25 ms·
> And don't believe stuff just because FB and Twitter censored it. They're not trying to hide the Truth, they just hate anti-establishment opinions regardless o
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> And don't believe stuff just because FB and Twitter censored it. They're not trying to hide the Truth, they just hate anti-establishment opinions regardless of whether those opinions are true. And things are not true just because they're anti-establishment. That's just the opposite end of conformity.
There are two reasons people censor things.
One is that they're authoritarians who don't want something true to be disseminated. In these cases the thing being censored is true.
The other is that they're authoritarians too incompetent to convincingly demonstrate that something they believe to be false actually is false using evidence or reasoning, since otherwise they could do that in place of censorship. This level of incompetence is correlated with being factually incorrect, so the thing being censored in these cases is also true more often than not.
That isn't to say that 100% of things being censored are true, or even 99%, because that would be too easy. But it's not a bad heuristic to expect that it's decently in excess of 50%.
- civilized 5y agoThis analysis misses that most of what people spread is bullshit: things they intuitively feel or want to be true, but which are difficult or impossible to prove or disprove. When bullshit spreads that authorities don't want spread, they censor. Neither party to the dynamic knows or cares if the bullshit is actually true or if there are compelling arguments either way. That would be too much work. Some day FB is going to censor some urban legend about zombies because it motivated some kid to kill another kid. Will you believe in zombies then?
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYou're just saying the same thing. Suppose the incompetent authorities aren't worse than random. They're just censoring whatever ambiguous things they don't like independent of their veracity. Then the expected chance that it's true is 50%. Coin flip. You add to that any amount of things censored intentionally because they know for sure that they're true and you're above 50%.
- civilized 5y agoThe base rate of truth for stuff people spread is much, much lower than 50%.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoWhich we know because we had a public debate and gave each side a chance to make their strongest case. Wait.
- civilized 5y agoWhat debate do you want exactly? Two scientists at podiums yelling at each other? Nobody's stopping anyone from making the lab leak case and several people have published their best cases for it.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIs this something you're putting forth as not having a probability around 50%?
- civilized 5y agoIt could be, but censorship doesn't increase its probability. All it shows is the authorities don't like it. Your argument that they'd use facts if it were false is not relevant here because nobody knows which way the facts point.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThis is actually a pretty good example. Suppose nobody knows, so the probability is ~50%. Now suppose there is any non-zero percent chance that they did know and the reason it was censored is that they didn't want to inculpate themselves. Then knowing that it was censored puts the percentage above 50%, right? It's a sliver of evidence in favor of the possibility that it could have been censored to hide the truth, in which case there was a truth to hide.
- krapp 5y ago>The other is that they're authoritarians too incompetent to convincingly demonstrate that something they believe to be false actually is false using evidence or reasoning, since otherwise it wouldn't have to be censored. There aren't enough hours in the day to waste answering every single instance of bullshit posted to the internet with a thoroughly researched, evidence-based point for point rebuttal that would only be buried under another layer of bullshit.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThere are always enough hours in the day to waste answering every single instance of bullshit posted to the internet with a thoroughly researched, evidence-based point for point rebuttal that would only be buried under another layer of bullshit. This is the internet. It's full of pedants who do it all day long and then do it again tomorrow. It's the method by which we determine whether the thing is actually bullshit. Nobody is requiring you to read or participate in the arguments. If you only want to know the end result, get off Twitter and find someone you trust to summarize them and read their summary. But that's no reason to shut down the debate.
- krapp 5y ago>There are always enough hours in the day to waste answering every single instance of bullshit posted to the internet with a thoroughly researched, evidence-based point for point rebuttal that would only be buried under another layer of bullshit. Maybe for some, but most of us have actual lives to live. >It's the method by which we determine whether the thing is actually bullshit. No it isn't. Science and critical thinking is the way we determine whether a thing is bullshit. Pedants on the internet are its second biggest source of entropy after Bitcoin, but at least Bitcoin eventually finds a consensus. >But that's no reason to shut down the debate. Once it's clear the other side has no interest in debate, only in aggressively spreading misinformation, shutting down the discourse is the only reasonable course of action.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Maybe for some, but most of us have actual lives to live. You're here, aren't you? But also, it doesn't have to be everyone in order to work. > No it isn't. Science and critical thinking is the way we determine whether a thing is bullshit. I tried doing all forms of science in the entire world personally but it turns out I didn't have time, so some of it had to be handed off to quite a large number of other people and now we have to have a debate and evaluate each others hypotheses. > Pedants on the internet are its second biggest source of entropy after Bitcoin, but at least Bitcoin eventually finds a consensus. Science is a process, not a result. > Once it's clear the other side has no interest in debate, only in aggressively spreading misinformation, shutting down the discourse is the only reasonable course of action. Who decides this? What happens when they get it wrong?
- shadowgovt 5y agoYou missed a third reason: they are trying to cultivate a userbase that is turned away by open debate on some topics. For example, I'm familiar with a site called Hacker News that will castigate, constrain, and in some cases out and out ban users for political flame war. They don't do this because they're trying to hide a truth... They do this because it's not what that website is for. The site owners and operators seek a particular signal on the site, and political flame war just fuzzes up the signal to noise ratio from their point of view. Is it authoritarian? Indubitably. But simply because some things are off topic.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoBut then this is not really any different from the second reason, because the chance of any given proscribed topic being true would average to 50%. Necessarily so because to ban the debate in that context is to ban both sides of it and averaging both sides of the same issue together will always yield 50%. Meanwhile you still have the non-zero (even if small) probability that they could censor something they want to suppress because they know it's true.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> and averaging both sides of the same issue together will always yield 50%. This is a strong assertion you keep making that doesn't hold water. The flat earth hypothesis, for example, doesn't become true simply because someone has banned discussion of it. Your assertion, unless I'm misunderstanding it, implies that any topic dang steps in to say "please stop posting about this" is true. And since he steps in to stop people discussing both sides of flamewar topics, your assertion implies that the positions held by both sides must be true, even when they are factually opposed, which is obviously impossible. There's definitely a flaw in your reasoning, sorry. :(