4 ms·
> I still hold out hope Well, Helion did just get $500M in funding, and is very close to that design space. I have doubts about Helion being able to do it, bu
by pfdietz 5y ago
> I still hold out hope
Well, Helion did just get $500M in funding, and is very close to that design space.
I have doubts about Helion being able to do it, but if I had to invest in fusion it would be them (and just possibly Zap). Going beyond DT and recovering energy electromagnetically addresses the engineering/economic showstoppers that make things like tokamaks burning DT seem like a dead end.
- runnerup 5y agoWhy do you pick Helion over Commonwealth Fusion Systems?
- pfdietz 5y agoHelion is using a FRC (Field Reversed Configuration), which was what I was responding to. Also: Helion is taking a riskier physics approach in order to reduce engineering difficulty. I consider this a very good idea. Ordinary DT reactors make heat (80% of the energy comes off in neutrons, the energy of which gets turned to heat in a blanket.) Fission reactors should be able to make heat more easily and cheaply, so what is the point? Helion's approach, on the other hand, has plasma energy converted directly to electrical energy by expanding against a magnetic field. If this can be made to work, it means the non-nuclear side of a fusion power plant can be made much smaller (ideally, turbines/heat exchangers/cooling towers could be avoided entirely; realistically they could be made much smaller for a given plant power output). Their fuel choice (DD, D3He), while much more difficult to burn, subjects the materials of the reactor to much less radiation damage. There is a realistic chance the first wall of a D3He reactor could last the life of the power plant.
- ncmncm 5y agoTokamak, dead end.