18 ms·
The data doesn't support that: The predominant, most prosperous, safest, most free societies have been the internationalist ones, in Europe, the US, Canada, Jap
by wolverine876 5y ago
The data doesn't support that: The predominant, most prosperous, safest, most free societies have been the internationalist ones, in Europe, the US, Canada, Japan, S Korea, etc etc.
There are strong hypotheses to back the data: Nationalism divides people at arbitrary borders, limiting their ability to travel, trade, and work together. Nationalists isolate themselves. We know well from economics that trade is best when it depends on economic merit, not on which artificial border you happen to live behind; it helps buyers and sellers - nobody will buy your goods if you don't buy theirs. Imagine science without internationalism. Imagine the IT industry - FOSS has contributors world-wide; the web was developed in Switzerland by a Brit, and shared by the world. Linux in Finland, etc.
In terms of security, the nationalists have only themselves; the internationalists have each other, such as the most successful and powerful alliance in history, NATO. Imagine the Cold War without internationalism in Europe, as the USSR took one small country after another. The free world's enormous advantage in military competition with China is that they have each other, they have allies.
Nationalism has a horrible track record, creating war and poverty, and the underlying curse, hate - arbitrarily, purposefully created - often by leaders using nationalism for their own power: 'be loyal to the nation, and I am the nation, I make the decisions'. Many, including Churchill, blamed nationalism for WWII (which is why the survivors built the UN and the predecessor of the EU).
The internationalist world has produced freedom, security, and prosperity at orders of magnitude beyond what humanity ever experienced before. It seems bizarre to me to trade that in for the old nationalist ideologies.
- notfromhere 5y agoThose states had strong national cultures but an internationalist foreign policy outlook. Most European countries are ethnic national states with one dominant culture. The only real not ethnostates are the UK and maybe...Bosnia? There are Different flavors of nationalism, but I don’t think you can lump them all as isolationist
- wolverine876 5y ago> Those states had strong national cultures but an internationalist foreign policy outlook. Are you using the past tense for a reason? And don't forget trade, the lack of passports or border controls in the EU, etc. > Most European countries are ethnic national states with one dominant culture. Don't forget Spain, Italy, and I'm sure we can come up with many more. Clearly they all have participated in the EU for decades, as well as many other international groupings. > There are Different flavors of nationalism, but I don’t think you can lump them all as isolationist It depends on how you define it; I was using the (implied, as I understood it) definition in the parent of my comment. If we define nationalism as 'roots for the Olympic team', then we are talking about something completely different.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoWhat data are you referring to, exactly? I think all the words you use are ill defined. Also, correlation and causation? Strong countries invade other countries and assimilate them, thereby becoming more multi-cultural?
- jollybean 5y agoA bit worse than wrong because your postulating 'data' that fairly clearly indicates the opposite of what you are saying. Also there are some serious misunderstandings here. China is 'a free society' and 'internationalist'? (Han) China has always been the opposite of 'free', which of course is a modern concept, that's not a judgement, just what it is. And they have not really ever been 'internationalist' only just recently joining the internationalist order, and vaguely so. But that aside: China, Japan and Korea, if we were to apply our reasoning objectively to them as we do ourselves, are objectively 'far right ethno-nationalist' states. They are technically, quite fascist. I wouldn't want to use that label in normal discussion as I don't want to trigger or flame war, but in all reality, this is the fact. All three have very, very strong national narratives about who they are, their origin, their superiority (to greater or lesser extent). They are ethnocentric culturally (i.e. a Black person in Korea might be very respected, but nevertheless considered 'not Korean'). Their religion, elite, and culture tie together, literally in Japan with the God Head Emperor, and in all three places elite families ruling by long held extra-governmental power networks. 