10 ms·
Camembert President
- 908B64B197 5y agoFrance had three great leaders in it's (recent) history (and a few good ones here and there). Louis XIV, Napoleon and Charles de Gaulle. Having Macron pictured next to two of them just doesn't feel right.
- dudul 5y agoIf you include Louis XIV as a modern leader, Louis Philippe and Louis XV were better leaders. Maybe you meant "famous leaders".
- 908B64B197 5y ago> and Louis XV were better leaders Not sure losing a lot of money and giving up on most of your North American settlement is an example of good leadership.
- dudul 5y agoThe money was lost by Louis XIV, his successor had to deal with the aftermath. He consolidated the true national borders by integrating corsica and eastern territories. I didn't say he was a good leader, I said he was better than Louis XIV.
- Rexxar 5y agoThe first article of this series of two explains the vote itself : https://lacampagne.substack.com/p/a-vote https://lacampagne.substack.com/p/a-vote It's simple, safe and efficient. I don't understand why USA are not doing something similar. All this voting machines, mail votes, counting/recounting where ballots are manipulated by so many people seems strange, inefficient and prone to fraud.
- karteum 5y ago> It's simple, safe and efficient We all know that having a single turn (like in the US) leads to a political landscape with 2 major political parties and few nuances (but the major problem in the US system is "the winner takes it all" policy in most states: if the number of members of the electoral college were proportional to votes in each states, the results would already be more fair) But the French system (with 2 turns) is also very far from optimal and non-linear, and also leads (to a lesser extent, and some variants/surprises) to 2 major political parties + some smaller "satellite" political parties. And some issue are for example that * sometimes, a candidate that would win against all others has a too low score at the first turn to pass to the 2nd turn (this is what happens in 2007 where all polls said that François Bayrou (who was center/moderate and more consensual) would have won both against Nicolas Sarkozy and against Ségolène Royal, but couldn't get enough votes to pass the 1st turn) * sometimes, the opposite issue happens i.e. a candidate that has no chances to win the 2nd turn has enough votes to pass the 1st turn: this is what happened in 2002 when Le Pen (extreme right wing) supplanted Jospin and went to the 2nd turn (that Chirac was then 100% certain to win at that time, with a consequence that there were no real/constructive debate about the programs) * some people who have new ideas cannot participate because you need 500 signatures of already-elected people in order to participate (so if you are not a member of an established political party, it's very hard to become a candidate to the presidential election) Just to say that there is no binary split between "democracy" and "dictature" : the voting system and algorithm influences a lot the political landscape and therefore the debates. Maybe people here are familiar with the Condorcet method used (among other things) in https://www.debian.org/vote https://www.debian.org/vote which is better in my opinion (yet a little bit difficult to implement in a wider scale such as a presidential election). Another approach / voting method that I quite like is this one (only in French, sorry) https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugement_majoritaire https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugement_majoritaire : I like it because 1°/ it is simple to implement and to understand, 2°/ it would inherently avoid the issues above and forces the candidates to be more consensual (i.e. to become "president for everyone") rather than cleaving, while still enabling nuances to express during the debates (not only on a "binary" axis left/right).
- jnaddef 5y ago
- deanCommie 5y ago> If your goal is to enact your political vision or your policy agenda, left, right or centrist, there is only one place, and that place is the Presidency. It's all fun and games until Marine Le Pen gets elected...
- Bayart 5y agoThat won't happen, and even if it did it wouldn't matter.
