3 ms·
Did you read the article? It is meaningless to "sort" names across countries. Most languages have their own sort rules, and some languages have multiple sorts
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Did you read the article?
It is meaningless to "sort" names across countries. Most languages have their own sort rules, and some languages have multiple sorts depending on the specific usage!
Sorting is almost never what you want.
Are you printing out a phone book onto dead trees? No? Then you do not need to sort names.
Just do substring search, and you've already got a UI that is 10x better than having people flip to 'A', then 'Aa' to get to 'Aaron', etc...
If you're about to say "but I need to define a sort order for a database table key" then you've made another mistake and also not read the article...
- emodendroket 5y ago> Most languages have their own sort rules, and some languages have multiple sorts depending on the specific usage! That is true. However, it's also obviously true that a sort order that tries to take all of these into account, instead of using the rules of the current user's language, is obviously useless, so I don't understand why you think it's a meaningful objection. Users are surprised and annoyed by an inability to sort names.
- mcphage 5y agoI guess I'm not too worried about sort order being incorrect, since it already is incorrect 99% of the time anyway—most programs sort strings "1" < "12" < "2", whereas that's... wrong. It annoys me several times per week, but we've all accepted it and moved on. Apple's OSes do it right, but that's about it—and even still, if you're in a shell, it's probably back to being wrong.
- jiggawatts 5y agoWindows Explorer gets it (mostly) correct also.