'Samsung' is not a corporate formation that we would understand in North America, though Europeans might understand it a bit. Japan and especially China historically have conquered and assimilated vast territories in the vein of de-facto superiority, some of this goes on today in E. China and Tibet. This is not a condemnation or anything of the sort, it's obviously complicated, it's just what it is. But those nations are the furthest thing from 'internationalist' in anything but the modern, economic sense with respect to trade and some institutions. Europe, historically, has had fuzzy political lines, but they bounce around and generally land along ethnic borders. Yugoslavia did not break up into random political territories, rather, ethnic one's. Same with Hapsburg Empire. Same with Soviets. Etc. Scandinavia is not a hodge-podge: most of the ethnic Swedes live under the same flag. Not all, but most. Obviously, especially on the continent, it's not so clear - yes - German speakers are scattered a bit in Poland, France and Czech - but they are overwhelmingly in Germany/Austria. That there are lot of 'fuzzy lines' doesn't mean lines do not exist. "The internationalist world has produced freedom, security, and prosperity at orders of magnitude beyond what humanity ever experienced before. It seems bizarre to me to trade that in for the old nationalist ideologies." This statement implies a misunderstanding of what 'Internationalist Order' and what it means. The 'Internationalist Order' is literally about 'Nation States' cooperating in some reasonable, common ground for trade and security. If anything, that 'order' is predicate upon the very notion of Nation States, it's literally part of the definition. 'The International Order' reinforces the notion of Nation State, and indirectly, nationalism. It's literally in the word: 'Inter'+'Nationalist'. Canada, US and Brazil are probably the leading examples of what 'pure' nation states are, i.e. not fully ethnocentric, and culturally more plural. I do believe there are material advantages here, but 'net net' I'm not so sure they are in the long-long term, I think it's more of a wash. But even with that plurality 'Nationalism' is still quite strong: paradoxically (or maybe not) 'Overt Nationalism' is stronger in Canada and the US than it is in Europe, because of weak local social ties, it is actively encouraged in North America. Germans (and Han Chinese, Japanese, Koean) don't need a flag to know who they are, flag waving for them is something completely different as we learned in the last decade or so where they are finally allowing the 'don't wave flags because we don't want to seem like Nazis' taboo fade a bit. I think the OP you are responding to is essentially correct, but the future is so much harder to predict. Even as we travel more and are exposed to more, we have more well-defined and managed borders than ever before, and there are few places to just 'go to', so maybe there will be less diversity in change than there was before? It's so hard to say.
- iammisc 5y agoEurope, the US, Canada, Japan, and S Korea are all incredibly nationalistic to varying different levels. How do you know someone's a European? They tell you all about how Europe is better than America? How do you know someone is american? They tell you all about how great America's freedom is? Japan is one of the most nationalistic countries on the planet. So is South Korea. Your claim that these countries are 'internationalist' is based on a flimsy understanding of their self-interested cooperation.
- wolverine876 5y ago> How do you know someone's a European? They tell you all about how Europe is better than America? > How do you know someone is american? They tell you all about how great America's freedom is? That doesn't match my experience of many Americans and Europeans. It also doesn't seem to fit a definition of "incredibly nationalistic". Incredibly nationalistic leads countries to wars and massacres, such as in Bosnia, Rwanda, Germany in WWII, etc. The EU and the US aren't going to war or massacring anyone. The term 'European' is a strong sign of modern internationalism.
- LogonType10 5y ago>The free world's enormous advantage in military competition with China is that they have each other, they have allies. More precisely, their advantage is that they have America, whose political polarization is being hastened by internal and external actors every day.
- wolverine876 5y agoThat is the basis of the international order since WWII based on the US economic resources (~50% of the world GDP around 1945, IIRC). But Europe and others have come a long way since then, work together (e.g., the EU!), and could clearly support themselves.
- LogonType10 5y agoIt's really too bad you can't win wars with printed money.
- dash2 5y agoThat’s exactly what the US did in WWII. And Britain in the C18.
- rsj_hn 5y agoEveryone suspended convertibility during WW1. The U.S. also in the Civil War.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhat wars have been won without it since the gold standard was abandoned?
- redis_mlc 5y ago[dead]
- systemvoltage 5y agoThis is a wishful idea and on the surface very captivating. The problem is that of doves and hawks in the social dynamics and evolutionary theory. Referencing Richard Dawkins' thesis, population comprising of only doves - this internationalist world view - would lend itself to extremely high probability of hawks rising to exploit. A single hawk has so much advantage that it leap frogs the doves in population growth. The total equilibrium of the population shifts from mostly doves towards a hawk-dominant population. This balance oscillates over evolutionary periods. I suspect something like that is going on in the world of nations. 1970-2010 enjoyed great success in globalisation. It bankrupted American manufacturing industry, created the rust belt and asymmetrical trade practices exploited the dove-dominanet globalist society. Remember, even today, China does not allow western companies to exist independently. They're forced to work with a domestic 50/50 joint venture to operate in China. We're seeing a huge rise in authoritarian regimes and I suspect aforementioned imbalance is the reason.