- southerntofu 5y ago> It's all fun and games until Marine Le Pen gets elected... It was never fun and games. The 5th republic was built on fascist legacy: De Gaulle was a famous authoritarian who used his powers to crush various forms of popular insurrection (Algerian independence movement, may 68...). He was famously behind the secretive "SAC" (Services d'Action Civique) fascist militias used to physically crush opposition, and oversaw the same police préfets who operated under Pétain apply the same nazi techniques against anti-colonial struggles. Marine le Pen may not be in power, but her ideas have been for a long time. Also interesting to note that the most extreme measures proposed by the Front National (founded by her father) in the 80s are now mainstream political agenda from both "left" and "right" [0]. [0] Actually all the candidates presented by TV are authoritarian right-wing (capitalist). But some claim to be left-wing despite proposing/enacting exactly the same politics. Mélenchon who is presented as extreme left is, in standards from a few decades ago, a centrist or maybe a moderate center-left; only with NPA and LO we start to see some left wing talking points (abolition of managers/ownership, equal sharing of resources for all..) but these are not the people the media give voice to
- miniwark 5y agoThis paper tell, one more time than the actual French constitution is monarchic in spirit, with an "elected king". But historically, this constitution is far more inspired by the two empires regimes than the french monarchies. - There was a "Sacred King selected by God" for the kingdoms aspect totally missing in the empires, while the emperors where, supposedly, "selected by the people" - the two chambers system, was first used by the consulate, a pre-imperial temporary regime (it was a fake triumvirate where Bonaparte was the only real ruler). This two chamber system was inspired by the UK system to appease monarchists and keep by the various regimes since then (except Vichy France). - the first empire have used a lot (of rigged) referendum where all adult male, where allowed to vote. - The first "suffrage universel" to elect a president was established by the second republic, and then abused by the new president, and future second emperor (all men, no women, no clergy and no algerians where allowed to vote) - The constitutions of the second empire include a referendum, called "plebiscite",as a way to either to approve the emperor or to change the law over the parliament. This was inspired by the first empire, and this is also the fact in the actual constitution. (Recently there was a change in the actual constitution to allow a referendum launched by member of the parliament. It was written in a way to render it unusable.) The way the institution are organised, the constitutions of the second empire (1862) and the actual constitution are father and daughter... The real big difference is than the actual constitution include at the start the "Déclaration des Droits de l'Homme et du Citoyen" from 1789. Also, De Gaule had lost a referendum in 1969! This was a big change, the idea was to allow the president to force a change of the constitution by referendum, but this time this a become a tool against him because he had say before "if i lost i quit", so the question was more "did we keep De Gaule as president or not ?" The same in 2005, there was another lost one, and a very big one, because France had say no to an European treaty (and also Netherlands) Since then the government/presidents do not use this tool any more they prefer to change the constitution using the parliament because it's less risky... (and using this way the two "No" where changed to "Yes" later) The history of Napoleon III becoming an emperor after being an elected president by the people was one of the main reason of the opposition of the parliament against De Gaulle for the change of the constitution. De Gaule had reply at the time than he was too old to become a dictator but Napoleon III had said before something like "In a democratic government, only the leader must have the power to govern".
- phtrivier 5y agoDepressingly spot-on. Although one peculiarity of the V republic is missing : it is in theory possible for the elected president and the elected parlement to have different political colors. It is much rarer now that the term of both president and MP are 5 years long, and both elections happen a few month. But three times in my lifetime, we have been in so called "cohabitation", where a "modern-democracy"-styled prime minister was governing, under the theorical authority of the elected monarch. This really was not the worst of time. It would have actually been a very nice way to govern, if the PMs had not caught delusion of "grandeur" at the end of their terms. I would vote for separzting the elections, and barring any PM from running for president.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoThis guy should write another piece explaining why England is a republic since the Magna Carta, with senators wily enough to pilfer Augustus' "The Republic is functioning regularly" and make it "The Monarchy is functioning regularly" (except for the occasional termination with great prejudice of 'monarchs' who got ideas).
- thomasfoster96 5y agoI’m not sure if you’re joking (sorry), but a ‘crowned republic’ [0] is definitely a common way to characterise the effective political system of many constitutional monarchies today — in particular the UK, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crowned_republic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crowned_republic
- davidgay 5y ago> why England is a republic since the Magna Carta You'd have a much better case if you went with "since the Civil War" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_Civil_War) or "since the Glorious Revolution" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glorious_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glorious_Revolution)...
- omegaworks 5y ago>You might wonder: why would electing the President by popular vote be such a big deal? After all, this is how things are done in the United States (at least technically). The last two Republican presidents would beg to differ.
- JasonFruit 5y agoMore broadly, the electoral college is still a thing.
- kergonath 5y agoYeah. It really isn’t how it’s done in the US, technically or otherwise.
- dudul 5y agoThe people still vote, ergo "popular vote". The difference is that the US use indirect democracy with th EC as representatives. I think it's mostly the way we use "popular vote" in the US that is incorrect.
- kergonath 5y agoThe people don’t vote for the president, though, which is the point. They vote for electors, and sometimes the electors vote in the same way as the people. Reasonably often they don’t.
- caned 5y agoI was hoping for cheese-related news.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPresident is more about Brie.
- GuB-42 5y agoActually "President" is possibly the most recognizable brand of Camembert cheese in France. That's the joke. It is not particularly good, it is produced industrially with pasteurized milk (real Camembert use raw milk) but it is commercially successful.
- koolba 5y ago> His solution was elective monarchy. This is effectively how China is governed. Except the elections are only done by party members and the “term” of the monarch is indefinite.
- kirubakaran 5y agoThat's just regular monarchy (with extra steps)
- colechristensen 5y agoLots of monarchies involved some form of picking the next king which went beyond inheritance or conquest.
