamming the same claim to projects with SECURITY pages where he'll expect some payment for just disclosing a GitHub reported dependency vulnerability that nearly every non-trivial npm project has.
- tptacek 5y agoYou shouldn't have any particular duty to follow up with someone who's withholding a bounty report. If the report is good, you'll know it; you may get a report without details, but if they're for real, they'll include credentials (usually: a link to previous findings). If they're complete anonymous randos and don't provide details, they've got nothing.
- rebuilder 5y agoIf all they're saying is "Your software is vulnerable", that's not news. That's like saying the sky is blue, there's nothing to investigate without more details.