5 ms·
>We wouldn't have vaccines without some form of protection for scientists and their backers. Do you truly believe this? If we got rid of the patent system 5 ye
by charcircuit 5y ago
>We wouldn't have vaccines without some form of protection for scientists and their backers.
Do you truly believe this? If we got rid of the patent system 5 years ago. Do you believe no vaccines for COVID would be made?
- friedman23 5y agoNot who you are responding to but yes, looking at the history of MRNA vaccine research I believe that these vaccines (MRNA specifically) wouldn't exist without the massive payoff that could come from a patent. edit: my comment went against the worldview of some ideological drones and they decided to downvote me instead of actually responding. There is a reason that MRNA was developed in countries with strong IP rights and countries without those rights are relying on century old technology to develop their vaccines.
- adam_arthur 5y agoDon't worry, I was downvoted too! America has produced by far the most medical advancements in the modern era. What people don't recognize about the lower cost of drugs in countries like Canada is that they effectively have government price controls. If we were to do the same here, it would greatly limit R&D into new treatments. However, there are of course other ways to reduce cost to the consumer without harming the rich ecosystem of biotech. Important to understand this dynamic when adjusting laws, because it would be very easy to totally kill medical innovation
- burnished 5y agoI down voted you for the 'drone' remark.
- unityByFreedom 5y agoPatents are an exchange. I share my invention, you provide protection so I can recoup the costs of creation. Without them, there is little incentive to create, and much more incentive to rip off someone else's work. The result would be a reduction of technology that would put luddites to shame. If we got rid of the patent system today, there would probably still be vaccines 5 years from today because of the prior investment. But, in 100 years, the only people who could get vaccines would be the ultra wealthy, and 100 years after that we would lose the knowledge to create a lot of new technology because the old tech never sufficiently made it into the public sphere.
- adam_arthur 5y agoWithout patent protection, there's very little financial incentive to invent new pharmaceuticals. Anything you come up with could be copied and produced for pennies on the dollars by any number of companies. Of course, the cost to produce most medicines is quite low. So you have to invest a high fixed cost in R&D, at great risk of failure, and in the end you don't recoup any of that cost. When patents expire, you'll see many generics come onto the market at reduced costs, and cost to consumer goes down. Some other system could probably work, but free market R&D would fail without protections to profit from creations. I suspect trying to replace the free market system with some quasi-public one would not produce as many innovations.
- js8 5y agoIn the case of the pandemic, people have other incentives than financial. I don't agree, it seems to me that almost nobody who innovates does it for money, people do it for fame, curiosity, desire to fix a problem. (All progress depends on unreasonable men.) Rather, it's people who organize innovators who do it for money, and the question if they need to be renumerated in patents is legitimate.
- johncolanduoni 5y agoThe innovators in pharmaceutical research need large amounts of money to run the studies to show safety and effectiveness of their inventions, to say nothing of the even more hit or miss discovery process. It’s conceivable we could pay for that in a different manner than patents and high US drug prices, but that cost can’t just be handwaved away.
- schwank 5y ago"When patents expire, you'll see many generics come onto the market at reduced costs, and cost to consumer goes down." This assertion is simply not true. A prime example - Insulin is 100 years old. Those who need it are paying sky high prices due to corporate greed, and many simply can't afford it. No competition, no affordable option. People are dying due to this greed.