3 ms·
I see this pattern almost weekly with engineers (both online and offline). The hubris is fascinating. (Full disclosure: I was often guilty of this myself for th
by sokoloff 5y ago
I see this pattern almost weekly with engineers (both online and offline). The hubris is fascinating. (Full disclosure: I was often guilty of this myself for the first decade-plus of my career.)
- BirdieNZ 5y agoThe current discussions around Covid and vaccines made me realise I am continually guilty of this hubris. I've heard people say before "whenever I see a discussion on a subject I am an expert on, HN is full of ignorant commenters", but I feel it far more viscerally now. The first stage was: these anti-vaxxers don't have a degree in immunology, what makes them qualified to even attempt to interpret scientific papers on the subject? The second stage was: wait, I don't have a degree in immunology either, why am I pretending to be "following the science" when I don't have even the vocabulary or the context to properly grasp immunology papers? Accepting that I am a functional ignoramus with regards to Covid, viruses, immunology, vaccine development etc. is very freeing. I'm basically knowledgeable on very few things, and am not an authority on (vaccines|economics|law|history|basically everything). Being good at software engineering doesn't make me an expert at everything I read two articles on.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoBut you have expertise in at least one field, which confers to you an improved ability (relative to someone who is expert at nothing) to recognize expertise vs ignorance. This is, as I understand it, a fairly straightforward conclusion based on the Dunning-Kruger effect.