4 ms·
Vague explanation of how their technology works here: https://www.helionenergy.com/our-technology/ https://www.helionenergy.com/our-technology/ I wish there wa
by rwmj 5y ago
Vague explanation of how their technology works here: https://www.helionenergy.com/our-technology/ https://www.helionenergy.com/our-technology/
I wish there was a good summary article of all the mainstream and alternative fusion approaches out there, like ITER, (SP-)ARC, General Fusion, Wendelstein 7X, etc.
- ethbr0 5y agoEverything is still either magnetic- or inertial confinement-based, right? And within those there are the variety of designs. I hate to say it, but a tiny part of me doesn't discount the possibility of energy majors subtley killing small-scale fusion approaches and pushing internation-scale huge projects (i.e. ones unlikely to be delivered quickly).
- OneTimePetes 5y agoHow else? Soundwaves or Lightpressure confinement? Diamond Anvil hammered?
- jacquesm 5y agoMost of the fusion energy we are consuming uses gravity for containment.
- ethbr0 5y agoIt's a proven method, but I have concerns about its scalability.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt scales just fine in the 'up' direction.
- omnicognate 5y agoUp to a point. Such reactors hit a size threshold above which they violently explode, leaving a dense, radioactive core that cannot be disposed of.
- gpm 5y agoI mean, that's just a failure in the EOL decommissioning mechanism of large instances, in terms of making them bigger, there becomes a point where it becomes difficult (or even impossible) to add more fuel [1], but they don't violently explode until the decommissioning phase. [1] https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/328/is-there-a-theoretical-maximum-size-limit-for-a-star https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/328/is-there-a...
- jacquesm 5y agoI think we can safely leave that to the next generation to clean up, like with all those other contaminated zones.
- ethbr0 5y agoWith all the extra energy, I'm sure we'd be able to find and budget for an EOL solution. After all, I'd be insanity to consume massive amounts of energy without accounting for its future costs.
- apendleton 5y ago> Everything is still either magnetic- or inertial confinement-based, right? Pretty much, but there are some that are kinda-sorta both (General Fusion's approach is "magneto-inertial"), and also a lot of variety within each bucket. Like, Zap Energy's approach is magnetic, but involves no external magnets, whereas developing the fancy magnets is a key operational challenge for CFS.
- hobscoop 5y agoThere's some interesting arguments in favor of the combination of magnetic and interial approaches. This is broadly known as 'magneto-inertial fusion', and there's a continuum of ideas between 'mostly inertial' and 'mostly magnetic'. I'd put Helion's approach far toward the magnetic side.
- foobarian 5y agoIt's interesting that they do direct electricity capture instead of the usual heat -> steam -> turbine approach. They also seem to be loaded with patents around this. I totally see why this investment might make sense and hope it works out.
- willis936 5y agoDirect conversion geometry was worked out a long time ago. The patents aren't very useful because the plasma temperatures that make aneutronic fusion attainable are far out of reach. If you can't demonstrate D+T then you have no hope for D+D or p+B11.
- sounds 5y agoThey're not doing direct capture of the He ion from aneutronic fusion. I'm not the best one to explain what it is Helion is doing, but it's not p+B11 -> 4He.
- randyrand 5y agoIn the timeline of Fusion I imagine 20 year patents will all be public domain by the time they're useful. In a sense, them patenting it so early is sort of a public good =)
- apendleton 5y agoI read Arthur Turrell's "The Star Builders": https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-Star-Builders/Arthur-Turrell/9781982130664 https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-Star-Builders/Art... a few months ago, and it gives a decent overview of many of the players and approaches, with the caveat that I don't think it talks about FRC reactors at all (what this and TAE are) at all from what I remember, probably because I think many people in the "mainstream" academic/government fusion community seem to not think it's a particularly serious contender. The general sense that I get (as a purely amateur observer but one who reads a fair bit about the various efforts) is that pretty much everyone thinks ITER will reach a decently high Q, but that it will take forever and be incredibly expensive, and that beyond that, of the people that think any of the startups have a chance (which seems to be a minority among fusion people but a decently big one), there's the most consensus around the potential of the high-field tokamak startups (so that's CFS/(SP)ARC and Tokamak Energy), because the physics is basically the same as with ITER, except facilitated by the much higher-strength fields allowed for by high-temperature-superconductor magnets; there are engineering challenges there still, but it seems like if the physics underlying ITER are sound and the magnets work (which has at this point been demonstrated as a stand-alone thing), the math all adds up. Stellarators (Wendelstein etc.) seem like the next-highest consensus: people seem to think the physics is sound, but it's less far along. Beyond that, other things seem to fall into one of: "the physics basis seems fine but the economics seem questionable" (probably most inertial approaches), "this has been considered at length and many believe this is physically impossible, but it'd be amazing if they're wrong" (TAE, arguably General Fusion, possibly also Helion), or "it'd be incredible if it works and physics doesn't forbid it but it's wildly novel and nobody really knows yet if it has legs" (things like Zap Energy's shear-stabilized Z-pinch plan). The overarching tldr is that it seems like the approaches that the most people think will work also have some of the most significant operational challenges if they do (breeding tritium, dealing with high neutron flux, etc.), which is why anybody is bothering with the quirkier approaches: if they work, they will probably ultimately work better than the tokamaks do, but they might not work.