3 ms·
Your user name as of 11/4/2021 is cracell. This is a fact. Where is the flaw?
by tomrod 5y ago
Your user name as of 11/4/2021 is cracell.
This is a fact.
Where is the flaw?
- aspenmayer 5y agoThe one posting may not be the legitimate owner of the account?
- tomrod 5y agoRegardless of legitimacy of ownership, the person who posted or controlled the bot who posted had possession of the account at the timestamp stated.
- aspenmayer 5y agoTo my thinking, “your” implies legitimacy of possession.
- tomrod 5y ago"Legitimacy" of possession at a specific moment in time is a lot to read into the comment. Simple possession is sufficient, as it attributes the actions of the actor at that specific moment to the possessor, legitimate or otherwise.
- aspenmayer 5y agoThat may make sense to you, but it does not logically follow to my reasoning. It’s a logical leap and a bridge too far.
- iammisc 5y agoThis supposed fact ultimately relies on trusting the hacker news code and execution engine to behave correctly which is an inbuilt assumption to the stated fact. It's implausible to me that hacker news is broken but your fact is contingent on this other one, which is much more difficult to ascertain with certainty
- watwut 5y ago1.) I have seen people claim their subjective opinions are "fact" just because they expressed them authoritatively and with conviction. It is not rare, it is super frequent. And it is frequent especially in tech and adjacent communities that frame themselves as rational or scientific. 2.) With history in particular, selecting which facts you use makes massive difference. You can tell technically truth statements, leave out context and end up with a massive lie about what happened. You can switch victim and aggressor, make assholes into heroes and so on. Same exact effect is in economy and other fields, but with history it is super easily apparent.