6 ms·
Are there privacy organizations that can stop themselves from putting out unhinged, frothing-at-the-mouth press releases like these? I'd like to be aligned with
by jeffbee 5y ago
Are there privacy organizations that can stop themselves from putting out unhinged, frothing-at-the-mouth press releases like these? I'd like to be aligned with some privacy interests but I absolutely no intention of associating with anyone who would write this.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoRight - agreed - (you'll get downvoted here though - HN moving towards the reddit orthodoxy model vs the discussion model). Its super off-putting What about letting users control cookies browser side? No permission needed and total control.
- Nicksil 5y ago>Right - agreed - (you'll get downvoted here though - HN moving towards the reddit orthodoxy model vs the discussion model). >Its super off-putting Nothing about any of your comments on this topic has demonstrated you're the least bit interested in having a discussion.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoNothing has made it seem like anyone actually looks at any of this themselves. I've been following this a while now. Open a new incognitio window and go here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/privacy-policy/europa-analytics_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/privacy-policy/europa-analytics_en Do not click accept on anything. Check your cookies. Tracking cookies have been set before consent. Many on HN are ranting about how something like this is illegal or that the GDPR is easy. The answer is that the GDPR is NOT easy. That some would say that setting tracking cookies on landing without consent is not legal, others that it is, and the EU is all over on enforcement. If you browse an EU website, they track you without any explicit consent. I prefer this approach personally, all their websites used to have a modal pop-up, you could not move forward until you consented. Between phone, desktop etc etc, SO annoying. I'm sure it turned a lot of folks off GDPR, so they cheat with this to try and avoid annoying people (as many others do).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Nicksil 5y ago>Nothing has made it seem like anyone actually looks at any of this themselves. I've been following this a while now. This is you, mate. Look through your comments here; almost all are aggressive, confrontational, and toxic. Some of your comments make assertions with no supporting information and are subsequently dispelled. I can't tell if you're just trolling or are otherwise oblivious to your behavior. If you demand better discourse, practice it. >Open a new incognitio window and go here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/privacy-policy/europa-analytics_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/privacy-policy/europa-analytics_en >Do not click accept on anything. >Check your cookies. "Incognito" mode (or whatever one's browser may call it) is irrelevant in this scenario. This mode of browsing simply eliminates a subset of browsing data upon exit. Such a mode is useful for quickly navigating to some website you don't want showing up in your history or maintaining a session and that's about it.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoSorry for not being clearer - I will try to spell things out better. "Incognito" mode (or whatever one's browser may call it) is irrelevant in this scenario." No it is not. When looking at what a website does, if you browse in your regular session you may be bringing over a very large cookie store, visit history, prior acceptance of cookie popups. The reason I suggest using a new incognito session is because you start these sessions fresh from a cookie perspective, and the site you are visiting should see you as a new user and re-prompt for cookie acceptance etc. Then you can easily see what they are doing. It's really actually interesting being lectured and yelled at by "experts" here. I think the GDPR is sort of a bandwagon thing at this point. A fair number of relatively uninformed folks on the issues / technical side jumping on and making a set of fairly strong and often uninformed claims? You literally have folks saying GDPR is not complicated, and literally on the same threads making plenty of contradicotry claims (ie, totally illegal to not have a deny all button, totally banned to track before acceptance, ok to track before acceptance (default opt-in vs opt-out) etc. The folks claiming GDPR is easy don't realize how big a consulting industry has sprung up to try and help folks trying to get it right. I mean, tracking rules for the cookie acceptance cookies - is like perfectly up these consultants thing because they make so much money off all this.
- Nextgrid 5y ago> What about letting users control cookies browser side? I've tried to explain why this isn't sufficient in another comment above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29122525 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29122525 TLDR: GDPR covers more than just cookies and restricting cookies does next to nothing when it comes to tracking (in fact modern browsers already do restrict cookies by default, which is a pain to deal with as it does break legitimate usage such as cross-domain SSO).
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoThe issue though here is around consent pop-ups being found to violate the GDPR. I'm just pointing out that the pop-ups continue to be very complicated for folks to deal with. My understanding is that the cookie set by the consent pop-ups may now be classified as personal data, requiring a data controller, permissions etc. Or am I misunderstanding this latest twist? Shouldn't be hard to fix, but good lord if you are a smaller player. Just note, politically somehow cookies have become the big privacy boogeyman. Meanwhile personal data is harvested at HUGE scale (cable TV / smart TV/ ISPs etc) at least in the US without consequence. Ripoffs online are insane in quantity without much consequence. Major issues like DoS attacks go unaddressed and more. And because practically while the EU says ads and analytics are not essential, since for free websites they are in reality pretty essential, there is a lot of natural tension there. I am bummed about SSO issues now and modal cookie popups particularly on mobile etc. The other issue privacy folks are missing I think is focusing on this endless consent and reconsent on every website. I've seen data that 95%+ of folks click accept all. So you are delivering a product feature that annoys 95% of your target, it's a losing game. My own expectation, in long run this compliance overhead will help the mega platforms win out. They are the only ones (youtube / google / microsoft / apple etc) with the scale to really manage the years long investigations, million page doc requests etc. Ie, if you are going to put a video online, you are going to need to put it on youtube if you want anything analytic related to it. The other side is, vast folks ignore the law and just hope they won't be caught, or do a random (I accept) cookie popup and hope they are covered.
- skinkestek 5y ago
- Nextgrid 5y agoCould you elaborate on what you find problematic with their press release?
- jan_Inkepa 5y agoI'm slightly surprised by your comment. The release seems pretty factual to me? I too am sensitive to overwrought tech organisation prose (privacy/piracy/open source groups/basically anything to do with Assange) but this seemed ok. What about it strikes you as particularly unhinged? The main word I can find that seems like it might be regarded as over-emotive is "plagued". Is it that kind of thing? [ OTOH, bad GDPR popups are pretty much a scourge... ] edit: oh I guess the stuff about advertising firms depriving people of their "fundamental rights" is yeah a bit over-wrought...(though privacy is important, at least to me, and I think it's ok for a civil liberties organisation to care a lot about it).
- deworms 5y agoIAB isn't a privacy organization, it's an opposite of privacy organization.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe article link no longer leads to the unintelligible screed of the Irish privacy org.