4 ms·
How To Ask Questions The Smart Way
- diminish 15y agoirc guidelines enlighten our daily speech too ;)
- sukuriant 15y agoEspecially the 'ask to ask' over instant messenger, when you're known to be responsible for something. People giving polite introductions to themselves when I'm working annoys me greatly, as they're only saying "hi" to ask a question, and it requires that I respond to them and break my focus as they spend the next 3-5 minutes writing a question; whereas they could have just spent those 3-5 minutes saying in their IM: "Hi, I'm working on <X> and <Y> happened. Have you come across this before; and, how do I fix this?" And accomplish the same thing without wasting my time. </rant>
- iwwr 15y agoMake people work as least as possible and you maximize the chance of getting an answer.
- derleth 15y ago> least Your statement is correct, but the only word that works here is 'little'. English is a strange language, even for people who grew up with it.
- randomdata 15y agoFor best results, play on the emotions of technical folk. It is like the old saying: Instead of asking "how can I do X in Linux?", state "Linux sucks, it cannot do X!" Not only will people go out of their way to prove you wrong – thereby answering your question – but the resultant discussion will also provide insight into the problem beyond what would not normally be given in a direct response. The latter is often just as valuable as the answer itself. I don't really want to advocate the behaviour, but it is interesting to see how people react to each.
- majmun 15y agousually when i do the 7 steps described in "Before you ask" section, at that point if the question is not answered than nobody in the world will answer my question. So to conclude this paper should not exist.
- delinka 15y agoHear, hear! This is my usual experience. So I would think my question is one of those Good Questions, but alas it goes ignored and unanswered. "Where have all the hackers gone?" I ponder.
- tokenadult 15y agoThis is my usual experience. Are you able to provide links to previous questions you have asked? Perhaps that can help someone reply with suggestions that might answer the original questions, or explain why the questions were not answered back when you asked them.
- delinka 15y agoI tend to stick with IRC so I have no links. It has been difficult to change habits to using a site like stack overflow.
- chalst 15y agonobody in the world will answer my question - It sounds like you haven't been asking the right questions. You'd be surprised at who turns up to answer really good questions. All 7 steps are really overkill, but the first four, and enough of five ("inspection or experimentation") to apply what you find out from the first four steps, really are essential. The last two steps (skilled friends & source code) are really optional, and if you need to resort to these to find the answer, it is likely that your problem is interesting to the mailing list. It's worth comparing ESR's essay to SO's How to Ask page - http://stackoverflow.com/questions/how-to-ask http://stackoverflow.com/questions/how-to-ask - which asks much less of the questioner, and reflects the difference between mailing list culture and that at SO.
- Luyt 15y agoA classic. I also read esr's other material, like the 'Cathedral and the Bazaar', and the his views on the Halloween Documents.
- narag 15y agoA look at the section titles of the document reveals that a lot of effort has been made to put the advice in positive (do this) instead of negative (don't do that!), even if the document itself is clearly a catalog of donts. So it ends up sounding as if asking questions were a terribly complex endeavor, when in fact it just requires common sense and politeness. Problem is that if you're prone to commit those faux-pas, you're not going to read this document before hand anyway. Its purpose seems to be to direct offenders to it to make them aware of their faults.
- RobertHubert 15y agoBookmarked for later, thanks. But seems like an awful lot of trouble just to get asking right lol. From the comments seems like mixed feelings about this one.
- wccrawford 15y agoNo, most people agree that the article is correct about how to ask... They just disagree about whether the people who don't already know this will read it. You're kind of proving our point. :D Once you get into the habit of asking correctly, future questions are really easy. You'll have seen the results of asking the right question AFTER you have done your own research. You'll also have learned how easy it is to get answers to most questions without asking a live human. And how much faster, too.
- RobertHubert 15y agoI wasn't asking a question... Dont know how I kind of proved any point by saying I planed to educate myself by reading the article lol. I was just making a statement about others comments and the general appearance of the article. Perhaps if it looked more "friendly" more people who should read it would read it.
