6 ms·
French couple wins legal fight over wind ‘turbine syndrome’
- kiliantics 5y agoCool, now can I get 100k for all the noise and health problems caused by the roads and fossil fuel power plants that are built around me? If this case could serve as a precedent for the existing and future health impacts of the harmful infrastructure we're forced to live with it could be a useful tool for tackling climate change but somehow that seems unlikely...
- notwhereyouare 5y agoI would imagine it's a matter of "who was there first". If you buy a house next to an airport and then try and complain to get the airport shut down, no, you shouldn't get any compensation. If you buy a house and then they start to build an airport, yes you should get compensation
- mrjangles 5y agoRegardless of whether the sickness is real, it is amazing these things can be built next to people's houses without just compensation. Simply the non stop noise would be more than enough to ensure you could never sell your house for even half of what you paid for it.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoClimate change cause real sickness (heat waves kill, for one) and my appartment in Paris has become unlivable for days, almost every summer now. Coal, oil and gas won't compensate me, for the price of my flat and the impact on my health either. This impact many more people than wind, so where should we start?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoIdem for the noise of airplanes (around 1/3 of them are private jets) that keep waking me up at 3 AM.
- dvhh 5y agoIn Paris ?
- rguillebert 5y agoCoal, oil and gas kills people https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-production-per-twh https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p...
- skocznymroczny 5y agoYou could try to sue the government. In Poland there has been some celebrities suing the government for "refusing to take action against climate change" and they won some compensation which they officially sent towards charity.
- boudin 5y agoIt's not black or white though. If wind turbines does have an impact, it should be studied and understood so that, whatever the reason is behind the impact, it can be taken into account. If not, there will always be the risk of backlash that would help nobody. If the causes are understood, then there can be ways to control the impact, solve those issues or, at least, have a better idea where those should and should not be implanted.
- gjs278 5y agoget an air conditioner lol
- vixen99 5y agoAnd cold impacts many more people than heat. Has climate change altered this statistic? I have no idea but to date, have seen no evidence that cold-related deaths have diminished in recent years. 'Cold weather kills 20 times as many people as hot weather, according to an international study analysing over 74 million deaths in 384 locations across 13 countries including Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Taiwan, Thailand, UK, and USA. The findings, published in The Lancet, also reveal that deaths due to moderately hot or cold weather substantially exceed those resulting from extreme heat waves or cold spells.' https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/627630 https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/627630
- HamburgerEmoji 5y agoHeat waves kill fewer than in the past, by far. In 1911 a heat wave apparently killed 41,000 people in Paris. That couldn't have been due to CO2. It was due to lack of cheap, plentiful electricity and air conditioning.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 5y agoHaving camped underneath one briefly, I can tell you there is no way I could live with one nearby my house. It's an extremely low frequency noise with a huge amplitude. I can tolerate it for a while, but it really wears on me quickly. Also, earplugs & hearing protection do nothing to actually stop the noise. It isn't loud enough to cause ear damage anyways. But I can still hear it even with the hearing protection on.
- criddell 5y agoIs there any type of active noise cancelling device that could be installed at the turbine that would work?
- gambiting 5y agoI used to think it's all nonsense and people just complaining about nothing, but now I have a wind turbine about 500m away from my house and I can absolutely hear it at night, just constant low frequency droning combined with a whooshing sound of the blades. Like, I've gotten somewhat used to it now, but I'd lie if I said it doesn't bother me. And again, I don't want to come across as someone against green technologies, we should be building lots and lots of these everywhere.....just maybe not this close to housing.
- bikeshaving 5y agoWould you say it’s worse or better than living near a highway without sound barriers?
- gambiting 5y agoIt's different - I used to live next to major road, and yeah it was louder in intensity, for sure, but at least it would die down quite a lot during the night, and you'd only ocassionally get a car/motorbike with a loud exhaust passing by. This really bothers me because it's just constant and completely unchanging, I keep lying in bed and hearing the whoosh, whoosh, whoosh, whoosh.....with cars I'm just like ok, there was a loud motorbike but it's gone now. With a wind turbine I know it won't change, and either I have to get used to it or....well, move out I guess, and that sucks.
- arcticfox 5y agoYMMV but I for the past few years I have been sleeping with Bose QuietComfort earbuds with active noise cancelling and they've significantly improved my life. Loud noises that would have woken me in the past are dampened enough that I can sleep through them, and annoying hums or whatever while traveling are just completely gone.
- gambiting 5y agoYeah so actually I use my Sony WF-1000XM3 headphones often when falling asleep, or I just put on some rain sounds on my phone next to me - that's usually enough.
- luch 5y agonow I think they can't be built less than 350 m from any house, and if they are in the 350 m to 500 m range they must be an impact study before approving the construction. However there wasn't such rules when the first wind turbine were built circa ~2005, and you have to keep in mind that wind turbines are usually located in places less desirable for housing and farming due to excessive wind. Moreover, it's usually the mayor's office or the county's office which approve the construction. There was instances where the turbines were located at the edge of one county and they didn't check if it were bothering the neighbooring county before signing the deal.