- wolverine876 5y ago> social dynamics and evolutionary theory These are sophisticated words, but I the argument is about strawpeople (hawks, doves, "population of only doves", etc.) and provides no factual basis. The facts are that nobody in history has been more secure. > 1970-2010 enjoyed great success in globalisation. It bankrupted American manufacturing industry, created the rust belt and asymmetrical trade practices exploited the dove-dominanet globalist society The free world did extremely well in that period, including the US. It was the biggest, most productive, wealthiest economy in the world, 'won' the Cold War, and became the sole superpower, all as freedom and democracy expanded around the world. Of course it is imperfect, imbalanced, and could (and should) be done better. But it has been the most successful international order ever, with no competition in sight. Also, the rust belt began rusting back in the 1950s.
- rossdavidh 5y agoThere is, no question, such a thing as too much preoccupation with a national culture. But, the article posits that a national culture more or less evaporating, is not a problem. All of the nations you mention ("Europe" is not a nation) have had to fight to maintain their identity (and both Europe and Japan have relied on US military protection for a couple generations now). It should not happen often, and if you have too many enemies you are probably misusing or ignoring "soft power". But, if you have no national culture which you find important (enough to defend), then another nation will take advantage of that fact.
- krapp 5y ago> But, if you have no national culture which you find important (enough to defend), then another nation will take advantage of that fact. Modern militaries don't defend cultures - fighting for "American ideals" or because "they hate our freedoms" is just propaganda. Militaries defend assets, territories and wage war for national interests, and their ability to do so is entirely orthogonal to their nation's sense of culture, or lack thereof.
- the_af 5y agoI don't think it's orthogonal though. You can argue which are the true goals of modern war, and I may find myself in agreement with you, but you can't convince people to support a war "for assets"; not unless you convince them those assets mean something to them, their culture, their religion, their patriotism, their way of life, something. So symbolism and the sense of the "group" (culture) remains very important.
- Nasrudith 5y agoWhat "not wanting a goddamned military invasion" isn't enough of a motivation for defensive military? There is no need to go that abstract for actual defense as opposed to the old Orwellian euphemism in the Department of Defense.
- 5y ago
- the_af 5y agoIn what sense is Japan "internationalist"? Their culture is nationalist, and more closed to foreigners compared to other countries. In their relatively recent past they were outright xenophobic. It is my (possibly outdated) understanding that even today they make distinction between descendants of Japanese born abroad and the "true" Japanese, to the point they have different words to tell them apart.
- TheDong 5y ago> It is my (possibly outdated) understanding that even today they make distinction between descendants of Japanese born abroad and the "true" Japanese, to the point they have different words to tell them apart. And the USA distinguishes "natural-born american citizens" from "american citizens". The law in America forbids a foreign-born citizen from being president. Similarly, English also has a special term, a "natural-born citizen", to distinguish this difference. Having different phrases for two different things doesn't really mean much. By contrast, according to the wikipedia page on the subject (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign-born_Japanese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign-born_Japanese), Japan has no restrictions on foreign-born citizens. They can become Prime Minister and hold other political offices. The difficulties lie in gaining such a citizenship, not in what you can legally do once you have it. I do think there are valid points you could make about how Japan's policies and culture have resulted in relatively low foreign immigration, but the talk of "having different words for things" and types of citizenship doesn't further your point nor seem based in fact.
- Calavar 5y ago> The law in America forbids a foreign-born citizen from being president. This is incorrect. John McCain was born in a foreign country, but he was born to American citizen parents, which made him natural born anyway. Someone who was born to noncitizen parents, but born within the geographical US would also be considered natural born. The US definition of "natural born citizen" is a lot more flexible than what most countries will allow even for naturalized citizens.
- 5y ago
- LongTimeAnon 5y agoInternationalist is code word for "we can auction off our need for an underclass to other nations so we don't actually have to address their cultural needs"
- pphysch 5y agoYou are conflating internationalism with globalism. Globalists believe that the time of Westphalian nations is over and everyone should live in one big borderless capitalist utopia ruled by global institutions/MNCs. Internationalists believe in bilateral diplomacy and trade between sovereign nations, sometimes through international institutions like the UN. Internationalists value national sovereignty. The key difference is that the basic unit of internationalism is the nation, while the basic unit of capitalist globalism is the individual or corporation. Secondly, nationalism does not have a horrible track record. America was incredibly prosperous in the "big government" era of the mid 20th century. If 2021 USA existed in 1941, it almost certainly would not have effectively waged war across the Atlantic and Pacific. Once the global capitalists took power in the 70s, things have been going downhill every since. Nationalism got replaced with the fake performative "nationalism" of Reagan, et al. Meanwhile, strong nations are currently on the up and up. Much to the chagrin of the global capitalists.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Meanwhile, strong nations are currently on the up and up. Much to the chagrin of the global capitalists. The East Asian miracles were based on nationalist economic policies as well as strong nationalist policies more generally in areas like natonal solidarity, immigration policy, cultural output, etc. The last 20 years have been a golden age of nationalism in rising Asia, as well as a deepening globalism in stagnant Europe. Contrasting the two regimes is useful. GDP per-capita growth 2000-2019 (ignoring Covid slump in 2020): EU: +18% (0.8% CAGR) East Asia: +184% (3.1% CAGR) The next 20 years are going to be interesting. https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/gdp-per-capita https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/gdp-per-capita https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/EAS/east-asia-pacific/gdp-per-capita https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/EAS/east-asia-pacific/...
