3 ms·
You missed a third reason: they are trying to cultivate a userbase that is turned away by open debate on some topics. For example, I'm familiar with a site cal
by shadowgovt 5y ago
You missed a third reason: they are trying to cultivate a userbase that is turned away by open debate on some topics.
For example, I'm familiar with a site called Hacker News that will castigate, constrain, and in some cases out and out ban users for political flame war. They don't do this because they're trying to hide a truth... They do this because it's not what that website is for. The site owners and operators seek a particular signal on the site, and political flame war just fuzzes up the signal to noise ratio from their point of view.
Is it authoritarian? Indubitably. But simply because some things are off topic.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoBut then this is not really any different from the second reason, because the chance of any given proscribed topic being true would average to 50%. Necessarily so because to ban the debate in that context is to ban both sides of it and averaging both sides of the same issue together will always yield 50%. Meanwhile you still have the non-zero (even if small) probability that they could censor something they want to suppress because they know it's true.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> and averaging both sides of the same issue together will always yield 50%. This is a strong assertion you keep making that doesn't hold water. The flat earth hypothesis, for example, doesn't become true simply because someone has banned discussion of it. Your assertion, unless I'm misunderstanding it, implies that any topic dang steps in to say "please stop posting about this" is true. And since he steps in to stop people discussing both sides of flamewar topics, your assertion implies that the positions held by both sides must be true, even when they are factually opposed, which is obviously impossible. There's definitely a flaw in your reasoning, sorry. :(