- Ekaros 5y agoOne wonders if there isn't any issues why aren't these build in parks and other places in cities? Surely we should be green and make savings from shortened transmission distances...
- orra 5y agoI realise you’re being flippant, but if you turn parks into windfarms then suddenly many, many people have no access to any green space. Transmission isn’t that expensive in the scheme of things. Else offshore wind, of which I am a fan, would not be viable.
- baud147258 5y agoIf heard from people (in France) that some were even built in their village without permits, usually with the mayor buying agricultural land and getting a fat bonus that way; of course the owner living on the other side of the village, far from any potential impact.
- baby 5y agoI’m reading this amazing magazine that tells investigation stories through comics[1] (in French) and there’s a story about a number of farmers who have issues with their cows dying or refusing to sleep in the barn at night. And when the wind turbines are down for maintenance they have no problem. Apparently they were able to track this data and somewhat prove the link, I’m not sure what’s the status on that. [1]: https://www.larevuedessinee.fr/ https://www.larevuedessinee.fr/
- josefresco 5y agoI found this interesting, in another related article: "The results showed that the experience of symptoms and mood during exposure to audible windfarm sound and infrasound was influenced by the type of expectations provided before exposure periods." https://theconversation.com/wind-turbines-dont-make-you-feel-sick-or-healthy-but-spin-can-20845 https://theconversation.com/wind-turbines-dont-make-you-feel...
- mrjangles 5y agoThe article starts with this: >Despite at least 19 reviews of the scientific evidence universally concluding that exposure to wind farm sound doesn’t trigger adverse health effects, people continue to report feeling unwell because they live near wind turbines. So I did a DDG search and the first thing that comes up is: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3653647/#b14-0590473 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3653647/#b14-05... Which supports the conclusion that wind turbines lead to bad health affects, and inside it has at least 10 references to other studies that showed the same health affects. Great, of course they don't mention that their are studies that do support the bad health affect. This is deliberately trying to trick the reader into thinking that this is all there is. Of course notice their clever wording. They know that would be a lie so they don't say it, they just imply it. >In our new study, we took 60 participants and divided them into two groups – positive and negative. We then exposed them to audible wind farm sound, overlaid with infrasound, during two seven-minute listening sessions. This is the kind of nonsense pseudo science that is prevalent everywhere in academia these days. The people claiming to get sick do so after months of tolerating the non stop sound. Seven minutes listening obviously isn't going to determine anything. And of course if you trick people into thinking that what they are about to listen to in the next 7 minutes will hurt them, then some will claim they were hurt. It is amazing people get paid for this. >A study released this week by South Australia’s Environment Protection Authority (EPA) once again concluded there was no evidence linking noise from wind farms to sickness among residents living near the Waterloo Wind Farm. This is like a tobacco company doing research that shows that smoking is harmless. Also, what does it even mean. People are getting sick, people are complaining, but don't worry, a study says it isn't actually happening. What does that even mean? >A recent analysis of noise and health complaints in Australia found that adverse health reports have coincided with negative publicity about the health effects of wind farms This is the only good study of the bunch. But a coincidence of negative publicity and people feeling empowered to come out and complain is not the same as saying that sickness was non existent before that. Certainly it seems most people stuck next to these things are very unhappy about it. Perhaps simply being miserable all the time is enough to make one sick. If that were the case then negative publicity would empower them to complain when before they felt powerless.
- wrp 5y agoAn Oregon community has had a similar long-running battle over a wind farm (Williams v. Invenergy). Very depressing to see people driven from their homes by noise and spending years fighting for relief or compensation.
- villmann 5y agoPsychosomatic disorder
- bsagdiyev 5y agoIt absolutely is not. It’s telling that you victim blame here.
- Uberphallus 5y agoThe article links to literature about it being a nocebo effect. Do you have literature pointing in another direction?
- pfortuny 5y agoDoesn’t make it less of a disorder.
- brokensegue 5y agoThe article is pretty clear that science does not accept this is a real disorder
- coolso 5y agoThat unfortunately does not mean it’s not a real disorder. Just that science hasn’t accepted it. But scientists are just as infallible and biased as everyone else. As are the media which may choose to cover some science rigid viewpoints while conveniently ignoring others. See also the Wuhan lab leak theory.
- MayeulC 5y agoIt is said that wind sounds can drive people crazy. Some folklore even reports that it was sometimes considered a mitigating factor when judging crimes. Some quick searching turns out a few proverbs and wikipedia articles, but nothing conclusive: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foehn#Effets_sur_les_personnes https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foehn#Effets_sur_les_personnes https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vent_d%27autan https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vent_d%27autan
- newsclues 5y agoCan modern building technology insulate the sound?
- davemp 5y agoYes, but it's not cheap.