- pphysch 5y agoGDP growth of (actively) developing nations vs developed nations is not the best indicator here. Hard to compare. Instead, compare China with India. Two huge developing nations with similar post-colonial timelines. But their post-2020 fortunes could not be more different. India was racked with the largest protests in human history last year, and then got hit hard by the SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant. China contained COVID-19 spread and is politically very stable. What happened in the last 20 years? Simplification is that China took a hard nationalist route and sought to protect its sovereignty. See GFW. India remained very open.
- throwaway2077 5y ago>The internationalist world has produced freedom, security, and prosperity at orders of magnitude beyond what humanity ever experienced before. - wouldn't be possible without being under the wing of the US - most of them wouldn't even exist as independent states if they didn't have a nationalist period all that distaste for nationalism would vanish the moment some tanks had showed up on their borders. >Nationalism has a horrible track record, creating war and poverty, and the underlying curse, hate - arbitrarily, purposefully created - often by leaders using nationalism for their own power: 'be loyal to the nation, and I am the nation, I make the decisions'. Many, including Churchill, blamed nationalism for WWII (which is why the survivors built the UN and the predecessor of the EU). every country in both world wars was nationalist. even the USSR had toned down commie stuff for the duration of WWII - which they called "The Great Patriotic War" in defense of "motherland", by the way.
- wolverine876 5y ago> every country in both world wars was nationalist I think this overstates the similarity to the point of meaninglessness. It's like saying Bezos and I both have money, so we're economically the same. The US fought for freedom of Europeans (with some interest of their own). WWII was won by a massive internationalist alliance by the Allies, in fact - and that was the difference; nationalist Germany lacked the allies to match them; they were virtually alone; conquered countries are much different than free allies.
- watwut 5y agoThe US was well aware of threat to them. Had Germany won and really acquired whole Europe, it would be virtually impossible for US to defend themselves after. It was not about abstract freedom or distaste toward racism. The danger was very real.
- wolverine876 5y ago> The US was well aware of threat to them. Had Germany won and really acquired whole Europe, it would be virtually impossible for US to defend themselves after. > It was not about abstract freedom or distaste toward racism. The danger was very real. There were geopolitical threats to the US. The US could have defended itself physically - protected by an ocean and an enormous economy - but the belief then was that it would have been impossible to maintain democracy and freedom in a world controlled by the Nazis. Freedom isn't abstract, it is a very real thing that people have taken great risks, suffered, and died for over centuries, all over the world (and to great success - look at how many people are free today compared with just 50 years ago). And Nazi horrors certainly motivated Americans, far beyond 'distaste'. I'm not sure how you can say otherwise.
- bobthechef 5y agoWhat are your definitions for "nationalist" and "internationalist"? You seem to be using meanings which are not operative here or even meaningfully coherent. For example, nationalism doesn't preclude cooperation or even immigration. That would be some extreme form of jingoism and isolationism that rarely exists. On the contrary, it is cooperation between diverse groups that leads to more fruitful results because of the differences in perspective. Internationalism understood as a homogenizing force could only lead to global provincialism and therefore the destruction of the very diversity that allowed fruitful collaboration and exchange in the first place. In the case of the USSR, it backfired for a few reasons, one of which was the failure to impose a manufactured identity onto its conquered peoples in place of individual national and ethnic identities (ethnic identity came roaring back after its collapse). EU federalists are repeating the same mistake. "European" is not a real identity. No one would die to protect "Europe". No one speaks "European". It probably should come as no surprise that many significant figures in the federalist camp have communist pasts or sympathies (Barroso comes to mind; he was a Maoist in his youth). If you want to point to empires, then what you find is that they were ruled by a dominant culture. Sure, the empire may have been multi-ethnic, there may have been a good deal of cultural exchange, and that dominant culture may have included members of various ethnic extractions, but those members of the ruling caste were assimilated into that culture, thus becoming part of a certain "nation". The Romans actually had a process for assimilating people into Roman culture. E.g. if you were Germanic, then you might be sent to Syria as part of the Roman Legion to keep you away from other members of your ethnic group. This would force you to learn Latin and to adopt Roman culture (probably not a bad deal for a Germanic person overall). The ruling caste unifies the empire, but they can only do that by setting the parameters within which the other ethnic groups can operate. This is like liberalism. The idea that liberalism is "culturally neutral" is ridiculous. Liberalism IS a culture. It does not tolerate anything that conflicts with liberalism. All of this is to say that I'm not entirely sure the opposition as framed makes sense. But know that mass migrations tear apart societies and will only lead to catastrophe. The result will be a period of chaos followed by some formation of (potentially new) nations and empires in the wake of the old.
