2 ms·
And another quite different thing people do with "unsafe" is label code that is, from Rust's point of view, entirely safe, but which has important practical pro
by tialaramex 5y ago
And another quite different thing people do with "unsafe" is label code that is, from Rust's point of view, entirely safe, but which has important practical problems they want its callers to pay attention to.
Perhaps openHellPortal is complicated enough that you feel it should be a separate function. On the other hand, you want to be clear that nobody should expect openHellPortal to check the necessary precaution are in place. So, mark openHellPortal unsafe and provide a safe wrapper SafeHellPortal which internally calls openHellPortal after checking some necessary precautions are in place and ensures closeHellPortal is called when appropriate too.
As far as I know nobody builds hell portals with Rust (You have to assume there'd be a HN post about it right?) but they do plenty of embedded systems development, and those people use unsafe this way. Twiddling the SOC's interrupt controller is nothing to Rust itself, but the people writing the interrupt controller twiddling code can mark it "unsafe" and explain what callers must do to avoid chaos. Then callers can obey those instructions and make a safe wrapper for a particular purpose e.g. "SerialPort", and the average developer needn't even know that under the hood randomly twiddling the interrupt controller causes everything to catch fire, because they're using a safe SerialPort abstraction which can't cause that even if they hold it wrong.
- Hercuros 5y agoHaving "unsafe" mean "can wreak havoc if used incorrectly" is fine, as long as it's clear what constitutes incorrect usage, and what the behavior of correct usages is. And it does not have to be clearly defined what "havoc" is (just like undefined behavior can cause any behavior). My issue is with using "unsafe" to mean "watch out, you might be using this incorrectly, but no one even knows the exact rules that you should stick to to make sure your code is correct." Of course, having it be in the "unsafe" part of Rust is better than having it be in safe Rust. But ideally you would be able to look at any part of a Rust program and be able to tell what it does, without having to think in terms of specific compiler optimizations or hardware details. Otherwise formal verification of concurrent algorithms and data structures becomes hopeless.