6 ms·
This means this project is abandoning open source and free software, as the Elastic License is not an open source license. > The Apollo developer community is
by sneak 5y ago
This means this project is abandoning open source and free software, as the Elastic License is not an open source license.
> The Apollo developer community is at the heart of everything we do. As stewards of our community, we have a responsibility to prevent harm from anyone who intends to exploit our work without contributing back. We want to continue serving you by funding the development of important open-source graph technology for years to come. To honor that commitment, we’re moving Apollo Federation 2 to the Elastic License v2 (ELv2).
One of these things can't be true.
It's really disheartening to see fake-open-source projects like this tout "the community" without realizing that taking software freedoms away (which is what this not-open-source license does) is ultimately an antisocial move. Being able to run a business off of a private fork of the software you gave away is not a bug, it's a feature. It's not exploiting anyone.
There are lot of fake open source people and companies around now. Docker Desktop, for example, isn't even source available.
Similarly, I personally view the AGPL as a nonfree license, although it's being pushed by anticapitalist zealots at the FSF who of course invented the notion of software freedom in the first place so my classification is, of course, controversial.
- ttybird 5y agoAGPL is both capitalist and socialist at the same time, depending on the developer. "Oh, you want to use my software for a nonfree internet service? Sure! You just got to negotiate a license with me :)" I can't see anything anticapitalist here.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoAs I understand it, it was never about developer's freedom at all. FSF puts user's freedom first and foremost. From that point of view, AGPL makes a lot of sense (even if in practice it is almost exclusively used as a poison pill to sell proprietary licenses).
- galaxyLogic 5y agoI believe that is right, AGPL is great for users. AGPL is a license, a contract between developers of software and users of that software. It gives certain rights to both parties. I think it is often implied that AGPL is somehow more "ethical" than other software licenses. I don't know why some people may think so and would like to hear the main arguments behind that. Is all copyright evil as well?
- wmf 5y agoThe AGPL requires contributing back more code which can be interpreted as providing more benefits to users. Plenty of software freedom advocates do believe that copyright is evil and copyleft is essentially using copyright against itself as a temporary stopgap until copyright can be abolished completely.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoIf you take any two software licenses they probably differ in some detail about what benefits they provide to users. What I don't get is why it is considered more ethical to provide more benefits to the users? Wouldn't Public Domain then be the most ethical license of all?
- jabl 5y agoThe hardcore free software position is that proprietary software is unethical, and while permissively licensed free software (or public domain) per se is fine, they allow such software to be co-opted to produce proprietary software. And thus copyleft licenses are better as they remove that temptation.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoRight proprietary software is the root of all evil, I get it, is some people's position. But what are the arguments that made them believe so, that proprietary software is unethical? How and why (do they believe) "proprietary software" is unethical?
- jabl 5y agoWell, I've been around FOSS my entire career, I've read a lot of RMS's writings, contributed to GNU projects, and to be honest, I don't know. Except that RMS got really really mad for not being able to fix a printer driver. I'm not sure free software philosophy would stand up to serious scrutiny from a moral philosophy perspective. One could argue that society as a whole would be better off if zero marginal cost things like software or poetry, or information in general, would be freely available to everyone [1]. But that raises the question how such public goods ought to be financed. In today's capitalistic society it doesn't seem like a very serious proposition. In today's world, the choice is often not between proprietary software for solving problem X vs. free software for solving problem X, but between proprietary software for solving X and no software that solves X. And I don't think society as a whole is better off by not solving problem X unless we have a FOSS solution. [1] Even that has limits. We probably don't want detailed instructions for making, say, biological warfare agents publicly available.
- wmf 5y agoCopyleft licenses like GPL are about user freedom, permissive licenses like BSD/MIT/Apache are about developer freedom, and COSS licenses like Elastic and SSPL are about freedom from competition.
- ngc248 5y agoaptly put .... freedom from competition license are pernicious and against "open source" whatever definition you adhere to. Just a wolf in sheep's clothing.
- jabl 5y agoElastic and SSPL are essentially source-available evaluation licenses for proprietary software. Which per se is fine. If that's the best business model for you, sure, go ahead and all the best to you. Just don't go and try to eat the cake and keep it too, by claiming you have some kind of 'open source community' driving your growth.
- ttybird 5y agoSSPL is a free software license, just like AGPL but slightly stricter.
