3 ms·
I couldn't disagree more with this comment. No amount of getting your hands dirty and making mistakes teaches you how to learn from your mistakes, nor changes t
by isoskeles 5y ago
I couldn't disagree more with this comment. No amount of getting your hands dirty and making mistakes teaches you how to learn from your mistakes, nor changes the impact of the mistakes. You also progress much faster by learning from other peoples' mistakes, this is why written language is so powerful.
Honestly, I think your comment is okay minus the fact that you're trying to highlight such hard disagreement with a sentiment that people should read the fucking manual. Really, you couldn't disagree MORE?
There is definitely value in RTFM. There are cases where making mistakes in production is not acceptable, and progressing by "making mistakes" is a mistake on its own. I don't think the case in this article sounds like one of those, but they do exist (e.g. financial systems (think about people losing money on crypto exchanges), healthcare, or, say, sending rockets into space). In many cases, making mistakes is fine in test systems, but completely, absolutely, catastrophically unacceptable in production. Although, I refuse to blame the junior engineer for such mistakes, I blame management that "sent a boy to do a man's job" (apologies for a dated idiom here).
(As an aside, overall, I disagree with many of the comments here nitpicking the way the author solved the problem, calling her "clueless", etc. I really don't care about that level of detail, and while I agree the solution does not seem ideal, it worked for them better than the previous solution.)
- crispyambulance 5y ago> No amount of getting your hands dirty and making mistakes teaches you how to learn from your mistakes... Categorically wrong. Mistakes, failure, and trial and error are very much a part of developing skills. If you're not making mistakes, you're also not taking enough risks and thus missing out on opportunities for growth.
- isoskeles 5y agoYes, mistakes are required to learn from them, but making mistakes does not imply that a person will learn from their mistakes.