4 ms·
Whenever I think the Internet protocol stack is too complex, I take a glance through the (also freely available) 3GPP specifications to refresh my perspective.
by userbinator 5y ago
Whenever I think the Internet protocol stack is too complex, I take a glance through the (also freely available) 3GPP specifications to refresh my perspective. They are so thick and dense it's a miracle that everything works, and I remind myself that people came up with all of it and there are probably experts who know far more than I ever will about that area. Nonetheless, I'm not surprised that they are full of little-known features like this.
- dilyevsky 5y agoThey are likely thick and dense on purpose tho - the cartel doesn’t want more competition
- boppo1 5y agoWho even has infrastructure to compete?
- BelenusMordred 5y agoBaseband chips and sim cards aren't infrastructure, but you still can't compete because getting permission to run one on modern networks is financially well out of reach for most. This is why open source inspectable firmware simply doesn't exist for these things. All we currently have is leaked 2G and 3G source code for people to build their own off, most notable would be omsocombb
- exikyut 5y ago> leaked "License: Affero GPLv3 for all cellular software, GPLv2+ for some remaining software (libosmocore, OsmoPCU, OsmoSTP, OsmoGGSN)[1]" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osmocom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osmocom) O.o?
- userbinator 5y agoI think that comment may be referring to the leaked Mediatek baseband source. That is capable of 3G/HSPA+ at least, maybe LTE.
- simfree 5y agoBaicells will happily sell you cellular basestation hardware. Omscocombb isn't leaked code either, just an alternative implementation.
- GuB-42 5y agoI wonder how it compares to Bluetooth? No one seems to get Bluetooth right. The specification is more than a thousand pages, and my understanding is that 5.0 is an complete rewrite (but you still have to support previous versions).
- userbinator 5y agoBluetooth is, while still huge, tiny in comparison to the GSM specs. I've actually read the whole thing, although not in complete detail --- just out of interest; it's similar to WiFi (802.11). The GSM specs aren't even available in a single document. It's split into dozens of pieces. My estimate would be in the tens of thousands of pages in total.
- dilyevsky 5y agoIf I recall some parts of 3gpp specs were also “secret” or at least were when I worked in the industry. Now compare it with a Wimax spec from ieee…