2 ms·
> More specifically, can you imagine your mind without language? Can you think, plan, or relate to other people if you lack words to help structure your experie
by kazinator 5y ago
> More specifically, can you imagine your mind without language? Can you think, plan, or relate to other people if you lack words to help structure your experiences?
Yes; for instance, when you use your mind to come up with how to rotate a sofa to get it around the bend in a stairwell, that does not really involve verbal/syntactic constructions, except for expressing the requirement at the highest level.
If you have to communicate the solution to your moving helpers, there will be a lot of hand gesturing, and use of pronouns. From an audio-only recording of the scene, capturing the verbalizations, nobody can reconstruct the manipulation of the sofa in even scant amounts of detail.
If people had to accurately document everything they do, every decision they make, in words, they wouldn't get anything done; they would be too busy editing words.