4 ms·
There are basically two modes of operation where trains can really be competitive: a. Suburban-to-city center commuter trains stopping every two miles or so, v
by inglor_cz 5y ago
There are basically two modes of operation where trains can really be competitive:
a. Suburban-to-city center commuter trains stopping every two miles or so, vacuuming up all the people from the suburbia that want to get to the city without the hassle of endless traffic jams. These need a certain density of the suburbs, so that the stops make sense and the train is "just full", but not absurdly crammed.
b. High speed connections between metropolitan areas, like Madrid-Barcelona, Tokyo-Kyoto, Köln-Frankfurt etc. Usually, at least a million people must live on either end of the connection.
One of the problems is that these two services need separate tracks. Suburban commuter trains are much slower on average than high speed trains and they cannot share the same track, unless you want to risk chaos every day.
Unfortunately, few densely inhabited places in the U.S. have space left for so many tracks, especially in the wider city centers. A potential renaissance of rail travel in the U.S. would likely require underground tunnels. Which is possible (see London's Crosslink project), but not exactly cheap.
- ravitation 5y agoThe Texas Triangle has a higher population density than France, a relative abundance of space between major cities, and four major metropolitan areas... But it's private companies trying to build high-speed rail, not Amtrak. The idea that it's a geography problem, at least for regional rail lines, is not very compelling.
- reillyse 5y agoI think relatively speaking the US is not densely inhabited. So sure in densely packed places there is not much space (by definition) but then almost nowhere in the US is densely packed. E.g. between LA and SF it’s 99% farmland, between LA and Vegas it’s mostly farm or desert. What the US needs is political will and I think the political will in the US has been eroded (by bribes) by the petrol, car and flying lobbies.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoDC to Boston is basically one continuous urban area, yet we still don't have high speed rail on that route.
- reillyse 5y agoRight, we are in agreement. I think there should be rail in urban areas, but I was specifically refuting the idea that there was no room for rail.
- samstave 5y ago>>>a. Suburban-to-city center commuter trains stopping every two miles or so, vacuuming up all the people from the suburbia that want to get to the city without the hassle of endless traffic jams. These need a certain density of the suburbs, so that the stops make sense and the train is "just full", but not absurdly crammed. UHMmmmmm Cal train from south SF to say - moutain view on a bike was the worst... They would only pull a couple cars and only one of them would be a bike car. Many times had the bike car been full and I had been physically stopped from boarding the train with a bike... when there was clearly more room on the train's bike car - it was that the bike-hangers were full... I was late to a number of meetings because of this. Also - Rail is so poorly integrated that BART and Amtrak and Caltrain all have less than optimal intersecting stations.