3 ms·
All else being equal on paper, the better their social skills the worse all their other skills will be since otherwise the guy with social skills would have had
by Jensson 5y ago
All else being equal on paper, the better their social skills the worse all their other skills will be since otherwise the guy with social skills would have had a way stronger career than the guy without and then they wouldn't be equal on paper.
The problem is the halo effect here. Candidate A has likely gotten preferential treatment throughout their entire life thanks to his social skills, possibly all the achievements they listed were just because they were good at talking and never had to perform in previous jobs? While if candidate B has similar achievements but acts like that then you know he earned them, since nobody would give such a guy a pass unless they knew their shit.
On average a new employer will rate the persons work the same as the persons old employers, since these are the same set. So if both the socially savy person and the socially inept person got the same rating at previous employers, then you should expect to rate these two the same as well. If in these cases your process prefers the first over the second then you will over select for social savviness and under select for technical acumen.
- xyzelement 5y ago> gotten preferential treatment throughout their entire life thanks to his social skills First, I am talking about communication skills, the ability to receive and present information. Second, this skills can be practiced and developed, it's not something you have or don't have. I assume that the person who is presenting well, does it because they put effort into it. Third, I don't get this "all else equal" thing. I don't have access to their rankings from their old boss, nor do I have reason to expect their old jobs required the same thing my role does. Maybe their boss "did their talking" for them. Maybe someone gave them a spec and they just implemented it without any back and forth. But that wouldn't fly here.