3 ms·
A core purpose of a church is to identify and evaluate: 1. What a virtuous life is. 2. How to live one. 3. What examples exist of people who have lived one.
by roenxi 5y ago
A core purpose of a church is to identify and evaluate:
1. What a virtuous life is.
2. How to live one.
3. What examples exist of people who have lived one.
4. How practically achievable a virtuous life is.
The chaplain is doing his job here. He is supposed to identify that Floyd hasn't lived a virtuous life, but he is still part of a greater community and that a virtuous person would help Floyd live the best life he can.
> Non-white supremacists don't talk about the great replacement.
You bought it up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The chaplain is doing his job here. The Church in which he is ordained clearly disagreed, as the Archdiocese (not the school) asked him to resign as chaplain. Even assuming this is blameworthy at all, blaming the school for dismissing him is nonsensical.
- roenxi 5y agoIt isn't clear that the church actually objected that much, for all their statement to the contrary. It isn't like they defrocked him or anything. It is more likely that MIT asked for him to be sacked and they took a decision not to fight over it because it wouldn't be helpful. What the chaplain was trying to do here was entirely in line with how he was meant to act. I wasn't blaming anyone but it does seem quite likely that this action was driven by MIT rather than the church. The church hasn't fired him, MIT has had him moved on from their campus. The church is being relatively proportional about the whole business.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It isn’t clear that the church actually objected that much, for all their statement to the contrary. I disagree. Not only is it clear that they objected to his message, its clear from the Cardinal Archbishop’s own public message on the same issue two days before Moloney’s why they did. > It isn’t like they defrocked him or anything. Er, yeah, I mean no matter the severity of the disagreement, its not even the class of issue for which that is appropriate. It’s like saying DOJ must not really be upset at someone prosecuted for tax fraud because they didn’t seek the death penalty. > It is more likely that MIT asked for him to be sacked and they took a decision not to fight over it because it wouldn’t be helpful. It’s clearly the case that MIT brought Moloney’s message to the Archdiocese’s attention, and its pretty clear that the message stands in stark contrast to both the MIT President’s and the Cardinal Archbishop’s prior statements on the same issue. It’s not clear to me what even shadow of a basis you have for suggesting that MIT was upset but the Church viewed the chaplain as “entirely in line with how he was meant to act”.
- roenxi 5y agoSomeone thinks that this letter - which I cheerfully point out is not only race-neutral but preaching tolerance and peace - is threatening enough that they have to disassociate with the priest. He then disassociates from MIT. He is still associated with the Catholic Church. This suggests that the outrage is emanating from MIT, rather than the Church. > Er, yeah, I mean no matter the severity of the disagreement, its not even the class of issue for which that is appropriate. It isn't appropriate to fire him full stop, appropriateness isn't at play here. The problem is that it has been a number of months, the people involved were convicted and there is still no evidence that the Floyd case was racially motivated. And that is politically inconvenient for a vocal group of people. People who, coincidentally, are very much associated with MIT students and leadership.