4 ms·
> Assume (1) A -> B, (2) A is sometimes true, and (3) B is sometimes false. Then isn't it provably true that P(A | B) > P(B)? No, this is not true. Consider a
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> Assume (1) A -> B, (2) A is sometimes true, and (3) B is sometimes false. Then isn't it provably true that P(A | B) > P(B)?
No, this is not true. Consider a population of 200 people, with 20 in group AB, 0 in group A, 80 in group B, and 100 in group Nil.
We see that A -> B, since group A has 0 members.
We see that A is sometimes true, since group AB has 20 members.
We see that B is sometimes false, since group Nil has 100 members.
P(A | B) = 20 / (20 + 80) = 0.2
P(B) = (20 + 80) / (20 + 80 + 0 + 100) = 0.5
- feoren 5y agoThank you, you're absolutely right: I meant to say P(A | B) > P(A). By excluding !B, you're necessarily excluding only the Nil group. I think I got it right in my edit, but thank you for correcting my thinking here.