4 ms·
I have no idea whether this would work. I read the really great debate linked by another commenter, https://old.reddit.com/r/fusion/comments/qkvzjs/fusion_energ
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I have no idea whether this would work. I read the really great debate linked by another commenter, https://old.reddit.com/r/fusion/comments/qkvzjs/fusion_energy_at_cop26/ https://old.reddit.com/r/fusion/comments/qkvzjs/fusion_energ..., and while it was 98% Greek to me, was good to see some of the ideas and challenges.
Main thing I wanted to say is that we all love to shit on how Silicon Valley has basically gotten rich off investing in websites and SaaS products over the past ~15 years, areas which the Internet has provided a natural monopoly to the winner but haven't really been the type of "societal innovation" we've been craving. This, however, is obviously different, and if it works (a huge if), would be on par with the transistor in terms of societal effects. Kudos to Sam for swinging big.
- eldavido 5y ago> Main thing I wanted to say is that we all love to shit on how Silicon Valley has basically gotten rich off investing in websites and SaaS products over the past ~15 years 500 years ago, these people would've chased Jewish financiers out of strongly catholic areas, or shit on Dutch merchants getting rich in the spice trade. When it comes to human nature, things don't really change.
- finnh 5y agoThe Dutch East India Company deserves to be shat on, for eternity. Also I think you mean "Catholic", not "catholic".
- anfelor 5y ago> Also I think you mean "Catholic", not "catholic". Wow, I sometimes like to think that I speak English at a native level and then I learn about something like this.. Catholic: relating to the Catholic church catholic: including many different things She is a novelist who is catholic in her interests. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/catholic https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/catholic
- deltree7 5y agoIf they hadn't invested in SaaS, they wouldn't have had the money to invest in this.
- sbierwagen 5y agoI mostly didn't follow the talk about confinement, but I am slightly concerned about neutron activation. He3 fusion is more "neutron-light" than it is completely aneutronic. Operating at reasonable power levels, the reactor is going to be fairly radioactive after a few years. Widespread adoption of fusion is going to require the general public to be more relaxed about low level radioactive waste than they historically have been. The quotes about total system efficiency is also odd. "95% efficient"? They're not planning on capturing heat energy, so neutron heating is totally wasted, and they're talking about using entirely resistive 12 tesla magnets, which will also throw off a lot of heat.
- twarge 5y agoIt's not just a slight concern. - Fusion reactors are an order of magnitude physically larger than fission reactors, - The particle energies are an order of magnitude higher than fission, resulting in much nastier activation and that results in orders of magnitude more highly radioactive waste.
- sbierwagen 5y agoA fusion reactor vacuum vessel will be bigger than the core of a fission reactor of equivalent power, certainly. But I wonder if a better metric is containment vessel size: there's a lot of very radioactive, very contaminated equipment inside a PWR containment vessel that isn't the core itself. >orders of magnitude more Really? Wikipedia says "a typical large 1000 MWe nuclear reactor produces 25–30 tons of spent fuel per year". I don't see a commercial fusion reactor being quite that bad, unless reactor lifetime ends up being very short. Helion's promotional images keep showing the reactor vessel in a shipping container, which is narrowly true, but doesn't show the support equipment on the other side of a five meter thick concrete radiation shield. No vacuum pump near a running fusion reactor will survive long. There are all sorts of fascinating engineering problems for a commercial reactor. Photos of the Wendelstein 7-X show it covered with ports for sensors, which you couldn't do with a power reactor, because anything you attach directly to the vacuum vessel will be destroyed. It'll probably end up terribly ugly, the usual intestinal tangle of any industrial plant, a big spiky sausage with pressure sensors at the ends of long tubes to reduce their neutron flux. If you have to mount any sensor directly to the vessel then you use ten or twenty fold redundancy, since replacement is impossible. After five years of operation, if you go to replace a sensor on the vessel and the threaded fitting crumbles away when you apply the wrench, what do you do? Weld on another one? What's the weld heat-affected zone look like inside the steel after it's spent five years soaked in hot hydrogen, helium, and is richly marbled with transmutation products, dozens of odd elements you don't ordinarily choose to alloy steel with?