- maqr 15y agoThe people who most need to read this document will never read it.
- ryanbigg 15y agoI disagree. We have this as the !ask command in #Rubyonrails for when somebody asks to ask. It really improves the kind of questions that people would ask if you first ask them to read it. You can't just expect people to chance across golden nuggets of knowledge like this one, you must lead them there first.
- wccrawford 15y agoHeck, I LOVE reading, and I can't be bothered to actually read it. What are the chances that non-techies are going to read it, let alone actually follow it? From what I skimmed, the advice is spot-on... But people with a problem don't have patience. They need to fix the problem and move on. And the ones asking for free help on the internet are usually not willing to pay for it. (People who have already exhausted other means are the exception... But then, they're already following this document!)
- hm2k 15y agohttp://labs.phurix.net/articles/how-to-ask-a-question http://labs.phurix.net/articles/how-to-ask-a-question
- LeafStorm 15y agoThere should be one of these for "How to Open an Issue on an Issue Tracker the Smart Way." To get an account on an issue tracker system, you have to pass a quiz on it.
- lambda_cube 15y agoIn the section "Be precise and informative about your problem" of the article there is a link to Simon Tatham's (PuTTY author) "How to Report Bugs Effectively": http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/bugs.html http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/bugs.html I've seen several open source projects link to that document as well, so it might be what you are looking for.
- wnoise 15y agoThis might make it slightly easier for some of you to read this. The document is in UTF-8. There are two places in the document that say it's in UTF-8. Yet the server currently reports the charset as iso-8859-1. So that's what Chrome's autodetect uses... Jargon file entries appear to have the opposite problem -- server reports utf-8, but the file is in iso-8859-1, and it claims to be iso-8859-1.
- JacobAldridge 15y agoThat might explain this, ironic, section: "If you're sending e-mail from a Windows machine, turn off Microsoft's problematic “Smart Quotes†feature ... This is so you'll avoid sprinkling garbage characters through your mail."
- Benjo 15y agoRelated: Amy Hoy on "Help Vampires" http://slash7.com/2006/12/22/vampires/ http://slash7.com/2006/12/22/vampires/
- Triumvark 15y ago> What we are, unapologetically, is hostile to people who seem to be unwilling to think or to do their own homework before asking questions. People like that are time sinks... If people really thought of those questions as time sinks, they wouldn't bother responding. The aggravated forum response smacks more of a perverted delight in bullying the novice. And I understand the impulse. You've just answered the same question three times, and get it again? What gives!? Someone should smack these people! But if people are asking the same questions over and over, it's time to take another look at your search/FAQ/layout. If people are hostile to other people on your forum, it shouldn't be dismissed as "they just love challenging questions." It's time to fix your buggy culture. Someone should write a companion piece working on the other end. How to Answer (Stupid) Questions the Smart Way: 1. If hate customer service, let someone else handle it. 2. Provide the most efficient answer. 3. Don't question the question. 4. Assume good faith (to crib from Wikipedia). 5. ...
- niklas_a 15y agoThe internet has really progressed since that article was written. Instead of hackers getting angry at newcomers we have resources such as stackexchange and quora that filter up the top questions and answers and make them easy to find.
- angdis 15y agoThe article is simply a massive preachy FAQ with intricate advice that really boils down to common sense and good manners. And yeah, the people who lack the common sense to post good questions, are not going to ever read something like that. I think that the atmosphere and characteristics of the forum determines the quality of the questions more than anything else and especially more than any list of "rules" in the FAQ or front matter of the forum. There are so many crummy forums out there and only a small number of really good ones. Comparing the crappy ones with the good ones, I'd say that a forum can cultivate "good questions" by using some of the following techniques: [1] A good number of non-anonymous posters. If you have your name in the game, you're less likely to behave badly. [2] Active moderators who aren't afraid of yanking stuff or even requiring approval for each post. [3] Crowd-sourced up/down votes [4] A very specific topic.