4 ms·
Tags (or other metadata) are: - A controlled vocabulary. This addresses the problem of numerous terms referring to the same concept, the same terms applying t
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Tags (or other metadata) are:
- A controlled vocabulary. This addresses the problem of numerous terms referring to the same concept, the same terms applying to different concepts, disagreements on spelling or charactersets, and standardisation or cross-references between multiple terms.
- Externally applied, subject to authority independent of an author or publisher. This addresses the problem of keyword-stuffing.
- Capable of referencing information not within a document itself. Its place of publication, earlier or later versions, cultural context, citations, amongst others.
- Can be applied to nontextual media: images, audio, video, data.
Tags themselves are not hierarchical.
Search is not introspective or contextual.
- Tomte 5y agoTags could be a controlled vocabulary, but in almost all cases they are free-for-all. Archive of Our Own has an interesting scheme, where authors tag their pieces freely, and volunteers behind the scenes enrich those pieces with tags that are indeed from a controlled vocabulary. (They also do other mind-boggling stuff: in those tags they encode all kinds of information, so that you can search for a Kirk-Spock love story where violence is involved and Spock is dominant, and so on…)
- dredmorbius 5y agoI could have been clearer, but tags, even in a highly informal process, *are supplied by the reader(s) or curator(s) rather than the author/publisher, at least in the context of organising one's own archive. In that sense, tags are, even if not highly structured, a controlled vocabulary. (I'm not referring to tagging that's provided by a publishing site itself, though yes, that's a fairly common practice. Tagging by a skilled third-party curator or librarian can of course be excellent.)
- civilized 5y ago> Search is not introspective What?