- _msw_ 5y agoDisclosure: I work for AWS, but I am not paid by AWS to comment on HN on Free Software matters, on which I have my own personal opinions. SSPLv1 is not a free software license. It is constructed to have unsatisfiable obligations that, in practice, restrict how the program can be used for completely legitimate, legal, and ethical purposes. Because the obligations cannot be satisfied, the license restricts the freedom of the user, thus software licensed with SSPLv1 is not Free Software. See also the blog post from Bradley M. Kuhn, one of the main Free Software organizers who led the work to draft the Affero GPL and AGPLv3 licenses. [1] Additional disclosure: I (personally) am a Software Freedom Conservancy Sustainer [2]. Consider donating if believe in fighting for digital rights, including rights to repair and improve software. [1] https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2020/jan/06/copyleft-equality/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2020/jan/06/copyleft-equality... [2] https://sfconservancy.org/sponsors/ https://sfconservancy.org/sponsors/
- shawnz 5y agoWhen does a developer stop being a user? If I want to use an open source IDE to write some commercial software, is that user freedom or developer freedom? Is it within a user's freedoms to use a software for any kind of monetary benefit at all even if it has nothing to do with software development, like for example using an open source text editor to write documents for work? If so then what's the difference?
- madeofpalk 5y agoUser of the software vs developer of the software As the user of an IDE, I should be able to develop my own modifications for it. Any users of my modifications should also have that same right.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoread up on free software movement vs open source thing. you are only looking at "open source" when the argument being that the software should be free for users, not the developers in the middle. when i write AGPL code, i expect "end users" to be given source of that code in whatever circumstance they might get to use the software. now here comes a developer who uses my code, puts it in a private fork in your words and denies his/her users access to source code, what happened to my giving that dev license to use the code? what you are referring to us those MIT/BSD license where the developer is expected to heartlessly work to build software which can be forked by anyone, used in a proprietary code and users cant do anything about it. you are talking about freedom of the "developer" while free software people talk about freedom of end users. obviously "fake open source" is there because something like SSPL is not a "open source license" but it is in essense the superset of AGPL and that is what Free software guys want. you use this code, the users MUST get source, the dev has no say in that
- cassonmars 5y agoI’m not really buying the notion that SSPL isn’t open source, and the more I read the discourse around free software and the intentions thereof (_user_ freedom), I fail to see how it doesn’t count. I know a lot of folks love to quip that the OSI won’t accept SSPL, but they don’t get to control the use of the term since it was never theirs to begin with, and the source is absolutely open and available. The stipulation is that you can’t pull an Amazon where you get to play “I’m not touching you” games with the software by wrapping the service with value adds via proxy to escape having to contribute back. That feels in line with the intentions that classical distributed software like GPL intended, for that the emergence of SaaS enabled barn-door-wide loopholes.
- bayindirh 5y ago> Similarly, I personally view the AGPL as a nonfree license, although it's being pushed by anticapitalist zealots at the FSF who of course invented the notion of software freedom in the first place so my classification is, of course, controversial. I don't think that world should be licensed with A/GPL all over, but I don't think A/GPL is the second coming of Evil, either. I like the virality and values which GPL family of licenses stand for, and I personally support them. I license all of my software with GPL, and open source it like that. Why? I don't my code, intended to be open and free for everyone, to be modified and locked up for somewhere for profit, that's all. In other words, if I put out something on my free time, for leisure, I want it to be free for everyone. For profit work is different. I'm not a fan of capitalism, but I'm not an anticapitalist zealot either. I'd license my work with most permissive license the circumstances allow, and try to open source it with all the power I have, but it's not always feasible, I know. So it can be Apache/MIT, whatever in that circumstances. So, that's my point of view. Horses for courses, and I refuse to give my honest/hobby work to someone just because it's convenient for someone to integrate it to something closed source or for profit, regardless of usefulness/quality of the software.
- OrangeMusic 5y ago> is not an open source license To be honest, this is disingenuous. "Open source" has several definitions, and even though some people would like _their_ definition to be the "official" one, I'm pretty sure most reasonable people would still definitely agree that this project is open source, seeing that the entirety of the code is on GitHub.
- sneak 5y agoSource available != open source. I have the source to Windows, that doesn't make it open source. There are lots of projects with full source on GitHub that don't have a LICENSE at all, which means that despite having access to the source code you have no rights to store or use them at all (under copyright law). The definition of what counts as free software/open source was settled a long time ago. This isn't some pet crusade.
- peggyrayzis 5y agoHi from the Apollo team! We're not abandoning open-source software. Excluding our Federation 2 libraries, nearly all of the 100+ public repositories in the Apollo GitHub organization are MIT-licensed. Our most popular projects, including Apollo Client (Web/iOS/Android), Apollo Server, apollo-rs, and Rover, remain MIT-licensed. Federation 2, the component of our platform that is licensed under ELv2, is most interesting to large enterprises. Apollo has built a successful business that helps developers at large enterprises adopt a unified graph at scale. These enterprise subscriptions fund the development of important open-source projects like Apollo Client and Apollo Server that benefit the entire graph ecosystem.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> Similarly, I personally view the AGPL as a nonfree license Is GPL a free license? What’s the factor that makes AGPL nonfree in the way that GPL isn’t?