- kergonath 5y agoI know the author is trying to be cute, but this: > the sole real seat of power is the office of the presidency is plainly wrong. The president still can lose their majority in parliament, they still can have an hostile prime minister, and they still don’t control the judges. There are many examples of the 3 powers slipping away from the president at various times after De Gaulle. A minority president is also becoming more and more likely as the candidates struggle and the parties keep shooting themselves in their respective feet. Not a great start. > The key difference of course is that in the US the President cannot dissolve Congress at his or her leisure. Dissolving the parliament, whilst a possibility, is politically very risky and quite often works against whoever is doing the dissolving (there are many historical examples in France and elsewhere). It is a threat, but a hollow one. It is quite similar to the motions of non confidence in that respect. > It was the last time a French parliament truly exercised its powers, on the cusp of losing them all. The parliament, of course, did not do itself any favour with the constant bickering, instability, and general ineffectiveness in the couple of years and decades before that point. Not that long before that parliament itself committed democratic suicide with Pétain. It’s a bit hypocritical to lament the shifting of the political centre of gravity in the context. > People know it is the only election that really matters, and they use it as an opportunity to count themselves, that is, the relative size and power of their parties or factions, and yes, to protest. This is also very debatable. Of course, some people think this, and it is reinforced by the popularity contest that the presidential elections have become. However, the cabinet is responsible for most policies, and who ends up there is determined by the legislative elections. The cabinet is useless only when act as the president’s foot soldiers, but they don’t necessarily have to. Anyway. The article mixes interesting takes and information with questionable interpretations.
- pjerem 5y ago> The president still can lose their majority in parliament, they still can have an hostile prime minister TBH, it’s now really difficult to have this setup now that presidential and parliament elections are scheduled every 5 years, few months appart. The people will give roughly the same parliamentary power ratio to the elected president than its election ratio. And most of the time, it will be even more because the President will do all it can to appear « good » on the first few months. And that’s understandable. You want to give the benefit of the doubt to the elected President and the schedule doesn’t let you the time to see which counter power is needed.
- remram 5y agoIs the role of the president really that disproportionate compared to other countries? The USA, for example? Recent presidencies, with their loads of executive orders etc really make me feel differently.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Is the role of the president really that disproportionate compared to other countries? Yes. > The USA, for example? The US has, among modern democracies, pretty much the strongest Presidential system. So, no, not compared to the US, in the same way that <extremely hot city> is probably not hot compared to Death Valley.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe President has a lot of power but it's not a problem and it works. What should be mentioned, especially to foreign readers, is that this topic is part of the left-right divide in France. It was De Gaulle (an army General) who came up with the current system while the preceding system, favoured by the left, was parliamentary. The left favours a parliamentary system that they claim is "more democratic" while depicting the current one as "elective monarchy" that perpetuates the "myth of the strong leader" (Napoleon, De Gaulle). Supporters of the current system point out that it does have balances and limits and that it brought stability (the preceding parliamentary system used to be very unstable, a bit like in Italy nowadays).
- southerntofu 5y ago> The President has a lot of power but it's not a problem and it works. By what metrics does it work? I could point half a dozen metrics by which it does not work. > it does have balances and limits In theory yes. In practice, though? All former presidents have been involved in illegal activities ranging from severe corruption to murder and crimes against humanity. Can you name one who had to stand trial?
- fredestine 5y agonope. European Union ( Germany which translate to USA) dictate France what to do using European laws. National politics and President Power in Europe all lean toward the same thing, new social measures that affect only a fraction of the population (same-sex marriage, positive discrimination). On the social side this is nice and good for those people. On the nation scale it doesn't change anything about average income, industries going abroad while pushing to welcome more immigrants that become jobless due to the loss of our industries, the 1% getting more and more of the cake.
- oliv__ 5y agoEmmanuel Macron's "reelection" you say? I highly doubt it.
- glandium 5y agoI'm a French person living abroad. I hadn't looked at the French political landscape until I recently took a quick look to somewhat prepare for the next presidential elections. And well, it looks like that's how it's going to play out, with no left candidate having any amount of significant popularity, and the extreme right having not one but two candidates that both trump the other candidates on the right. And Macron being the most popular candidate overall. Unless things change significantly in the next 6 months, it's going to be the same second round as 2017.
- di4na 5y agoThere is one possibility for a different scenario if LR (the historical Right) manage to have a good campaign and a good candidate. 2017 they were cut short by some scandals, but this time maybe... I am not betting too much on it though, cause the past decade of discourse and policies proposition on the french Historical Right have made me go away from them quickly... They are quite detached from reality at this point.
- glandium 5y agoThe lineup for LR is not exactly inspiring. I don't see any of them standing a chance (although I don't know Juvin), unfortunately. Really, as I see it, the best case scenario would be Le Pen not being on the second round, but then Macron would still win.
- di4na 5y agoBertrand is strong in the polls and is known by the voters. Not worse than Fillon last time. Same for Pecresse. So who knows.
- southerntofu 5y ago
- albertTJames 5y agoMany inconcistencies and a strong bias thorough the paper. Not sure how this got upvoted on HN .
- southerntofu 5y agoI don't agree with the author on some points, but on a quick read did not notice inconsistencies. care to point them out to educate us?