- wolverine876 5y agoI just read about Albert Einstein, who in WWI called nationalism "the measles of mankind." I hope these nationalists win the day and we can get back to world wars!
- paganel 5y agoI can’t get into the US as a tourist without a visa, even though I’m a EU citizen, not sure how internationalist the US really is. Maybe from the inside the perspective is different.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe US requires visas, therefore it is hardline nationalist? The US has free trade and (usually) an essentially open border with Canada, so does that make the country hardline internationalist? Which is it? Using extremes makes any analysis impossible.
- paganel 5y agoYes, restricting access to your territory to actual international people makes you less of an internationalist country, I fail to see the contradiction in that.
- wolverine876 5y ago> restricting access to your territory to actual international people makes you less of an internationalist country Now we've backed away from the US being hardline nationalist to 'less internationalist'. Still, the requirement is completely open borders? It gets silly.
- netcan 5y ago>> the predominant, most prosperous, safest, most free societies have been the internationalist ones... I'm not sure there are rules to this. A lot of the narrative depends on how we define terms, and the story can be told in radically different ways. For example, European and ME multiculturalism existed. The empires were multicultural, in various ways. Ottoman, austrohungrarian... Under these regimes, multiple national/religious/language groups coexisted in most major cities. Warsaw was barely 50% Polish at times. Istanbul 50% Turkish. Budapest, Etc. In this telling, nationalism, liberalism, democracy & republicanism are the same movement. They're the anti-empire, anti-monarchy radicalism that ended multiculturalism. Nations were became self governing. This was followed by population exchange, ethnic cleansing and worse. WW2 shifted borders and populations until we were left with culturally homogeneous "nations." Jews during & after the holocaust, Germans of Czechoslovakia, Poland, and other post war population shifts & cleansing. The Greek/Turkish populations "exchanges." Cyprus dividing, more recently. Yugoslavia violently breaking into nation states. Multicultural societies that existed, often for centuries, under imperialism. Under nationalism, democratic or otherwise, that multiculturalism came under attack. Much of the middle east current troubles, can also be seen as nationalism playing out after centuries of Ottomanisms. The multiculturalism of Bagdad, for example, is much diminished after every round of violence and war. Familiar story. Baghdad has been shedding diversity for a long time, as have many other post-empire cities. >>Many, including Churchill, blamed nationalism for WWII (which is why the survivors built the UN and the predecessor of the EU) You could also argue that the UN is a very strong pro- nation state force. The UN assumes that nations exist, everyone belongs to a nation state, that national sovereignty is supreme and that there are no other ways to be. You have to fit this framework to even exist, from the UN's perspective. In any case... in my (this time) telling the multicultural, international order was empires. The force that brought this order down was "liberalism," which also, generally was closely linked to democratic mandates, republic-seeking, national liberation. National liberty came at the expense of non-national liberty. I'm not making a case for empires. I'm just making a case for complexity of perspective. There is no "X leads to Y" in history.
- hoseja 5y agoAll that is meaningless when I come with a bigger stick and you don't have a stick at all and nobody willing to hold it.
- jhgb 5y ago> The predominant, most prosperous, safest, most free societies have been the internationalist ones, in Europe, the US, Canada, Japan, S Korea, etc etc. I can't speak about US, Canada, Japan, S Korea, etc etc., but Europe is the birthplace of the nation state. In fact the current state of Europe (such as for example the fact that my home country exists in the first place, and isn't instead a province of Germany or Austria) is a direct result of nationalism. > Imagine science without internationalism. Imagine the IT industry - FOSS has contributors world-wide; the web was developed in Switzerland by a Brit, and shared by the world. Linux in Finland, etc. A red herring. Dictatorships (such as USSR) censored international communication, but nation states did not.