4 ms·
I can't wait for when decentralization fanatics will invent some kind of order that will very much look like the good old natural pyramid one can encounter anyw
by agumonkey 5y ago
I can't wait for when decentralization fanatics will invent some kind of order that will very much look like the good old natural pyramid one can encounter anywhere..
- forgotmypw17 5y agoThe major difference between decentralized pyramids and centralized ones is the size. The bigger the size of a network, the more attractive it is to abusers, while at the same time being more difficult to manage.
- evancoop 5y agoThat would suggest an oscillation - network effects to inflate network sizes, abuse, mismanagement, frustration, disruption, creation of a new paradigm. Lather, refactor, repeat?
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI don't think it is always the case. There are many networks which remain small and do not over-grow, but you are less likely to know about them. Typically, they are constrained by some limitation like being for an offline group or requiring a vouching process to join.
- skulk 5y agoIt already exists, the two ideas just haven't been been combined yet. I'm imagining a decentralized platform with StackOverflow-style reputation (higher score = more power) tracked in a blockchain.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 5y agoout with old, old is the new new
- nonameiguess 5y agoWhat you're imagining also (sort of) already exists. Credit reporting agencies, the Better Business Bureau, Yelp, Angie's List. They're "centralized" in the sense of reputation data is stored in a database with a single owner rather than something like a blockchain, but decentralized in the sense that anyone can submit reports, reviews, or votes. Importantly, a blockchain is not very fit for an application like this because it is append-only. That makes perfect sense for a transaction ledger, where you want immutable history and transactions are reversed by entering a new transaction with the signs reversed, but you really want the ability to correct a reputation history by actually redacting false reports rather than just appending a correction.
- photochemsyn 5y ago> "the ability to correct a reputation history by actually redacting false reports rather than just appending a correction..." George Orwell's 1984 features a main character whose job is just this: rewriting history by 'redacting false reports'. Of course well-meaning people will set up these systems without considering the potential for abuse. In many cases, persistence is desired - it does matter who said what when, historical written letters are important documents, and records of actions also form institutional histories. Normalizing the 'redacting of false reports' can easily turn into rewriting history for propaganda reasons. I suppose you could have a two-lane social media system, one channel where comments and posts were not anonymous and were recorderd for posterity, and one channel for anonymous ephemeral chatter. However, trying to run both channels on one platform might not work, legally or technologically.