3 ms·
Is "naturally gifted" the new "self-made man"? It seems so obviously self-refuting that I can't believe people use it without irony. Can anyone name anyone wh
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Is "naturally gifted" the new "self-made man"?
It seems so obviously self-refuting that I can't believe people use it without irony.
Can anyone name anyone who is naturally gifted at anything that didn't get taught and learn a million different things (not all of which they were good at) in order to get to the point where they could display their "natural gift"?
I say we take anyone's kid who they claim is naturally gifted and dump them on a deserted island shortly after birth and we'll see exactly how well they get on with their natural gifts. Maybe we'll come back in 16 years and they'll be doing calculus, speaking three languages fluently and playing the saxophone, but I doubt it.
After all, we wouldn't want them held back by the decades of parental care and schooling that we give to the normies who need to like, learn stuff from books and be fed for years and other such crutches for the feeble-minded lesser beings.
- ergot_vacation 5y agoWhat on earth are you talking about? Yes, obviously in order to make an apple pie you must first create the universe. In order to be gifted you must first be born, have a basic level of food and shelter, be mostly free of disease and so on. That's not a relevant point of discussion here. We're discussing a case where all things are equal. "But all things aren't equal!" You scream. "Those evil white people grew up in the lap of luxury while the poor, repressed minorities had a life of scraping, miserable poverty!" First, this isn't always true. There are poor white people and middle-class (or even rich) minorities, and to suggest that every minority is hopelessly disadvantaged because they all grew up in the ghetto is its own kind of racism. But second, this is a separate discussion. To answer the question "Are some people naturally gifted?" you have to adjust the other variables to equal first in order to tease out the answer to that specific question. Having discovered that yes, indeed they are, you can then conclude that this CONTINUES TO BE THE CASE in situations where "privilege" is not equal. The fact that some people are handicapped or helped by their economic or racial background does not magically erase the fact that they are ALSO helped or held back by their innate intelligence, and tendency to understand or not understand specific concepts. Some people are smarter than other people, in a way that has nothing to do with economics or racism, but is purely biological luck. In direct contradiction to your assertion, THIS is self-evident, in the same way that "Things fall to the earth when dropped". and "Eventually, everyone dies" are. To deny this is to deny basic, readily-observable and reproducible reality, in a way that suggests either disingenuousness or mental illness. Everyone is not equal, never has been, and never will be. It is an inherent property of the randomness of nature that some members of a species end up with abilities superior to others, completely independent of economics, race, social class, or any other human construction. Stop pushing this inane Harrison Bergeron gibberish.
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago> We're discussing a case where all things are equal. No, we're not.
- chakkepolja 5y ago> Can anyone name anyone who is naturally gifted at anything that didn't get taught and learn a million different things. Dude it's high school math not spring boot. Some kids have some types of intelligence better than others. If some part of intelligence was not intrinsic, we could be teaching calculus to rabbits.
- Viliam1234 5y agoIt makes almost as much sense as saying: "Do fish live in water? Nonsense! Throw a fish into boiling water and watch how it dies." If you throw a naturally gifted child into a volcano, or abandon it on a deserted island, sure, it will die. Therefore, no gifted kids, QED. But the standard assumption is that the gifted kids grow up in normal environment (and the fish swim in non-boiling water), and then do better in math that average kids growing up in the same kind of normal environment. The argument is "different outputs for the same input", not "excellent output for any kind of input". School definitely can (and should) be improved, including math education. But instead of making everyone equally good at math, the optimal kind of math education would make everyone better at math, and the gifted kids even more better.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYes, this is all fine, until the parent of the fish who gets sent to the ocean says to the parent of the fish sent to the volcanic geyser, "well my kid is just naturally gifted, that's why we put them in the cool ocean water, all you volcano fish were holding him back, I mean just look at your test scores". And then a fish says, maybe they're not naturally gifted, but just not poached, and everyone suddenly starts talking very specifically about fish in some alternate world that all share the same water. "What, are you saying there's no biological differences between fish, what kind of nonsense is this? If we explicitly assume there's no other factor involved then what is left but raw natural intelligence?" as if they're trying to miss the point intentionally.