4 ms·
"Unfortunately, the probability exists that a witness may answer these questions with something other than an unqualified “yes”. The hedging, evasive answer avo
by giantg2 5y ago
"Unfortunately, the probability exists that a witness may answer these questions with something other than an unqualified “yes”. The hedging, evasive answer avoids the truth ..."
Hmm, avoids the truth, or avoids the answer you wanted?
"The witness who “doesn’t remember” or “isn’t sure” about dates, times, distances, or amounts."
Witnesses are notoriously unreliable. It's possible these are valid, truthful answers.
- whatshisface 5y agoThis is written for a lawyer who's on a side, not a curious investigator that's trying to maximize their own knowledge of the truth.
- giantg2 5y agoExactly. The lawyer/author is presenting themselves in the light of seeking the truth. Maybe they actually believe it themself, but it's not a unbiased view. "... a curious investigator that's trying to maximize their own knowledge of the truth." Do we actually have anything like this in the 'justice' system? Lawyers are on sides. Police only investigate to prove guilt, not innocence (most of the time). Judges are basically referees. Juries don't get to investigate, only view what the court allows them to (and society in general has a bias against defendants). In my experience, nobody is interested in the truth.
- vladf 5y agoHow would such a thing like this exist in practice? Who would watch this watchman? When your goal is to "discover truth" as Chief Truth Discoverer of the DOJ the only way to audit you is with grander truth discoery.
- giantg2 5y agoI agree, if we are only talking about some official position/office. You could use things like transparency and metrics released to the public. Right now complaints against the judiciary and many other positions in the system are considered so secret that they wont even release them if the contain exculpatory evidence. The reasoning is that the secrecy is necessary to preserve public trust of the system, and the system itself is more important than any individual's rights or justice. We could evaluate the complaints, wrongful convictions, etc to create better procedures and policies to find the truth.
- elicash 5y agoI kinda wonder the opposite -- is this "adversarial" approach towards finding the truth, where you've got people assigned to make the best case for different arguments regardless of your personal feelings about it, underutilized in other arenas?
- giantg2 5y agoIt depends. Maybe I misunderstood you, but you seem to be implying that I am against the adversarial system. I am not. The adversarial system is supposed to produce the truth in a fair fight. In my opinion, the system does not allow for a fair fight. Usually the party with the most money can win. There is a lot bias that exists as well. The people in the system continue to grant themselves more privileges that those not part of the system. The system even situates itself to where it costs more to defend ones innocence than to just plead and pay a fine. One cannot say that our system provides truth or justice when it allows this to occur.
- elicash 5y agoNot implying anything about you. I used your comment as a jumping-off point for what I thought was an interesting question about whether this adversarial approach should be extended to other areas.
- giantg2 5y agoOk. I saw the "opposite" part, but didn't see anything that directly argued the opposite of what your comment was saying.
- elicash 5y agoYou're focused on the opposite end. Like, you're talking about the problems of the adversarial approach, but I want to focus on where it could be useful and not used today. Not "you have the opposite position as me." I don't blame you for assuming I was trying to say you're wrong about something -- usually people are trying to argue! I just wanted to shift focus because your comment made me think about something related, yet on the other end.
- hash872 5y agoA number of other developed countries have judges who serve a more inquisitorial role, they're not just neutral referees in the process. Up to you if you think that's better, I'm pretty skeptical of the power of the state so I really don't
- giantg2 5y agoIt would be nice if juries could ask more questions. Generally they are very limited in the ability to ask questions and the scope of the question. Even in the more inquisitive role, they aren't actually investigating anything - like finding new info or evidence.
- jancsika 5y ago> Do we actually have anything like this in the 'justice' system? Aren't there things like children's advocates in family court? Review boards at every level who check up on accusations against lawyers/judges/etc.? I'd venture to guess there are dozens of such entities sprinkled throughout the legal system.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't know that children advocates are really seeking justice. They are seeking the best outcome for the kids. They also don't do any real investigating or truth seeking. "Review boards at every level who check up on accusations against lawyers/judges/etc.?" Do they? Do they actually do anything? I have experiences with these and they were mind blowing if you come in thinking they're about justice. Don't forget, they keep these secret because they want to protect the system, even if it means sending an innocent person to prison (no requirement to turn over exculpatory evidence even if subpoenaed). The Bar won't even investigate misconduct by prosecutors unless the court has already declared that misconduct occurred. I would really love to hear about one of the dozen or so boards or whatever that could help me right some past wrongs. Because I've gotten nowhere.
- jedimastert 5y agoRemember that this is geared towards representatives of a corporation, not persons representing themselves. These kinds of answers are almost certainly in a record somewhere.
- ghaff 5y agoA record someplace maybe. A record that I have? Often not. Ask me when I first discussed $TOPIC with someone or when I was briefed about $TOPIC or when I talked to a reporter about $TOPIC, I may have a date-stamped note, scrawl in my paper calendar, or an entry in an electronic calendar (assuming I'm still with the same company). But I may also have a vague recollection which no amount of prodding is going to crystallize or just no memory at all.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't see how this changes much. It's very possible they don't have those details recorded, or if they do they still don't remember them. Then they are just reading off of the notes. The credibly that is often given to notes is alarming. Sure, dated notes in combination with memory is good. But if there is no memory to go with them and no validation process, then it's possible there was a mistake in the notes, yet they treat them as truth.
- ghaff 5y agoMore times than I care to admit, I'll have some cryptic comment or action item in my calendar notes and I have to go back to the person I was talking with and ask: "What the hell does this mean?"
- DannyBee 5y agoThis person is not saying every person who forgets something is evasive. They are specifically talking about people who are being evasive (IE the facts are known, this person just wants to argue about it). There's a huge difference between someone saying "yeah, i got no idea", and passive aggressively doing the same constantly becuase they want to be cute. This is not talking about the person who occasionally forgets something. This is talking about a deposition where everything is a struggle because the witness is being passive aggressive. The difference is pretty obvious (in most cases) live.
- Gibbon1 5y agoI was on a Jury for a trial that lasted 2 weeks, dozen witnesses. I came away with the impression that there is what happened, what they saw, what they perceived, and what they remembered. And then memories change over time. Doesn't help that most witnesses are ambushed by circumstances. They're muddling through life when something untoward came out of left field. And so weren't forming long term memories.