5 ms·
Something I consider to be a "red flag" in the press releases of any new kind of energy source, power plant, or engine is when they start talking about the pote
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Something I consider to be a "red flag" in the press releases of any new kind of energy source, power plant, or engine is when they start talking about the potential applications of something fungible like electricity.
E.g.: In the Tech Crunch article linked elsewhere in this discussion there is this quote:
"Helion’s CEO speculates that its first customers may turn out to be data centers"
Do you know what else a 50MW generator could be used for? Anything. Anything that electricity is used for now. Why talk about things we all already know? Why talk about specific applications?
It's like a car company advertising that their new engine could be used to drive to Starbucks to get a coffee.
Once you notice this pattern, you'll see it everywhere in Free Energy / LENR circles...
- tlb 5y agoEventually a power source can power anything, but choosing good first customers is important. Usually, v1 of the product is expensive and flaky. So you need first customers who are willing to pay extra for the privilege of being early adopters, or for PR value. Data centers seem like a good bet here. As you get better at mass producing the machines, the cost will come down and you can make money selling power to the grid at much lower prices.
- jiggawatts 5y agoData centers absolutely do not go for unproven and flaky electricity sources! They go for the most boring, proven, and even downright inefficient sources. They need robustness above all things. Untested nuclear reactors (fusion or fission) are about as far away as possible from what they want as it is possible to get. Not to mention that many data centres are bang in the middle of high density urban areas, or at least reasonably close to them, typically in some industrial area on the outskirts of town. No council in their right mind would approve any kind of nuclear power without years and years of environmental impact studies, justifications, reams of paperwork, etc... You might argue that it's "safe", but the bureaucrats won't care about your opinion. They'll be worried about perception in an era where people set communication towers on fire because they want to stop 5G "radiation". Fusion is precisely the kind of technology that is best implemented as base load in a standard power plant type configuration. Far away from big cities and scaled for efficiency. It makes zero sense to plop something this esoteric down somewhere downtown to occasionally power a data centre during a rare power outage. This "suggested" use case is 100% intended to appeal to people like you, the "YC News" crowd type. It is absurd on its face. Hilariously improbable. But it sounds cool and it got you talking, so a successful marketing trick, I suppose.
- tlb 5y agoGoogle is big on solar power for its data centers, despite being intermittent. https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-1-6-million-solar-panels-will-power-these-new-data-centres/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-1-6-million-solar-panel... They also have grid connections, of course, so it's no problem if the energy source has frequent downtime. Some data centers are in cities but there are many remote ones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prineville%2C_Oregon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prineville%2C_Oregon is a small town with large Apple and Facebook centers. Fusion reactors wouldn't be used just during outages, but for base load, reducing consumption from the grid. They already have this sort of power supply/demand matching to support their solar arrays. Appealing to cost-insensitive early adopters is an excellent way to start. The Tesla roadster is a well-known example. I don't see the absurdity.
- idlewords 5y agoThe sun is not intermittent
- conradev 5y agoSolar power itself is intermittent, yes. But it is not a risky investment – quite the opposite actually. You can buy panels and inverters with 25yr manufacturer warranties. Maintenance costs are low and predictable (cleaning panels, replacing equipment). Energy output is as predictable as the sun, and in certain regions it is pretty constant. It is also not "costly" in the sense that the bulk of the cost of installing solar is the labor.
- glenstein 5y ago>You might argue that it's "safe", but the bureaucrats won't care about your opinion. They'll be worried about perception in an era where people set communication towers on fire because they want to stop 5G "radiation". I agree with all the other stuff you said, and I would accept this as a fair characterization of what is in store for nuclear plants historically. I wonder though how much of that experience would transfer in the event that we have real fusion reactions, given climate considerations and a novel technology that won't necessarily become entangled in the same narratives, and (maybe?) comes with a different set of environmental implications than traditional nuclear power plants.
- cormacrelf 5y agoYou would buy a few solar panels for your house at a few thousand dollars a pop, but would you buy a 50MW fusion reactor for your house, at the prices they'd be selling at? If not, there's clearly a continuum between you and the person they'll end up selling to first. They are rightly taking every opportunity to clarify to investors who their potential market would be. It has to be someone without vested interests in coal supply contracts and therefore the delayed success of your product, with a huge amount of money to throw at energy security, at a large enough scale for it to be worth a big start up cost. You also need someone to go first, because fusion is scary. This is non obvious. It is an essential part of their pitch, and no amount of cringe from people who know what electricity is is worth omitting it.
- jiggawatts 5y agoIf they can make 50 MW reactors at all, then yes, I will be buying the electricity from them. Not the reactor. The electricity. It goes down wires and is distributed nationally! I'm also not in the personal market for: Nuclear power, offshore wind, or gas turbines. Yet, I get electricity from all of those sources. If they can make one 50 MW power plant, then they can make ten 50 MW power plants. Put a nice little array of them on some cheap industrial land, hook them up to the grid, and start selling 500 MW like any other power plant. Easy. You can also get funding like any other power plant. Just turn up at a bank. Or issue shares. Whatever. If it works there's no need for specialised applications. It just needs to work! There is no need to "sell" their investors on the concept of electricity generation and usage. We get it. We all get it, in the most literal sense, right now. No need to talk us into it. They should be selling me on their capability of producing the thing in the first place, not its utility. That's much harder if they're faking it, which is why they talk about its utility instead. You know... if it works. If.
- cormacrelf 5y agoAgain, someone has to buy the reactor. They are in the business of selling reactors, not electricity. They are talking about who is going to buy the reactor. They think big companies who own data centres are going to buy the physical reactors. You are talking about something else entirely. > Helion’s CEO speculates that its first customers may turn out to be data centers, which have a couple of advantages over other potential customers. Data centers are power-hungry, and often already have power infrastructure in place in order to be able to accept backup generators. In addition, they tend to be a little away from population centers. They are definitely talking about selling them physical reactors.
- roenxi 5y agoIt isn't as strange as you might think. Electricity isn't perfectly fungible, so new technologies do get deployed to specific use cases. For example, solar panels got enthusiastic use in very remote areas even when they theoretically were more expensive than a grid connection. Because there was no grid in remote areas, and no population to support one.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]