4 ms·
I agree with the on topic point here - this food index doesn't really scream inflation (although it does scream tough times of someone). But... > Debt to GDP h
by roenxi 5y ago
I agree with the on topic point here - this food index doesn't really scream inflation (although it does scream tough times of someone). But...
> Debt to GDP has actually been declining since Q2 2020 and sits at ~125%. There is nothing that says increases are inevitable.
125% debt to GDP is well into the territory where countries do not pay their debts back in real terms. The US is a democracy, it is all but infeasible that the borrowings will be meaningfully repaid in full. Although physically speaking it is possible, if the US politicians thought that was feasible then the time to act was the 2000s. It is a bit late now. They've been at emergency debt levels (literally world-war level borrowing) for a decade now. Graceful recovery from that seems unlikely given the total lack of political will to do things the straightforward earn-more-than-spend way.
- pas 5y agoThere's nothing that makes that debt load scary, unserviceable, etc. the US can raise taxes anytime. It's simply doesn't have to. It can play the annual debt ceiling chicken game without any real impact on its ability to issue new debt.
- ptero 5y agoRaising taxes beyond a certain point tends to decrease the total tax haul as those with lots of money move income to other jurisdictions and some of others work less, leaning harder on social system (further increasing the public debt).
- pas 5y agoThe US is very far from that.
- ptero 5y agoHow do you know?
- pas 5y agoThe US economy is huge, people and companies are not likely to leave if the US increases taxes. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-do-us-taxes-compare-internationally https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-do-us-taxe... https://files.taxfoundation.org/20210517160849/The-tax-burden-on-labor-in-Belgium-is-seven-times-that-of-Child-OECD-tax-burden-tax-wedge-with-single-worker-with-no-children-earning-a-nations-average-wage.png https://files.taxfoundation.org/20210517160849/The-tax-burde...
- roenxi 5y ago> There's nothing that makes that debt load scary, unserviceable, etc. There absolutely is - there are a series of steps that will need to be taken to reduce that debt load. If anyone was seriously planning to see them through they wouldn't have let the numbers get that high. This is emporor-no-clothes levels of debt; the plan is not to pay it back. If the plan was to pay it back then the plan would need to have started more than a decade ago. Who is trying to do that? Nobody. The plan is inflation.
- ethbr0 5y agoThere are two things that make debt unserviceable: debt payments and cost/rate to take on new debt. Debt crises only happen when debt payments exceed ability to repay and the cost/rate to take on new debt spikes. Everyone fails to appreciate the second factor when looking at large economy, stable country debt levels. High debt:GDP ratios are dangerous, but not intrinsically a crisis... until the market also loses faith. Given that in the current international economic climate, the US can issue new debt, and find buyers, at <2%, that's a cheap way to buy time for even normal inflation levels to nibble away at debt. Ironically, now is the perfect time to deficit spend, in the same way it's a perfect time for an IPO. Why would you not take money, invest it in something productive, if people are screaming to give it to you at negative real rates?
- roenxi 5y agoThe US has been taking on new debt faster than inflation has chipped it away for around 40 years at this point. There is no evidence it is going to stop. If anyone who cared was anywhere near the levers of power it wouldn't have crossed 100% debt:GDP. Sure it isn't a crisis right now. But the debt will continue to grow and at some point there will be a crisis because either rates will spike, or government manipulation of rates will turn out to have killed off real investment and critical parts of the economy will give out. And in neither of those scenarios are the people lending the US money going to see all of it come back. Hopefully it is all lent by foreigners and not pension funds, that is all I can say.
- 5y ago