4 ms·
Forgive me if I don’t want to read anything written by someone making an astrology product. I may be open-minded, but I have limits where it comes to people wh
by teddyh 5y ago
Forgive me if I don’t want to read anything written by someone making an astrology product. I may be open-minded, but I have limits where it comes to people who I know are trying to influence me into believing stupid false things to their benefit.
I mean, if they’re fine with claiming that astrology is real to enrich themselves, why should I believe anything else they say?
- odyssey7 5y agoMany consider astrology to be a creative and self-reflective process. Definitely would want to hear technical ideas from that kind of person. In any case, it’s up to the reader to decide where they will look for ideas and what they find valuable.
- teddyh 5y agoIn the current climate of censoring “misinformation”, astrology and its ilk should have been the first to go. Propagating superstitions and encouraging magical thinking is, if anything is, a destructive force on critical thinking.
- odyssey7 5y agoOn the other hand, astrology is decentralized and requires individuals to find their own values, and to actively interpret the meaning of things they read. I find that being this engaged with something enhances critical and creative thinking. And in the case of astrology, self-awareness.
- throwamon 5y agoOh, so it's just like philosophy and science, except without any philosophical or scientific backing.
- pxc 5y agoNo. Astrology is a somewhat mystified, ritualized form of useful reflexive and social activities, namely thinking about personality and long-term thinking about life decisions. Just like how a funeral at a church is a somewhat mystified, ritualized form of the useful reflexive and social activities of remembering and grieving.
- teddyh 5y agoEncouraging people to “find their own values” and to “actively interpret the meaning of things they read” , without any grounding in reality or science, will mostly result in people either growing more ardent in their existing beliefs (whatever they happen to be), or make people spin wildly out of control in conspiracy theories and/or magical thinking and superstitions.
- ashtonkem 5y agoEh. Astrology is obviously bullshit, but on the whole it’s much less harmful than other forms of misinformation. If we’re going to spend public and private credibility haggling over misinformation, I’d rather focus on the forms that have a much higher body count. I’m fine with leaving astrology in the category of “not subject to any moderation, but openly mocked by other commenters whenever it comes up”.
- teddyh 5y agoSure, there’s a scale to these things: https://twitter.com/abbieasr/status/1312512066071060480 https://twitter.com/abbieasr/status/1312512066071060480 However, it could be argued that small continuous amounts of superstition and magical thinking (like regular horoscopes) weakens people over time, so that they are vulnerable to the larger stuff (like essential oils) or even larger and more harmful conspiracies later.
- bcrosby95 5y agoAdd Santa and the tooth faerie to the list.
- markn951 5y agoWell... they're not really "making" an astrology product. They're an engineer "making" an application backend. It's almost kind of irrelevant what it's being used for in this context (a relatively technical discussion on the merits of a language).
- teddyh 5y agoSure, they might be honest about this – who knows? But anyone known to be peddling snake oil doesn’t get the benefit of the doubt. If they’re telling the truth, there will be others, more trustworthy, who can make the same argument.
- Nav_Panel 5y agoI know one of the founders, and she has a deep background in philosophy and psychoanalytic theory, as I do as well. Astrology as a contemplative and epistemological practice has deep roots; the idea that astrology is "real" in a physical causal sense goes back to Ptolemy and only persists because of the historical influence of the Christian church. I've written a bit on the topic here: https://listed.to/@simpolism/27322/what-is-astrology https://listed.to/@simpolism/27322/what-is-astrology As an engineer who's also studied a bit of astrology and has played around with how one might produce a description language to support the astrological symbolic apparatus, I think a functional language is a great choice. The idea of strict types defined as a set of symbols makes perfect sense in astrological terms. Although I'm much more familiar with OCaml/SML than Haskell, a basic outline would be something like: type Planet = Sun | Moon | Mercury | ... type Sign = Aries | Taurus | ... | Pisces type House = 1 | 2 | ... | 12 Using this, you could represent a whole chart in a pretty straightforward way. And then you could have higher order constructs, which represent meaningful formal relationships, like: type Aspect = (Planet, Planet, Degree) type Rulership = (Planet, Sign) etc. It's a pretty natural idea, to use a strong type system to represent what is effectively a formal language (astrology).
- whimsicalism 5y ago> I know one of the founders, and she has a deep background in philosophy and psychoanalytic theory, as I do as well. Astrology as a contemplative and epistemological practice has deep roots; the idea that astrology is "real" in a physical causal sense goes back to Ptolemy and only persists because of the historical influence of the Christian church. I've written a bit on the topic here: https://listed.to/@simpolism/27322/what-is-astrology https://listed.to/@simpolism/27322/what-is-astrology Sorry, how does this justify lying and deceiving people for profit? > she has a deep background in philosophy and psychoanalytic theory, By "deep background" you mean she got a BA in psychology?
- Nav_Panel 5y ago> lying and deceiving people for profit? Who here exactly is being lied to? Some people feel that doctors lie to them, so they don't go to doctors. Similarly, if someone feels like astrology is all a big lie, they don't have to use the app. > By "deep background" you mean she got a BA in psychology? I mean she's done quite a lot of reading on enlightenment and modern philosophy, can hold a conversation on Kant, Hegel, etc. as well as Freud, Lacan, RD Laing, and others. Humanities degrees tell me very little about the quality of someone's understanding.
