6 ms·
Every device can do things behind the users back. Intel Management Engine runs even when the computer is turned off, contains a full blown operating system and
by DeathArrow 5y ago
Every device can do things behind the users back. Intel Management Engine runs even when the computer is turned off, contains a full blown operating system and has access to tcp/ip stack.
If privacy is a concern, no device should be trusted. By device I mean anything that contains a chip.
What's worse, people might suspect their phone or PC might be leaking data to third parties, but they will be less suspecting about their TV, their fridge or their car. But since anything is becoming smart these days, one can assume that anything that runs out of electricity is a potential privacy problem.
- jiggawatts 5y agoThe NSA specifically orders motherboards without these management components. No one else can typically get them, they’re not available to people like you and me. I think some things are overblown and unjustified paranoia. Other things? Justified paranoia.
- raverbashing 5y agoThe IME is just a "smarter than needed" addition, so it's probably not too hard to take it out But every PC has a SMC which deals with things like power-on, WOL, etc
- _kbh_ 5y agoYou can remove “modules” of the management engine but it’s responsible for booting the x86 cores so you cannot entirely turn it off.
- RalfWausE 5y agoMy approach as an practicing paranoic: Use retro Computers.
- coldacid 5y agoThis is the avenue I've started taking, myself.
- DeathArrow 5y agoHow much retro are we talking? If retro enough we can't use them for any modern use case. Maybe something like a RISC-V core written to a FPGA by yourself is pretty safe.
- RalfWausE 5y agoIt all depends on the one question: What IS your use case? Mine is as an tutor on an evening college, casual writer and some dabbling into some embedded projects. For THIS use case my (very retro) Atari 520 ST with 4 MB Ram is totally working. Is it nuts? Yup, but i can be sure that no state trojan is monitoring my totally boring behaviour.
- pphysch 5y agoTake this behavior too far and you might just sign up for more monitoring. "Why does citizen #2743652 have internet/electricity service with no registered devices or online profiles?" *Does deep background check*
- RalfWausE 5y agoNah, no problem: Just use some cheap tablet for a bit casual time in the "commercinet" (e.g. YouTube)... ;-)
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoYou can have both. * https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/Main_MiSTer/wiki https://github.com/MiSTer-devel/Main_MiSTer/wiki Combine retro with FPGA as you like(within the constraints of that development board). Or waste Watts by using software emulation.
- ranma42 5y ago> No one else can typically get them, they’re not available to people like you and me. Isn't that just setting the HAP (High Assurance Platform) bit in the ME blob to disable it after bring-up? For Intel platforms it is possible for the end-user to modify the firmware themselves in many cases. https://hackaday.com/tag/hap-bit/ https://hackaday.com/tag/hap-bit/
- csomar 5y agoShouldn't that be necessary if you want to boot your PC from the network?
- tentacleuno 5y agoRealistically, how many real people actually use PXE? It must be tiny. Seems strange to include what is essentially a business function in a product for normal people.
- saltminer 5y agoAny IT department that images devices, for starters. The number of people who actually use it is quite small, but the number of devices those people image with PXE is massive.
- tentacleuno 5y agoRight, but "IT department" falls under business use. I was talking about people who aren't technically inclined.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoI consider netbooting like drawers in the kitchen, where I grab tools according to task. Be it preparing meals, or actually eating. In a reversal of what you call business function, I'd consider it as my business to do what I want in my space when I want, how and where. That shrinkwrapped pre-installed OS/Appstore is just another business sector, which the masses have been conditioned into accepting. Convenient. But sometimes not, rather the opposite.
- cliffj 5y agoI think you were most likely right, coz you just reminded me one incident that I talked with my colleagues regarding solar power one day and just one day after that I received a cold call trying to sell me some solar solutions. There were 3 ppl in the conversation, I was the only one without solar at home and I was the only one received the call too. How likely that would be a coincident? Such things are so scary but what can we do? For most of the ppl, they cannot prove something like that happened. For me, I might be able to prove it but I cannot easily do it without significant efforts.
- gambiting 5y ago>>How likely that would be a coincident? People say this all the time but literally no one has been able to prove any kind of secretive listening-based advertising. The best explanation is that either you or someone else in your household has searched for something related and now it's appearing in your ads, or actually more likely, advertisers are incredible at linking cookies to actual users, and it's enough if your friend searched for solar panels and then his interests were associated with you. Like, advertisers can figure out all your friends have solar panels but you don't - so they show you ads for them. It's far easier to do than listening and to your conversations covertly.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoIf you have "OK Google" or whatever it is turned on, it is indeed listening to you. I've seen it with my parents. They will talk about it, not to their phones, but around their phones, and they'll start seeing ads for something they talked about. I've always had that featured turned off (I have to press the button), and I don't notice it. My wife also sees it with her iPhone with siri turned on. I talked to her about, for example, Jordan Peterson, and her phone starts blowing up with Jordan Peterson on Instagram. I dont think it's pure coincidence.
- gambiting 5y ago>>I talked to her about, for example, Jordan Peterson, and her phone starts blowing up with Jordan Peterson on Instagram. And why did you talk to her about Jordan Peterson? Is it perhaps because you read an article about Jordan Peterson earlier? If so, I assume you both share the same IP at home - so she starts seeing things you viewed or browsed. Facebook owns Instagram too, so if you look at something on Instagram it's not that wild that your partner's Instagram starts showing her things that interest you - it's just association. >>If you have "OK Google" or whatever it is turned on, it is indeed listening to you. Sure, and that's what I meant in the first paragraph - no one has been able to prove that this feature is sending your voice to Google/apple/Amazon servers unless you trigger the key word. Recording and sending voice would create some trace and no one has been able to prove this exist. That's not me saying it doesn't exist, just that for what is supposedly wide spread phenomenon, we have no proof it's actually happening other than anecdotal stories which can be easily explained by other means.