5 ms·
> There's no onboarding. No signup. No confirmation email. No OAuth. You're just in the product. You mean like pretty much every single darned productivity pro
by kazinator 5y ago
> There's no onboarding. No signup. No confirmation email. No OAuth. You're just in the product.
You mean like pretty much every single darned productivity program before year 200X?
It's sad that this even has to be an issue.
- Vinnl 5y agoAlso no install though.
- kazinator 5y agoAh, but this business of being prompted to create an account also afflicts software that requires installation.
- kavalg 5y agothey do have a docker image (no collaboration though)
- remus 5y agoIt's actually a pretty good example of a PWA which can be installed (depending on whether your platform supports it, works well with chrome and windows, sorta works on iOS but more fiddly. Havent tried firefox).
- Vinnl 5y agoIt can be, but I was mostly trying to list a benefit that the "good old" apps didn't have, i.e. not needing to install it. That said, I'd also misunderstood the grandparent comment: they meant that it's a shame that Excalidraw is one of the few apps nowadays that have these features, even if the other ones also have advantages like not requiring an install.
- jamil7 5y agoNo annoying drip emails “checking in” every few days.
- jesterson 5y ago"Hey, I know you are super busy but I just wanted to check..." Makes me want to ditch the product on the spot. Yes, I've seen your emails. Yes, I will let you know if I need anything. No, I don't need a zoom call/onboarding video/introductory convo with your marketing team.
- ballenf 5y agoDitching the product is probably the goal of the email, if the stats show that paid adoption happens within x days 98% of the time. What I think those stats miss is that I will test a product with one email and if I decide to buy for a team will use a new account. So it looks like the conversion happened immediately skewing their sales/marketing strategy.
- sytelus 5y agoYes, but they also don’t have to run series rounds, forced to grow 50% YoY, exit in 5 years and retire before they turn 30.
- dgb23 5y agoNot sure what you are comparing this against? --- First of all it's a free, open tool, MIT license, that is also hosted for free. It loads instantly without an installation step. You just type in the URL and it works. It's not a "productivity program" specifically as illustrated in the article. The design is very simple, intuitive and deliberately minimalist, while it does quite a bunch of subtle things under the hood that harmonize with the overall goal of the program. --- Now there may have been tools kind of like this in the 90's. Not aware of any of them from the top of my head.
- michaelt 5y agoI assume kazinator means: In Office 95, you click the Excel icon and it opens to a blank document with no login or registration or anything like that. As did drawing software, 3D modelling software, and so on. Of course, arguably one did have to pay for it and install it - but that was a one-off thing.
- samstave 5y agoDear god - anyone here have to setup licensing servers for high-end 3D software from the past, like Softimage or Alias|Wavefront - those were a bitch, and if you lost connection to the licensing server, you couldnt run the program.
- bayindirh 5y agoExcalidraw is akin to dia, but on the web. Also, it's more targeted and polished it seems, and that's nice.
- BjoernKW 5y agoPeople might be seeing this through slightly rose-tinted glasses. Yes, you could use Excel 95 by just double-clicking on an icon. However, not only did you have to buy and install the software, which back in the day often meant going to an actual brick-and-mortar store to purchase a shrink-wrapped box labelled "Office 95", but it even required buying a specific type of computer with a specific operating system first. In this specific case, that doesn't even take into account Microsoft's shady tactics of strong-arming vendors and OEMs into exclusively shipping Microsoft software with their products. So, arguably, the barrier to entry still was a lot higher than with even the most obnoxious growth hacking tactics we see in many SaaS products today. That said, I absolutely love the way Excalidraw are "onboarding" users. It's just worth remembering that not everything went downhill with SaaS products (in fact, quite the opposite) and not everything was better "back in the day".
- OneTimePetes 5y agoGoogle and Co really dragged this industry into the mudpit.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoYou mean that the companies making insane margins and paying top compensation are exactly the ones responsible for most of this this since they're massively profiting from monetizing consumers through various dark patterns, ads and spying? Shocking! Who would have thought? /s
- Ettaa 5y agoExactly, like good ol' times
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- watersb 5y agoYou can hurt yourself if you run with scissors.
- watersb 5y agoThe first "onboarding" I can remember, from Microsoft Word 6.0 in (?) 1993. It would display a dialog when you opened the program. Every. Damn. Time. Displayed a useful tip from the included documentation. At the time, it felt like a huge, complicated, OLE application, a big departure from the previous version, Word 5.1. I suspected that some members of the Word 6 product team felt the same about that startup dialog: at a loss to suggest anything productive for that "Useful product tip for today", they wrote down some inane safety tips. "Welcome to Microsoft Word... You can hurt yourself if you run with scissors."
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI sympathose with the author, bit I shouldn't have to scroll past that to find out what does the tool he is raving about actually do. This stuff can go below that
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI originally was going to sarcastically point out that this just means it's at the early stages of the process, when it needs to attract the power users and early adopters. Once they're on board they can start to annoy everyone and take advantage of the lock-in to attract more users while preventing current users from leaving. I then read that it was free and open, so felt bad, but did notice an ad for Excalidraw+, which basically means my cynical first take is likely to come true eventually, as that is what the market will optimize towards.
- simonh 5y agoOK it's pre-200x and you read about a new productivity app you want to try. You have to check it's compatible with your OS, figure out where and how you can buy it, wait for the diskettes or CD to ship or until you can visit a B&M store, run the installer, then manually enter a product key (fun!). You'd be lucky to have it all done in less than a week and a few hours of your time. How soon they forget!
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>You have to check it's compatible with your OS You still have to today. A lot of stuff is Mac/Windows/Linux exclusive. Sure, I can run Windows stuff on Linux and vice versa if I'm tech savvy, but Mac stuff requires buying Apple hardware, so that's a massive barrier right there. >figure out where and how you can buy it Or you could just download it. The internet existed pre 200x as well. > then manually enter a product key (fun!) Honestly, it was fun. Much more fun than the phone-home, always-on telemetry and invasive DRM that act like rootkits & spyware we have today. Good luck playing older games you bought and paid for who's DRM require authentication from the publisher's servers that went offline years ago. Yeah, fun! Back then, you paid for the product, you got your license and CD key, you owned it forever. No subscription rent seeking model BS. Maybe I'm just old and cranky.
- dhosek 5y ago> Or you could just download it. Outside of free software/shareware, there wasn't a lot of software available for download in the 90s. And compatibility was a lot jankier in that the base systems sold to consumers were insufficient to run a lot of popular software. For folks like you or me, probably not a problem (unless you happened to have a graphics card that wasn't supported) since we'd generally have obscene (by the standards of the day) amounts of hard disk and RAM, but Mom's computer might have 4M of RAM and a 10G hard drive. Back in the floppy disk era the thing that always drove me nuts was that most (with very few exceptions) software vendors put the software key on the label of disk 1. Which would be in the drive when they asked you to enter the software key. I remember some OS/2 software that put it on disk 2 instead and I wanted to go to the company and kiss whoever it was who decided to do that.
- gilbetron 5y agoI agree with the annoyance of so many modern tools and all the crap to use them, and appreciate ExcaliDraw for not doing it, but what is this talk of productivity programs being some sort of nirvana before 200x?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]