- weatherlight 5y agoHow is this not flagged? > I don’t want to read anything written by someone making an insert religious/philosophical belief here product. I'm not sure the what's being built takes a way from the correctness of the way something was built.
- whimsicalism 5y agoWhy should it be flagged? Seems like a perfectly reasonable comment, just like how in day to day life I think less of people when I learn that they are religious.
- weatherlight 5y agoI'm an atheist, I say this because its against the hacker newsguidelines > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- IncRnd 5y ago> Forgive me if I don’t want to read anything written by someone making an astrology product. I may be open-minded No. You are closed-minded. The article explained three reasons why Haskell was chosen, not about converting you to believe in Astrology. FUNCTIONS IN THE MATHEMATICAL SENSE TYPE-DRIVEN PROGRAMMING HASKELL MAKES ILLEGAL STATES UNREPRESENTABLE This is the tl;dr from the page, where there is nothing about Astrology: "Haskell is optimized for developer efficiency. You can get a lot done, have a high degree of confidence that it runs reasonably without having to do too much thinking or ass-covering. We move fast & need things to be reliable. Rather than hand optimizing Doom 2 for ___, Haskell is the opposite. The computers serve us. Code is for humans to read, and only incidentally for computers to read. Code is how humans express themselves to each other and computers, and it’s up to computers to run it in a reasonably good way."
- teddyh 5y agoI have enough to read already. I choose not to spend my time reading texts by known con artists, whatever the texts may contain. If the truths expressed therein are valuable, someone else with more authority can repeat or re-discover them elsewhere.
- User23 5y ago> I choose not to spend my time reading texts by known con artists And yet you have the time to impugn other people's character here? I propose to you that your time might be better spent on your reading backlog.
- pxc 5y ago> I have limits where it comes to people who I know are trying to influence me into believing stupid false things to their benefit. The market for astrology already exists. Their whole thing is getting people who are into it to prefer them because their math is better. I get the anti-pseudoscience reflex, but (1) it's the wrong way to think about astrology and (2) it's weird to pick on astrology apps for their 'ethics' when the practice is more or less benign. We're not talking about a cult where people refuse medicine for their children here. From an employment perspective, Co-Star seems way cleaner than places where lots of people I know and like work. Better horoscopes than missile defense or spy drones or brutal retailers like Amazon. Better a stupid, fake typology than spyware that reads people's emails to hit them with more effective ads. Better to produce models of the positions of stars than models of human faces to power militarization of the Israeli border. Re: (1) Astrology as most people practice it is a low-stakes system of prompts for reflecting on oneself and one's environment in a way that is useful and healthy, but can easily be neglected when you're just trying to get from one day to the next. Taking it too seriously is a mistake, but it can be useful without being correct about the capacity of the power of heavenly bodies to determine human personalities or affairs. If we had nobles using court astrologers again, I'd say attacking astrology as harmful would be valuable. But when it's more about prompting for reflection or producing a shared vocabulary of personality, I think it ranges from helpful ritual to benign nonsense.
- onion2k 5y agoForgive me if I don’t want to read anything written by someone making an astrology product. Typical Capricorn.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads on generic flamewar tangents. They're tedious, predictable, and usually turn nasty. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- whimsicalism 5y agoI hardly think criticizing astrology is a generic tangent for an astrology company as per the rules.
- dang 5y agoIt definitely is. It's a cliché, threadbare topic about which people adamantly repeat platitudes they settled on long ago.
- teddyh 5y agoIf there were an article about Rust posted to HN from, say, the Church of Scientology, would criticism of CoS be disallowed? Some things should be called out when you see them.
- dang 5y agoYou need to understand what we're going for on this site: curious conversation. Curiosity withers under repetition and burns under indignation. Therefore, topics that combine a lot of repetition with a lot of indignation are not what we're looking for. They also have a habit of taking over an entire thread very quickly, much as fire consumes and spreads quickly through what it touches (which is why 'flame' is a good metaphor for the corresponding kind of internet comment). There are a lot of past explanations of these principles in case any of it is helpful: repetition is bad for curiosity https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20repetition%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... good discussion is specific, not generic https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=generic%20discussion%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... reflective responses are better than reflexive ones https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=reflective%20reflex%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... trying to avoid the internet callout/shaming culture https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=online%20shaming%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=a... (and so on)
- whoisjuan 5y ago> I may be open-minded You're not. If you were you will understand that astrology and other esoteric beliefs are culturally anchored to the human experience of many people in the world. In particular the self-development that many people seem to get from astrology. I don't need to believe in astrology to understand its cultural role. I think it's completely fair to build a business around a cultural idea and use that idea as a thematic glue to teach people about self-development and self-care. If you donwload the app, you will quicky realize that's exactly what they are doing. Personally not my thing, but I respect what they do and their approach to building a business around this.
- cbhl 5y agoYou may disagree, but I read this comment as a gendered microaggression and I hope you will reconsider your stance to be inclusive of this sort of content on HN going forward. I see astrology as an entertainment product. Some folks take it way too far, and it's fine if you'd prefer to abstain. But I think that it is the same as with other vices (porn, casinos, gatcha games, etc) who, otherwise, can have very interesting technical problems.
- teddyh 5y agoYou don’t know my gender, and the article has no author name attached.