2 ms·
The concept behind the overton window is fundamentally rooted in the statistical properties of large numbers of people. It's not about what might or might not a
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
The concept behind the overton window is fundamentally rooted in the statistical properties of large numbers of people. It's not about what might or might not appeal to a voter, it's about what might or might not appeal to a large number of voters, where the effects of statistics mask the noise inherent in their individual foibles, and things coalesce to give you a sort-of clear answer.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The concept behind the overton window is fundamentally rooted in the statistical properties of large numbers of people. No, its fundamentally rooted by the fact that the relationship between distance from an individuals preferred policy in any dimension and a candidates actual policy on that dimension and the effect on the individuals willing to vote for the candidate is nonlinear. The thresholding effect in groups is only because of (and is a function of) the thresholding effect in individuals.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWhat you're describing is real, but it's not called the overton window.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> What you're describing is real, but it's not called the overton window. Its usually not something worth discussing on its own, but I don't know why you wouldn't call the exact same thing that is called “the Overton window” for any other size set of people “the Overton window” for an individual.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoBecause the Overton Window isn't really about voting patterns or explicit support for specific policies. It's about a cultural phenomenon that constrains the cultural response to possible policies. If someone running for POTUS was to have suggested UBI in 1992 (say), they would have been instantly dismissed (probably as a communist). No voting. Not even much in the way of individual reactions, other than a few high profile op-eds here and there and sunday morning talkshow outrage. When Yang was talking about UBI in 2020, while he was not successful even in the primaries, the idea did not trigger the same sort of cultural reactions at all.