2 ms·
On what unclear basis the statement is legitimate 'One personally thinks there's absolutely no downside to X, so everyone who doesn't is an idiot' ?! Look: eve
by mdp2021 5y ago
On what unclear basis the statement is legitimate 'One personally thinks there's absolutely no downside to X, so everyone who doesn't is an idiot' ?!
Look: even when the statement is disambiguated as 'A personally thinks there's absolutely no downside to X, [and from that also thinks] everyone who doesn't is an idiot', no, A is not entitled to think that "people with different ideas are idiots". A is supposed to have had an amount of intellectual experience in the past, that has already clearly and inequivocally shown A that A is fallible, and has only limited information and a partial grasp of the world.
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoIn the same sense as "I personally don't think that the reason for hairloss is a dinosaur that comes visit overnight and pulls people's hair while they're sleep, and everyone who does [think that] is an idiot". People having a different opinion is not a problem. People coming repeatedly to outlandish conclusions based on the limited evidence is a problem. Even with "limited grasp of the world" et al which is tautology. These "but you can't know everything!" arguments only go so far.
- mdp2021 5y agoBut the «outlandish conclusions based on the limited evidence» represent a strawman: the problem is different. And it remains that the conclusions you have made are in your head and a substantial part of the rest of the world legitimately, according to their experience, came to different conclusions. That argument is just valid. Especially given the tautology. You may get misleading corroborations from easier evaluations and than fail in the critical ones.